Which EDGE mammal interests you more: The red panda or the aye-aye ? (poll)

Which EDGE mammal interests you more: The Red panda or the Aye-aye? (poll)

  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .
Onychorhynchus coronatus

Onychorhynchus coronatus

Well-Known Member
Another poll in a series for zoochatters to vote for one of two EDGE mammal species. This time it is a contest of a species traditionally considered "cute / cuddly" and one typically seen as "weird / spooky": the aye-aye vs the red panda.

Both are arboreal mammals, both are classified as endangered by the IUCN and both have unusual morphologies with "pseudothumbs" that have evolved due to highly specialized feeding ecologies.

Which of these mammal species interests you most / will you vote for ?

full


full


Please also feel free to write comments regarding why you made the choice and why the species you have voted for interests you more.

Thanks !

Look forward to seeing the results!

Photo credits to @KevinB and @gentle lemur.
 
Last edited:
Onychorhynchus coronatus said:
Another poll in a series for zoochatters to vote for one of two EDGE mammal species. This time it is a contest of a species traditionally considered "cute / cuddly" and one typically seen as "weird / spooky": the aye-aye vs the red panda.

Both are arboreal mammals, both are classified as endangered by the IUCN and both have unusual morphologies with "pseudothumbs" that have evolved due to highly specialized feeding ecologies.

Which of these mammal species interests you most / will you vote for ?

full


full


Please also feel free to write comments regarding why you made the choice and why the species you have voted for interests you more.

Thanks !

Look forward to seeing the results!

Photo credits to @KevinB and @gentle lemur.
Click to expand...

For me, I choose Red Panda.

Aye Aye fascinate me, but in the end, Red Panda interests me more. The way they go about their lives, their incredible climbing skills, and their docile nature is what really interests me about them. Here in Australia, they are commonly kept in zoos, and are a popular ambassador for endangered species. They are extremely cute and their physical appearance is quite striking. They are a hard species to miss.
 
Both are species with unique adaptations and specializations, but personally I voted for the red panda.

My main reason for this vote is my familiarity with this species, having seen it numerous times over the year. The red panda also used to be in the logo of both of my local zoos (Zoo Antwerpen and Zoo Planckendael, which are managed by the same society), until 2007. I still enjoy searching the red pandas on zoo visit to any zoo that has them, and love the times when they are awake and show themselves well.

I also find the facet of a member of the order Carnivora adapting to and surviving on a mostly vegetarian diet of a plant that is neither highly nutritious nor easily digestible for a species that does not possess a four-chambered stomach or hindgut fermentation to be very interesting, as are its adaptations to living an arboreal lifestyle. With regards to diet a specialized insectivorous diet is not nearly as unusual for a primate as the red panda's bamboo diet, although the aye aye is admittedly quite large for an insectivorous primate and its ways of getting insects are indeed weird and unique.

As mentioned above, red pandas definitely have the ability to be popular ambassador species for endangered species and for their native range and habitats. I have noticed in zoos that for a relatively sleepy and sometimes a little cryptic species they are certainly popular with visitors. I think Madagascar probably would have more popular and appealing ambassador species then the aye aye, even if one foregoes the very popular ring-tailed lemur.

That said, the aye aye is also a fascinating species - and the fact that all species can be fascinating in their own right and have unique aspects always make these polls very difficult in my opinion.

PS: @Onychorhynchus coronatus thank you for using my photo as an example of the species.
 
Last edited:
Jambo said:
For me, I choose Red Panda.

Aye Aye fascinate me, but in the end, Red Panda interests me more. The way they go about their lives, their incredible climbing skills, and their docile nature is what really interests me about them. Here in Australia, they are commonly kept in zoos, and are a popular ambassador for endangered species. They are extremely cute and their physical appearance is quite striking. They are a hard species to miss.
Click to expand...

Thanks for voting and your comment!

They are cute indeed and definitely seem to be a popular ambassador species and in addition very interesting from both a conversation and evolutionary biology perspective.

For me though personally I had to vote for the aye-aye due to its singular and eerily beautiful and gothic look, fascinating ecology and evolution and its conservation plight.
 
KevinB said:
Both are species with unique adaptations and specializations, but personally I voted for the red panda.

My main reason for this vote is my familiarity with this species, having seen it numerous times over the year. The red panda also used to be in the logo of both of my local zoos (Zoo Antwerpen and Zoo Planckendael, which are managed by the same society), until 2007. I still enjoy searching the red pandas on zoo visit to any zoo that has them, and love the times when they are awake and show themselves well.

I also find the facet of a member of the order Carnivora adapting to and surviving on a mostly vegetarian diet of a plant that is neither highly nutritious nor easily digestible for a species that does not possess a four-chambered stomach or hindgut fermentation to be very interesting, as are its adaptations to living an arboreal lifestyle. With regards to diet a specialized insectivorous diet is not nearly as unusual for a primate as the red panda's bamboo diet, although the aye aye is admittedly quite large for an insectivorous primate and its ways of getting insects are indeed weird and unique.

As mentioned above, red pandas definitely have the ability to be popular ambassador species for endangered species and for their native range and habitats. I think Madagascar probably would have more popular and appealing ambassador species then the aye aye, even if one foregoes the very popular ring-tailed lemur.

That said, the aye aye is also a fascinating species - and the fact that all species can be fascinating in their own right and have unique aspects always make these polls very difficult in my opinion.

PS: @Onychorhynchus coronatus thank you for using my photo as an example of the species.
Click to expand...

No problem :) its a great portrait of the red panda so had to use it.

Yes , absolutely agree, they are fascinating from an evolutionary perspective and they certainly tick all of the boxes for being a popular ambassador species for the public.

Again , sadly have to agree about the poor old aye-aye, it isn't ever going to have the crowd appeal of "cuter" lemurs like the ring tailed or ruffed.

Nevertheless, I'm very fond of the aye-aye so voted accordingly.
 
Last edited:
Aye-aye hands down. Nepalese red pandas are held in the three main New Zealand zoos I regularly visit and although I enjoy seeing them (especially cubs), I’d be far more interested to see an Aye-aye, which I would rarely get the opportunity to see.

I think in any case, the species (or subspecies) we see in our local zoos are the ones we have the most affinity for e.g. the Sumatran tiger is my favourite subspecies of tiger; but for sheer novelty factor, I doubt there’s few ZooChatters who would turn down the chance to see something new!

To be fair, you did say red panda, which includes the Chinese subspecies, but I think I will still have to go with the Aye-aye! :cool:
 
Zoofan15 said:
Aye-aye hands down. Nepalese red pandas are held in the three main New Zealand zoos I regularly visit and although I enjoy seeing them (especially cubs), I’d be far more interested to see an Aye-aye, which I would rarely get the opportunity to see.

I think in any case, the species (or subspecies) we see in our local zoos are the ones we have the most affinity for e.g. the Sumatran tiger is my favourite subspecies of tiger; but for sheer novelty factor, I doubt there’s few ZooChatters who would turn down the chance to see something new!

To be fair, you did say red panda, which includes the Chinese subspecies, but I think I will still have to go with the Aye-aye! :cool:
Click to expand...

Thanks for voting and the comment @Zoofan15 !

I think both the Chinese and Nepalese red pandas are becoming far more common in zoos and they seem to be pretty popular animals with a lot of crowd appeal.

Sumatran tigers are beautiful, definitely my favourite subspecies of tiger too, very striking.

Why do you like the aye-aye ? why does it interest you ?
 
Onychorhynchus coronatus said:
Thanks for voting and the comment @Zoofan15 !

I think both the Chinese and Nepalese red pandas are becoming far more common in zoos and they seem to be pretty popular animals with a lot of crowd appeal.

Sumatran tigers are beautiful, definitely my favourite subspecies of tiger too, very striking.

Why do you like the aye-aye ? why does it interest you ?
Click to expand...

Funnily enough, the Siberian tiger used to be my favourite subspecies, having spent my early childhood in England. I now prefer the Sumatran tigers I grew up seeing in Australasia’s zoos; but still support England in rugby for obvious reasons. :p

I like the Aye-aye because it’s a quirky and unusual animal. It’s superstitious associations also add to its air of mystery.
 
I think personally I just know more about them, they’re very common here in UK zoos and are a charismatic species, that’s not to say I don’t like aye-ayes, I just think in general the red panda edges it for me.
 
Zoofan15 said:
Funnily enough, the Siberian tiger used to be my favourite subspecies, having spent my early childhood in England. I now prefer the Sumatran tigers I grew up seeing in Australasia’s zoos; but still support England in rugby for obvious reasons. :p

I like the Aye-aye because it’s a quirky and unusual animal. It’s superstitious associations also add to its air of mystery.
Click to expand...

I think the Sumatran tiger is the most visually beautiful of the subspecies, I think its the darker stripes and richer shade of orange / russet of the pelt.

Totally agree, I think that aura of malevolence that it has in Malagasy folklore just add to the appeal.

Jude T said:
I think personally I just know more about them, they’re very common here in UK zoos and are a charismatic species, that’s not to say I don’t like aye-ayes, I just think in general the red panda edges it for me.
Click to expand...

Yes, they definitely outnumber the aye-aye in zoos.

I think the red panda would be one of those traditionally charismatic species that ticks a lot of people's boxes.

Afterall, it is cute , vibrantly coloured, has a superficial resemblance in body shape to domestic cats and the connection in name and the appearance of the face to the superstar giant panda.

A bit of trivia on red pandas , one of India's presidents , cant remember if it was Indira Ghandi or Nehru, was so fond of the red panda that they kept them as pets throughout their life.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JT
Onychorhynchus coronatus said:
Yes, they definitely outnumber the aye-aye in zoos.

I think the red panda would be one of those traditionally charismatic species that ticks a lot of people's boxes.

Afterall, it is cute , vibrantly coloured, has a superficial resemblance in body shape to domestic cats and the connection in name and the appearance of the face to the superstar giant panda.

A bit of trivia on red pandas , one of India's presidents , cant remember if it was Indira Ghandi or Nehru, was so fond of the red panda that they kept them as pets throughout their life.
Click to expand...
I also think they’d be a good species to work with should I get the chance.
 
Red pandas are, of course, a charismatic species with a very interesting taxonomic history; however, I frequently saw red pandas on childhood zoo visits so they never had the same appeal for me as the mysterious aye-aye.

I first read about aye-ayes when I was a young child and became fascinated by this strange nocturnal lemur; my interest grew when I learned it was once believed to be a rodent not a primate....

There were no aye-ayes in European zoos when I was a child so I didn't think I'd ever be lucky enough to see one. I'll never forget my excitement at seeing my first aye-aye in Vincennes Zoo (Paris) in 1987 so I had to vote for the aye-aye.

(As mentioned elsewhere on ZooChat Vincennes had an amazing lemur collection about this time.)
 
Tim May said:
Red pandas are, of course, a charismatic species with a very interesting taxonomic history; however, I frequently saw red pandas on childhood zoo visits so they never had the same appeal for me as the mysterious aye-aye.

I first read about aye-ayes when I was a young child and became fascinated by this strange nocturnal lemur; my interest grew when I learned it was once believed to be a rodent not a primate....

There were no aye-ayes in European zoos when I was a child so I didn't think I'd ever be lucky enough to see one. I'll never forget my excitement at seeing my first aye-aye in Vincennes Zoo (Paris) in 1987 so I had to vote for the aye-aye.

(As mentioned elsewhere on ZooChat Vincennes had an amazing lemur collection about this time.)
Click to expand...

Thanks for sharing Tim !

I actually had no idea that red pandas have been commonly kept for a while in zoos so this is quite interesting to find out.

I suppose I always assumed that they had been a relatively recently established species in European zoos long after the giant panda and that this was largely due to the connection with the giant panda and its popularity.

Yes , definitely an enigmatic species , and I can quite see why the aye-aye was mislabeled as a rodent for so long due to those bizarre looking incisors.
 
Last edited:
Jude T said:
I hope to be a keeper one day, it's all I've ever seen myself doing and obviously I'm open to other things in the field of zoology and conservation, but yes to answer your question, if I were to become a zookeeper I think they'd be a good species to work with.
Click to expand...

Wish you luck in achieving your goals Jude !
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top