Humans did for Australian megafauna

Its hard to argue that humans aren't the cause of megafaunal extinctions. Everywhere humans went on the planet, the megafauna disappeared soon afterwards. The time-scale of extinctions always follows human migrations.

My personal thoughts on global Holocene extinctions are that in almost all cases humans are directly and indirectly responsible (i.e. directly through hunting, indirectly through destruction of habitat [burning], introduction of disease [e.g. with dogs], introduction of novel predators [dogs again], etc). In some cases there are probably natural factors working in combination but which by themselves would not have resulted in extinctions.
 
Africa and Asia are areas where humans evolved alongside the local fauna. Therefore, these areas built up an immunity to us.
 
southern and southeast Asia actually did lose a lot of megafauna - what is left there now is a remnant - but as jbnbsn99 says southeast Asia has a much longer history of human activity than the Americas and Australia. Homo erectus spread into Asia (or evolved there from Africa-originated H. ergaster, depending on one's theoretical leanings) well over a million years ago and so the situation there is similar to that in Africa where the megafauna evolved alongside hominids. What is telling is that as humans later spread eastwards through the Lesser Sunda island chain, the big animals quickly disappeared along the route, as they did once H. sapiens arrived in Australia. The last place on earth to show megafaunal extinctions (until the modern day of course) was New Zealand where the moa were wiped out about 800 years ago....right when humans finally reached the islands.
 
Last edited:
Same could be said of the Madagascar extinctions about the same time as the New Zealand extinctions.
 
Madagascar was a bit earlier, around 2000 years ago when humans first arrived there from Indonesia, but yes it is in the same general ball-park as New Zealand (in both cases the last large-bodied species disappeared around 800 to 500 years ago)
 
Back
Top