Here are my thoughts on the situation:
- Send Kibo from Valencia to Beekse Bergen, while of course retaining Calimero as well
- Send Jambo to Cabarceno from Valencia
- Send Jums and Junmar from Cabarceno to Valencia
- Retain Shaka at Noahs Ark, for now
View below for explanation:
- Personally, I REALLY want Shaka in a breeding situation. He is a founder with no offspring, and is an absolutely stunning bull to boot. However that said, I would be reluctant to send him to Beekse Bergen myself, at least at this point in time. His attempts as a breeding bull in Vienna sadly failed, and while it sounds like the issues were more with the cows than Shaka, its still something to take into consideration. I do want him in a breeding situation, but I'm not sure where, at the moment.
- I think Kibo from Valencia would actually be an excellent fit for Beekse Bergen! He is still fairly genetically valuable (only 7 living descendants), is a proven bull with two different cows, and moreover, the fact that he is a fully mature, confident bull could factor in well to helping stimulate Calimero to breed.
- Jambo from Valencia? No. He is not a bull to use when time of of the essence to get a cow pregnant. He is still on the younger side, and not proven. I agree though, a move might be good for him. Going to Cabarceno, he could meet bull Yambo, who is similar in age (aka a good sparring partner), plus a number of younger bulls as well. Large open enclosure, lots of receptive cows, all the good stuff. Maybe he could finally fill out there and become a proper breeding bull.
- Jums and Junmar are a very successful duo, they seem to get on well with each other, are both well proven breeding bulls, and not particularly genetically valuable. Sending them to Valencia is an ideal choice. Best case scenario? They get their cows breeding and it's great. Worse case? Valencia still has the two bulls it seems to want, and even if they never breed again, there is no loss of genetic value since Jums has so many offspring already.
Also leave Tusker at Ouwehands. Yes, he is an excellent breeder, but like Menno said, there is no real sense in sending him to Beekse Bergen, since he should not be breeding with his daughters. Given how many male offspring he already has (and they are starting to become proven breeders themselves), I personally would relegate tusker to use as a "saviour bull", bouncing from facility to facility with cows that NEED to get bred urgently for whatever reason. Tusker is the perfect bull for that. He is already well represented, so its no real loss if things don't work out, he's a social, easy going bull, and very, very experienced with natural breeding. The perfect bull for that sort of situation.