Elephants in Major American Zoos

snowleopard

Well-Known Member
15+ year member
Premium Member
Gone are the days when it was practically a necessity for all the best zoos to have at least one elephant. Young children would collect pennies and donate them to zoo fundraisers in order to gather enough money to buy a single pachyderm. Zoos have evolved tremendously since then, to the point where many great zoos of the world don’t even have elephants in their collection.

The book that I cowrote, titled America’s Top 100 Zoos & Aquariums, contains reviews and photos of 80 zoos and 20 aquariums. There are 54 out of the 80 zoos that currently display elephants. The zoos with elephants are overwhelmingly in warm climates, mainly located in the southern half of the United States, although there are still a few zoos with elephants in colder latitudes.

The 54 zoos with elephants:

ABQ BioPark – Asian
Atlanta – African
Audubon – Asian
Birmingham – African
Bronx – Asian
Busch Gardens – Asian
Caldwell – African
Cameron Park – African
Cheyenne Mountain – African
Cincinnati – Asian
Cleveland – African
Columbus – Asian
Dallas – African
Denver – Asian
Disney’s Animal Kingdom – African
El Paso – Asian
Fort Worth – Asian
Fresno Chaffee – African
Honolulu – Asian
Houston – Asian
Indianapolis – African
Jacksonville – African
Kansas City – African
Knoxville – African
Little Rock – Asian
Los Angeles – Asian
Louisville – African + Asian
Maryland – African
Memphis – African
Miami – African + Asian
Milwaukee County – African
Montgomery – African
North Carolina – African
Oakland – African
Oklahoma City – Asian
Omaha – African
Oregon – Asian
Phoenix – Asian
Pittsburgh – African
Point Defiance – Asian
Reid Park – African
Roger Williams Park – African
Rosamond Gifford – Asian
Saint Louis – Asian
San Antonio – Asian
San Diego Zoo – African + Asian
San Diego Zoo Safari Park – African
Sedgwick County – African
Smithsonian’s National Zoo – Asian
Tampa – African
Toledo – African
Topeka – African + Asian
Tulsa – Asian
Utah’s Hogle – African

28 zoos exclusively have African elephants
22 zoos exclusively have Asian elephants
4 zoos have both African and Asian elephants (Louisville, Miami, San Diego, Topeka)

There are 26 zoos in the book that do not have elephants:

Akron
Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum
Binder Park
Brookfield
Buffalo
Central Park
Como Park
Detroit
Fort Wayne
Gladys Porter
Great Plains
Henry Vilas
John Ball
Lincoln Park
The Living Desert
Minnesota
Nashville
Philadelphia
Riverbanks
Sacramento
San Francisco
Santa Barbara
Tanganyika Wildlife Park
Virginia
Wildlife World Zoo
Woodland Park

What is interesting is that during the writing process of the book, between 2015 and 2019, there was a growing total that ended up including 6 zoos that phased out elephants during that time period. Buffalo, Nashville, Riverbanks, Santa Barbara, Virginia and Woodland Park are those zoos that all got rid of elephants in the span of a few years.

Now, the question is which zoos will be next to phase out elephants? I think that legitimate candidates would include these 14 zoos: Bronx, Cameron Park, El Paso, Honolulu, Knoxville, Little Rock, Louisville, Montgomery, Point Defiance, Roger Williams Park, San Antonio, Toledo, Topeka and Utah’s Hogle Zoo.

How many of those 14 zoos will still have elephants by the year 2031? Already almost all of those zoos are down to only one or two elephants, below the AZA minimum. If those 14 zoos all phase out elephants in the next decade, which is entirely believable, then that will leave only 40 out of the 80 zoos in the book with elephants. I honestly cannot see a zoo without elephants willing to spend tens of millions of dollars to add those animals to their collection, and so unfortunately the great elephant exodus from modern American zoos will continue.

The good news is that for the zoos that have committed to elephants, there has been a long list of superb exhibits built in recent memory for thriving, larger herds. Also, some zoos (Cincinnati, Tulsa) have ambitious plans for the future that are very exciting. For anyone wishing to visit great elephant exhibits in American zoos, I’ve created a couple of lists below.

A list of what are arguably the Top 10 Asian elephant exhibits in the USA (alphabetical ranking):

Columbus
Denver
Fort Worth
Houston
Los Angeles
Oklahoma City
Oregon
Rosamond Gifford
Saint Louis
Smithsonian’s National Zoo

A list of what are arguably the Top 10 African elephant exhibits in the USA (alphabetical ranking):

Birmingham
Cheyenne Mountain
Dallas
Disney’s Animal Kingdom
Fresno Chaffee
North Carolina
Omaha
Reid Park
San Diego Zoo Safari Park
Sedgwick County
 
Last edited:
Loved this read, the number is a bit smaller than I thought for major zoos with elephants, especially seeing the star power they have and allowing for funding of newer habitats. Cincinnati’s Elephant Trek is one that has my attention and wanting to see how it turns out. The “re-imagining” of Elephant Valley at SDZSP looks like a much needed renovation and expansion to that area, displaying their dynamic herd.
 
Is Nashville not bringing their elephants back? I thought their absence was temporary, but I could be misremembering or not heard more recent updates. I also haven't heard whether Virginia and Riverbanks phased them out permanently or are planning on returning them at some point.

I'd also be curious how many of those 14 zoos you named as mostly only having 1 or 2 elephants left (a higher number than I would have guessed) have already stated they are planning to phase out their elephants @snowleopard. I know Point Defiance and Bronx are, but I'm not clear on what the plans are for the rest of them.

Regardless of the specifics, the trend towards fewer zoos with larger enclosure complexes for elephants has been going on for at least a decade or two now and it's not surprising to see the trend will likely continue.
 
Of the zoos that have phased out elephants, the only ones I can realistically see getting elephants back are Brookfield and Nashville. Brookfield has always wanted elephants back but the funds have never been available. The zoo is well aware of the demand and they have always intended on having them return one day, but with a new CEO being brought on later this year they could have a completely different vision for what they want to see in the zoo, and that may not include elephants. When it comes to Nashville, elephants were notably left off the plan for the 200 million dollar African expansion and any mention of their return has been removed. It's possible that they still want them but don't want to make it public until they can ensure it will happen, as money and availability issues could arise.
 
I'm not so sure that either Nashville or Brookfield will ever bring back elephants. Nashville sent away its 4 female African elephants in 2015 and already 6 years have elapsed. With the upcoming 40-acre African Safari going to possibly take up to a decade to be finished, by then it will be 16 years and counting without elephants. As for Brookfield, they haven't had elephants in 11 years and that zoo really needs outdoor exhibits for its great apes and to figure out what to do with the 1961 Dolphinarium. Add in concerns about the cold weather and I think that the city of Chicago will never have elephants again. Nashville is more likely, but still 10+ years away minimum.

Only Bronx and Point Defiance have publicly announced phasing out elephants, @Coelacanth18 , but the list of 14 zoos that I mentioned could all conceivably phase them out in the future. It can happen fast, just like the 6 zoos that recently phased out elephants in just a handful of years. (Buffalo, Nashville, Riverbanks, Santa Barbara, Virginia and Woodland Park) There are plenty of other zoos that I didn't even mention. Examples include Calgary, Toronto, Greenville, Lee Richardson, Brookfield, Grant's Farm, Monterey, Baton Rouge, Niabi, etc. I think, on average, that it's about one North American zoo per year that no longer displays elephants.

Here's my list of 14 zoos that I think will not have elephants by 2031 (I looked up the year of birth of each elephant on The Elephant Database link):

The elephant database

Bronx - 2 elderly elephants (1970 and 1971)
Cameron Park - 1 elderly elephant (1977)
El Paso - 1 elderly elephant (1952)
Honolulu - 2 mature elephants (1985 and 1975)
Knoxville - 3 elderly elephants (1979, 1980 and 1983)
Little Rock - 3 elderly elephants (1960, 1969 and 1976)
Louisville - 3 elephants of two species (1970, 1985 and 2019)
Montgomery - 3 elephants (1982, 1984 and 2007)
Point Defiance - 1 elderly elephant (1964)
Roger Williams Park - 3 mature elephants (all 1985)
San Antonio - 3 elderly elephants (1960, 1969 and 1976)
Toledo - 2 elephants (1979 and 1985)
Topeka - 2 elderly elephants (1959 and 1971)
Utah's Hogle Zoo - 2 elephants (1986 and 2009)

There's a few more zoos on my list with 3 elephants than I expected, as I'd forgotten that Louisville has a youngster and all 3 of Little Rock's ex-circus elephants arrived in 2017. Of the 31 elephants on the list, 29 of them are 35 years of age or older...in some cases much older! Ten years from now, almost every elephant on the list will be a minimum of 45 years of age...if even still alive.

I've visited all 14 of the zoos and it's somewhat ironic that the Bronx Zoo's elephant exhibit is arguably the best of the lot. Every single other enclosure is at best adequate and in some cases brutally small judged by modern standards. The majority of those zoos exist in a fairly warm part of the United States, but the enormous cost of building a modern elephant complex and the scarce availability of elephants means that I really do think that all 14 zoos are on the precipice of not having elephants by 2031. Which zoos will step up to the plate and spend millions on a new elephant habitat? Any of them?
 
I decided to compose a similar list of places that have phased out their elephants (or a certain species) since 1991 just for comparison. I will try to include what species the zoos have lost and the date when the last elephant(s) were phased out, but may mess up, so correct me if the zoo had more than one species.

Abilene Zoo (TX) - African - 2007
Alaska Zoo (AK) - African + Asian - 2007
Blank Park Zoo (IA) (Not owned but temporarily displayed from a ranch) Asian - unknown but sometime after 2008
BREC'S Baton Rouge Zoo (LA) - Asian - 2013
Brookfield Zoo (IL) - African - 2010
Buffalo Zoo (NY) - Asian - 2018
Central Florida Zoo (FL) - Asian - 2011
Chehaw Wild Animal Park (GA) - African - 2004
Detroit Zoo (MI) - Asian - 2005
Dr. Juan A Riviero Zoo? (PR) - African - Unknown (Is this zoo sill open? A news report from 2017 says the elephant was moving to Georgia to live in a sanctuary.)
Erie Zoo (PN) - African, maybe Asian? - Unknown, I'm assuming after 1991 since a female lives in Cleveland)
Frank Buck Zoo (TX) - Asian - 1998?
Gladys Porter Zoo (TX) - African - 2006 or 2007
Grant's Farm (MO) - African - 2018
Greenville Zoo (SC) - African - 2014
Gulf Breeze Zoo (FL) - African - 2003
Henry Vilas Zoo (WI) - Asian - 2000
HolyWild Animal Park (SC) - Asian - 2006?
Jackson Zoo (MS) - African - 2010
Lee Richardson Zoo (KS) - African - 2015
Lincoln Park Zoo (IL) - African + Asian? - 2005
Lion Country Safari (FL) - African - 2006
Louisiana Purchase Gardens and Zoo (LA) - Asian - 1999
Mesker Park Zoo (IN) - Asian - 1999
Nashville Zoo (TN) - African - 2015
Niabi Zoo (IL) - Asian - 2013
Philadelphia Zoo (PN) - African + Asian - 2007
Popcorn Park Zoo (NJ) - African - 2001
Racine Zoo (WI) - Asian? - Unknown
Riverbanks Zoo (SC) - African - 2019
Sacramento Zoo (CA) - Asian - c. 1991
San Francisco Zoo (CA) - African + Asian - 2005
Santa Ana Zoo (CA) (Seasonal) - Asian - 2011
Santa Barbara Zoo (CA) - Asian - 2019
Siegfried and Roy's Secret Garden (NV) - Asian - 2005
Six Flags Discovery Kingdom (CA) - African + Asian - 2015 or 2016
Southwicks Zoo? (MA) (Seasonal) - Asian - Unknown, sometimes after 2016 (Do they still display them seasonally?)
Virginia Zoo (VA) - African - 2015
Wild Adventures (GA) - Asian - 2021
Woodland Park Zoo (WA) - African + Asian - 2015
York's Wild Kingdom (ME) (Seasonal) - Asian - 2011

Please correct me of any inaccuracies, and take this list with a pinch of salt, as I may be incorrect on some things.
 
I decided to compose a similar list of places that have phased out their elephants (or a certain species) since 1991 just for comparison. I will try to include what species the zoos have lost and the date when the last elephant(s) were phased out, but may mess up, so correct me if the zoo had more than one species.

Abilene Zoo (TX) - African - 2007
Alaska Zoo (AK) - African + Asian - 2007
Blank Park Zoo (IA) (Not owned but temporarily displayed from a ranch) Asian - unknown but sometime after 2008
BREC'S Baton Rouge Zoo (LA) - Asian - 2013
Brookfield Zoo (IL) - African - 2010
Buffalo Zoo (NY) - Asian - 2018
Central Florida Zoo (FL) - Asian - 2011
Chehaw Wild Animal Park (GA) - African - 2004
Detroit Zoo (MI) - Asian - 2005
Dr. Juan A Riviero Zoo? (PR) - African - Unknown (Is this zoo sill open? A news report from 2017 says the elephant was moving to Georgia to live in a sanctuary.)
Erie Zoo (PN) - African, maybe Asian? - Unknown, I'm assuming after 1991 since a female lives in Cleveland)
Frank Buck Zoo (TX) - Asian - 1998?
Gladys Porter Zoo (TX) - African - 2006 or 2007
Grant's Farm (MO) - African - 2018
Greenville Zoo (SC) - African - 2014
Gulf Breeze Zoo (FL) - African - 2003
Henry Vilas Zoo (WI) - Asian - 2000
HolyWild Animal Park (SC) - Asian - 2006?
Jackson Zoo (MS) - African - 2010
Lee Richardson Zoo (KS) - African - 2015
Lincoln Park Zoo (IL) - African + Asian? - 2005
Lion Country Safari (FL) - African - 2006
Louisiana Purchase Gardens and Zoo (LA) - Asian - 1999
Mesker Park Zoo (IN) - Asian - 1999
Nashville Zoo (TN) - African - 2015
Niabi Zoo (IL) - Asian - 2013
Philadelphia Zoo (PN) - African + Asian - 2007
Popcorn Park Zoo (NJ) - African - 2001
Racine Zoo (WI) - Asian? - Unknown
Riverbanks Zoo (SC) - African - 2019
Sacramento Zoo (CA) - Asian - c. 1991
San Francisco Zoo (CA) - African + Asian - 2005
Santa Ana Zoo (CA) (Seasonal) - Asian - 2011
Santa Barbara Zoo (CA) - Asian - 2019
Siegfried and Roy's Secret Garden (NV) - Asian - 2005
Six Flags Discovery Kingdom (CA) - African + Asian - 2015 or 2016
Southwicks Zoo? (MA) (Seasonal) - Asian - Unknown, sometimes after 2016 (Do they still display them seasonally?)
Virginia Zoo (VA) - African - 2015
Wild Adventures (GA) - Asian - 2021
Woodland Park Zoo (WA) - African + Asian - 2015
York's Wild Kingdom (ME) (Seasonal) - Asian - 2011

Please correct me of any inaccuracies, and take this list with a pinch of salt, as I may be incorrect on some things.
Another great list. One minor correction, Lincoln Park only had Africans by the time they made the decision to phase them out. Asian elephants had been gone for at least several years at that point.
 
Doesn't San Antonio have plans to add African elephants to Africa Live after their death? I thought I read that somewhere

That's an old idea. From what I understand it's dead in the water with new management and the new capital campaign. The elephant exhibit will largely be boxed in and if elephants are kept it would need to be in a new complex across the highway from the existing site on undeveloped land. Considering that's like 9 acres of space, I am unsure if the zoo would even want to devote so much area to just one species.
 
It's all about sourcing. @nczoofan, isn't the new administration for SA from SeaWorld background? I may have been out of loop on that. Africans are highly unlikely but Asian are not out of the realm of possibility. Considering where Nicole and Karen came from that herd is wide open for possibilities.
 
It's all about sourcing. @nczoofan, isn't the new administration for SA from SeaWorld background? I may have been out of loop on that. Africans are highly unlikely but Asian are not out of the realm of possibility. Considering where Nicole and Karen came from that herd is wide open for possibilities.

Yes. The director and assistant director both have ties to Seaworld. The director actually grew up in San Antonio and ran Aquatica from what I remember. Although he has been on board since 2014, the zoo only recently launched its campaign into high gear. I haven’t seen the complete plans. Only bits and pieces such as short-term projects (butterfly house, new train) and projects a few years out (expanded entrance area & gorilla complex).

So they may very well want to keep elephants yet none of the information I have heard from staff or seen says so yet. The zoo acknowledges the current exhibit is not sufficient longterm with its tiny barn and 1/3 of an acre yard of so, although I can imagine that it will be as is until Lucky passes. Then who knows although I imagine the zoo will receive pressure to either end the current exhibit or reveal a new exhibit. I hope Lucky lives many more years though and she seems to be active and in good health every time I visit though.

Africans were mentioned when the zoo brought in Karen and Nicole, but this was under the previous director. Tbh that plan never made sense as it called for expanding the elephant exhibit outside the quarry. Yet that exhibit would be the steepest elephant exhibit known to man, although tbh it was probably just kicking the can down the road.
 
No worries, they helped out Ringling by taking the two and helped them selves regarding Lucky. They won't keep the current exhibit elephants given what you previously mentioned. They are staunch on keeping elephants but a major exhibit will have to be in the works (just even to compete with Dallas, Houston and Ft Worth). I also agree gorillas will come first. The three are just placeholders until the funding comes but SA will be one of last to give them up out of @snowleopard list
 
No worries, they helped out Ringling by taking the two and helped them selves regarding Lucky. They won't keep the current exhibit elephants given what you previously mentioned. They are staunch on keeping elephants but a major exhibit will have to be in the works (just even to compete with Dallas, Houston and Ft Worth). I also agree gorillas will come first. The three are just placeholders until the funding comes but SA will be one of last to give them up out of @snowleopard list

From what I understand the funding has been coming in. The campaign was originally gonna be in the 50-100 million range, and now that’s been upped to 200 million. If they are as committed to elephants as you say then I can imagine a 4-5 acre complex across the highway from the existing zoo (could also move the asian animals such as tigers). The only other option would be to relocate the entire maintenance area, demolish the bird house and surrounding exhibits if the zoo wants them within the existing site. We won’t really know though until late next year when the zoo plans to go public for the final 10% of the campaign or so.
 
That's an old idea. From what I understand it's dead in the water with new management and the new capital campaign. The elephant exhibit will largely be boxed in and if elephants are kept it would need to be in a new complex across the highway from the existing site on undeveloped land. Considering that's like 9 acres of space, I am unsure if the zoo would even want to devote so much area to just one species.

San Antonio has had a rocky relationship with elephants in the press in recent years, with 'Lucky' often in newspaper articles in terms of criticism of the small enclosure. I know that Woodland Park Zoo received a lot of negative press and demonstrations at the zoo and finally they got rid of their elephants and it has been peaceful ever since. San Antonio might just let their elderly pachyderms live out their lives and then end the elephant program forever.

It's difficult for me to imagine any single major zoo in America going out of its way to spend tens of millions of dollars on adding elephants in this day and age. Even Nashville just announced a 10-year African Safari project and there are no elephants returning in the immediate future. San Antonio has all that extra land at their disposal and there's so much else they could do with it without adding elephants. The zoo already gets a minimum of a million visitors per year and it would be great to see other attractions on the undeveloped land. Why not continue a Texas tradition and build a large Reptile House? The current one has an amazing collection in adequate and at times small terrariums. Or the zoo could add an African Savanna...or an aquatic area with sealions...or even some great apes as San Antonio curiously lacks any great apes in its collection.
 
San Antonio has had a rocky relationship with elephants in the press in recent years, with 'Lucky' often in newspaper articles in terms of criticism of the small enclosure. I know that Woodland Park Zoo received a lot of negative press and demonstrations at the zoo and finally they got rid of their elephants and it has been peaceful ever since. San Antonio might just let their elderly pachyderms live out their lives and then end the elephant program forever.

It's difficult for me to imagine any single major zoo in America going out of its way to spend tens of millions of dollars on adding elephants in this day and age. Even Nashville just announced a 10-year African Safari project and there are no elephants returning in the immediate future. San Antonio has all that extra land at their disposal and there's so much else they could do with it without adding elephants. The zoo already gets a minimum of a million visitors per year and it would be great to see other attractions on the undeveloped land. Why not continue a Texas tradition and build a large Reptile House? The current one has an amazing collection in adequate and at times small terrariums. Or the zoo could add an African Savanna...or an aquatic area with sealions...or even some great apes as San Antonio curiously lacks any great apes in its collection.

I mean yes they have gotten negative press with Lucky, although less as of recent. Bringing in retired Ringling elephants was a PR great move, even though I think Lucky would be fine on her own. The zoo has done the best it can with the current exhibit, removing the moat and extending it 30% with soft sand flooring. As well they stuff the exhibit with enrichment. Still we all agree it is not optimal long term, although the city of San Antonio does have an affinitty with Lucky after her 55 years there or so.

As I said I don't know what's in the master plan, yet the zoo does have the room and more to build an exhibit larger than those seen at Dallas, Fort Worth, and Houston. Either way I can imagine any new exhibit will occur after Lucky's time. We will have to wait and see though, as Gorillas (the zoos first great ape, which is a situation I am not sure many zoos are in) seem to be the first focus of the master plan. The zoo seems focused on redeveloping the existing zoo area into Africa and Australia. Then they want to move the 8 acres of maintenance buildings and animal care buildings and relocate them across the highway. The zoo has 11 acres of underdeveloped space above the quarry walls and 11 acres across the highway, so they'll have plenty of flexibility.

I will admit though I am a little biased, but I do believe the current leadership of the zoo, the city of San Antonio, and the donors want to push the zoo to the level of the other main zoos in Texas. It's lagged exhibit wise (although currently has the largest collection and probably the best conservation work). Yet San Antonio is key on being seen as a first-class city akin to DFW, Austin, and Houston.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top