Generational amnesia is masking nature’s decline

UngulateNerd92

Well-Known Member
10+ year member
Premium Member
Connecting with nature and talking to grandparents can help us become more aware of environmental declines.

People of all ages are now increasingly aware of the current ecological crisis. In 2019, the UN IPBES Global Assessment announced that global biomass of wild mammals had fallen by 82% while temperatures soared to the hottest on record and over 1 million species were considered at risk of extinction. Yet, it’s often extremely difficult to translate such enormous global issues into concepts relevant to our daily lives.

It’s often easier to look back and consider change in our own lives and ask, “How much change have I experienced?” As a child I remember enjoying huge variety of birds in our garden, annual snowfall and predictable summers, all things that seem less common today. Thinking back, remembering the past and considering change allows us to better judge current conditions. How many bird species used to arrive in the garden each spring? Is that different to now?

The world we grow up in and observe from an early age forms our personal reference point, or baseline, against which we compare all future experiences of change. We are inherently influenced by our own sense of what is ‘normal’ and what are acceptable changes from that starting point. Looking further into the past, it’s even harder to fathom the experiences of our ancestors and how they might see the world today, as what we now consider pristine nature, might appear to them as wholly degraded.

Generational amnesia is masking nature’s decline
 
I didnt need to read the article immediately to know precisely what this headline meant. For years i’ve lamented the way even our dialogue paints a false picture of the current state of the planet. for example we say:

“Half the Amazon is on fire” rather than say: “Half the remaining 60% of the Amazon is on fire.

We “reset” the baseline constantly, rather than continuing to speak in a way that acknowledges whats already been lost.
 
I met conservationists in Germany and Switzerland who oppose reintroduction of European bison 'because we should focus on what we have' or 'because we should focus on native species'. Of course, European bison is native.
 
I met conservationists in Germany and Switzerland who oppose reintroduction of European bison 'because we should focus on what we have' or 'because we should focus on native species'. Of course, European bison is native.

I don't understand that attitude regarding the wisent in Germany in particular. I mean it isn't a situation comparable to reintroduction of the gray wolf or the brown bear to the UK or Ireland is it ?

Germany is not an island nation pressed for space but a mainland continental one and a large one at that with plenty of land and green space for rewilding and remaining forests too.

Historically and in prehistory the bison roamed from Southern France across Germany and into Eastern Europe and its last stronghold was / is the Białowieża Forest next door in Poland.

So how can these conservationists argue that the European bison is not a native species ?
 
Last edited:
I met conservationists in Germany and Switzerland who oppose reintroduction of European bison 'because we should focus on what we have' or 'because we should focus on native species'. Of course, European bison is native.

I understand this position. Bison is a large animal who was absent for half a millenium and who can cause a lot of conflict in densely populated areas where every tree and every piece of lawn is owned and managed in intensive manner. Damage to planted trees, crops, possible traffic accidents. German conservationists already get ton of hate for otters, wolves or beavers and don´t want more.

Personally, I would just reintroduce large number of bison in Poland, close to German border. They will find their way, like wolves did.
 
I understand this position. Bison is a large animal who was absent for half a millenium and who can cause a lot of conflict in densely populated areas where every tree and every piece of lawn is owned and managed in intensive manner. Damage to planted trees, crops, possible traffic accidents. German conservationists already get ton of hate for otters, wolves or beavers and don´t want more.

Personally, I would just reintroduce large number of bison in Poland, close to German border. They will find their way, like wolves did.

Good point, but they will inevitably eventually cross over into Germany anyway and recolonise habitat where they were once extirpated, right ?
 
Good point, but they will inevitably eventually cross over into Germany anyway and recolonise habitat where they were once extirpated, right ?

This would require more nuanced answer. But in short, two strong powers go against each other. On one side, nature protection in both Poland and Germany gets stronger, laws get better enforced and population is more positive towards enviromental issues. Bison herds in Poland are slowly growing (but still inhabiting just a very small percentage of former range).

On the other side, the landscape in both Poland and Germany gets more obstructed each year, by building new roads, houses and other infrastructure. So landscape gets so fractured that large animals that need large area to sustain meaningful number of herds have little chance for long term survival. Also, bison is seen as too dangerous by average Germans. First animal that crossed the border from Poland in 2017 - he got shot by hunters almost immediately, and it was done legally, agreed by local administration.
 
This would require more nuanced answer. But in short, two strong powers go against each other. On one side, nature protection in both Poland and Germany gets stronger, laws get better enforced and population is more positive towards enviromental issues. Bison herds in Poland are slowly growing (but still inhabiting just a very small percentage of former range).

On the other side, the landscape in both Poland and Germany gets more obstructed each year, by building new roads, houses and other infrastructure. So landscape gets so fractured that large animals that need large area to sustain meaningful number of herds have little chance for long term survival. Also, bison is seen as too dangerous by average Germans. First animal that crossed the border from Poland in 2017 - he got shot by hunters almost immediately, and it was done legally, agreed by local administration.

I see, yes it definitely requires a nuanced answer indeed. There does sound to be a lot of potential for human-wildlife conflict with all of the urbanization and fragmentation of forest habitat.

I think it is a catch-22 situation as it is almost inevitable that the bison will eventually cross into Germany and begin recolonising.

They are obviously going to do this whether people like this or not.
 
Back
Top