Which EDGE species will you vote for : The secretary bird and the Northern bald ibis? (Poll)

which species will you vote for ?

  • Total voters
    22
  • Poll closed .
Onychorhynchus coronatus

Onychorhynchus coronatus

Well-Known Member
Fourth poll on EDGE bird species: This time it is a contest between two highly charismatic birds, one of which the subject of long-term conservation efforts that have spanned decades and the other a species which has only just come on the radar of conservationists.

Both species are African (North and Sub-Saharan African respectively), both species are classified as endangered by the IUCN , both are deeply culturally significant to the human cultures of the ranges they inhabit (Middle Eastern, European and Sub-Saharan African respectively).

full


full


Which of these bird species interests you most / will you vote for ?

Please also feel free to write comments regarding why you made the choice and why the species you have voted for interests you more.

Thanks !

Look forward to seeing the results!

Photo credits to @Goura and @KevinB.
 
The secretary bird is the only member of a monotypic family while there are a number of species of ibis (including another in the same genus as the northern bald ibis).

Consequently, my vote goes to the secretary bird as the most evolutionary distinct of the two species.
 
Tim May said:
The secretary bird is the only member of a monotypic family while there are a number of species of ibis (including another in the same genus as the nothern bald ibis).

Consequently, my vote goes to the secretary bird as the most evolutionary distinct of the two species.
Click to expand...

Thank you for voting and your comment @Tim May !

I agree the secretary bird is a very interesting species and particularly with its monotypic status and as a member of the Accipitriformes.
 
I agree that secretary birds are more interesting than waldrapps, but the ibis has my vote because of how small the population is. I believe they are more in need of conservation efforts.
 
Strix said:
I agree that secretary birds are more interesting than waldrapps, but the ibis has my vote because of how small the population is. I believe they are more in need of conservation efforts.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your comment and voting @Strix !

That pretty much sums up my vote too which was for similar reasons.

However, I must say that the secretary bird is also severely endangered and has only just come on the radar of conservationists while the Northern bald ibis has benefited from intensive conservation efforts for several decades.

Also, despite its wide range I think the secretary bird is likely to be in a very steep decline across many areas of Africa.
 
You have me in a cleft stick with this one; Secretarybird wins for being a distinct family (and one I have only seen in captivity), yet I feel the ibis is not easily dismissed. The fact that it was a lost Alpine breeding species that is now being reestablished in Iberia, and that I have seen it both semi wild in Biricek, and fully wild in Tamri. I declare a personal draw!
 
Tetzoo Quizzer said:
You have me in a cleft stick with this one; Secretarybird wins for being a distinct family (and one I have only seen in captivity), yet I feel the ibis is not easily dismissed. The fact that it was a lost Alpine breeding species that is now being reestablished in Iberia, and that I have seen it both semi wild in Biricek, and fully wild in Tamri. I declare a personal draw!
Click to expand...

Yes, its a difficult one isn't it ?

Well there are no wrong or right answers to this, its all subjective so a draw is acceptable.

It is great to hear you have seen the species in the wild as from what I've heard it has really been a struggle to re-establish it back across its former range.
 
Mo Hassan said:
My knee-jerk vote was for the ibis due to its status in the wild, but honestly, for distinctiveness I ought to have chosen the secretary bird. Great arguments on both sides from everyone, it's tough to pick.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your comment @Mo Hassan !

You can still change your vote back to the secretary bird if you like , no problem.

Have you seen either of these birds in captivity or the wild ?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top