Trends in European zoo collections in the 21st century

Giant anteater - Myrmecophaga tridactyla
This used to be a rather uncommon species of which breeding wasn’t too common. Well nowadays the nut has been cracked, over 3/4 of the current holders only started keeping this species this century, while only two holders from 2000 (London Zoo & Tierpark Hellabrunn in Munich) stopped keeping the species. With over 80 current holders giant anteaters have become just as common as Californian sea lions. Back in 2003 I was just as happy to see my first anteater in Duisburg as I was to see a beluga. 1 year later Artis in Amsterdam was very proud to become the only anteater holder in the Netherlands. How times have changed…
You know that the giant anteater population is really booming when the species has reached to Turkey*.

I’m aware that Turkey isn’t taken to account when making this thread I am only bringing it up to demonstrate how far the species has spread and how the TAG and studbook keeper is even able to trust a zoo in a region that lacked any experience with the species until 2013.
 
Number of zoos kept (current and former during the holding period):
A 1 zoo
B 2-5 zoos
C 6-10 zoos
D >10 zoos

Time period kept:
1 < 1 year
2 1-5 years
3 6-10 years
4 11-20 years
5 > 20 years

* Species successfully bred
♱ Dead end (in case of species gained)
↑ Species gaining popularity (in case of species gained)

ARMADILLOS - CINGULATA
22 species across 2 families
6 species kept this century (27%)


An order of heavily armoured small mammals that can withstand a lot of things, just not cars. They were previously lumped in the same order as sloths and anteaters, but are now generally treated as a separate order.

Long-nosed armadillos - Dasypodidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 1
# Species kept currently: 1
# Species gained: 1
# Species lost: 1


Only two species of this family of road bumps have been kept in Europe this century and neither was ever a common sight.

Species gained but lost

Brazilian lesser long-nosed armadillo - Dasypus septemcinctus A2
The subspecies hybridus (sometimes treated as a separate species) was kept at Paradise Wildlife Park in Broxbourne, UK, from 2002-2003 and 2004-2006, but not bred. It was allegedly also kept at Zoo Veszprem in Hungary until 2010. But these animals appear to have been 2 nine-banded armadillo that were imported from the US in 2007 and it seems likely these were the same animals that were subsequently sent to Zoo Dortmund in 2009.

full

@devilfish Bar 2 short stints completely absent from Europe this century: the lesser long-nosed armadillo

Species in decline

Nine-banded armadillo - Dasypus novemcinctus
At the start of the century this species was still kept in a few major zoos, from which it all but disappeared in the first decade. Zoo Dortmund was an outlier as the last major zoo with nine-banded armadillos, where they were kept until 2017, they received 1.1 animals via Zoo Veszprem in 2009. Currently the species pops up now and again in small zoos across Europe from private keepers, whereas major zoos are now focusing on the South American armadillos. It could well disappear (temporarily) from European zoos in the near future, but it is likely to reappear again somewhere.

full

@Newzooboy A North American native that is outcompeted by South Americans, the nine-banded armadillo

Progress
11/22 orders completed
21/106 families completed
43 species present in 2000
56 species present in 2023
31 species gained since 2000
18 species lost since 2000
 
Chlamyphorid armadillos - Chlamyphoridae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 4
# Species kept currently: 4
# Species gained: 0
# Species lost: 0


This family didn’t see any gain or loss in terms of species kept, although zoos have claimed to acquire dwarf armadillos (Zaedyus pichiy), these are just mislabelled screaming hairy armadillos (Chaetophractus vellerosus). Despite the lack of new species, this family is an increasingly familiar sight this century. One species has increased tremendously, but others have followed the same trend.

full

@Ding Lingwei Small but not quite a dwarf, the screaming hairy armadillo

Species gaining popularity

Southern three-banded armadillo - Tolypeutes matacus
Sometimes it is not entirely clear why species start to appear everywhere from nowhere. At the start of the century this was a very rare species and in recent years the increase in holders has been so strong that there are over 100 zoos with them. Zootierliste isn’t clear on how many holders there were in 2000, it could have been (almost) completely absent. The current zoo population is almost completely derived from animals bred in Zoo Heidelberg, which acquired the species in 2004, and Zoo Halle, both in Germany. As it is a perfect terrestrial addition to many primate exhibits and as these armadillos are also active during the day, their popularity is not very strange. But their appearance everywhere out of nowhere is nonetheless astonishing.

Six-banded armadillo - Euphractus sexcinctus
Another armadillo species that has become significantly more common during this century. Similarly to their three-banded cousin they are a popular addition in mixed species exhibits, both in nocturnal houses and in daylight exhibits. Primates are a favourite companion, but they can be housed with birds too.

Large hairy armadillo - Chaetophractus villosus
It is a bit repetitive, but this is the 3rd armadillo species that has become significantly more common this century. They are a popular addition to mixed species exhibits, both in nocturnal houses and in daylight exhibits. What makes these 3 South-American armadillo species gain so much popularity is a bit of a mystery to me. The ease with which they can be mixed with other species certainly helps, but sometimes popularity just seems to breed more popularity. There also seems to be a shift from only large zoos keeping armadillos to any zoo acquiring them. The lesson that they do equally well in diurnal exhibits, if not better, compared to the now much scarcer nocturnal setting must also have helped. But overall the change is remarkable.

full

@Tomek Coming to a zoo near you!

Progress
12/22 orders completed
22/106 families completed
47 species present in 2000
60 species present in 2023
31 species gained since 2000
18 species lost since 2000
 
An order of heavily armoured small mammals that can withstand a lot of things, just not cars. They were previously lumped in the same order as sloths and anteaters, but are now generally treated as a separate order.
Zootierliste has placed armadillos in a separate order but still place all marsupials together
 
these are just mislabelled screaming hairy armadillos (Chaetophractus vellerosus)

Which are in severe decline and will, I suspect, be lost entirely in the coming years - so I'm somewhat surprised this was your only mention of the species.
 
Which are in severe decline and will, I suspect, be lost entirely in the coming years - so I'm somewhat surprised this was your only mention of the species.

You are probably right, but this was one of the cases where Zootierliste isn't conclusive. While there is a fair amount of (mostly UK) zoos with this species this century, there is only 1 zoo (Frankfurt) with 100% evidence that the species was present in 2000 too, while the other holdings indicate a minimum timespan that doesn't include 2000 (though it isn't unlikely the species was present at that time then too in a few places). With currently 2 holders listed, that is clearly less than in 2005, though even now there seems to be confusion about species. Berkenhof Tropical Zoo in Berkendamme, the Netherlands lists their hairy armadillo as larger, while on pictures here and on their website, they seem to have screaming. As I knew such cases exist, I mentioned in the outline that the gaining popularity and losing popularity categories are not exhaustive, though I still tried to make them as complete as possible.

There will also be species that have a high risk of disappearing in the near future that won't be mentioned as their situation isn't really different from 2000 such as zorilla which has been held at roughly zoos in 2000 and now.
 
I believe the 9-banded had been lost for European zoos for quite a few years since their “return”. I wasn’t aware of any on show for quite some years untill this thread pointed them out.

Armadillo’s do seem on the rise, specially the 3-banded. First time I saw them was at Osnabruck, which I believe was also one the first to receive offspring. Now they’re everywhere.
 
PANGOLINS - PHOLIDOTA
8 species in 1 family
2 species kept this century (25%)


These walking pinecones are some of the most endangered wildlife on the planet, but keeping them alive in zoos has turned out to be a challenge. Which is a pity as they are a fascinating group with an important story to tell. Given their rarity in zoos the closest most people will get to a pangolin is watching the live action Jungle Book movie, which means it is at least good for something. Despite that, it is now actually possible to see pangolins in captivity in Europe, which wasn’t the case 23 years ago, which means an infinite increase ;). The taxonomic nitpickers will have noticed by now, that pangolins aren't actually close to the previous orders on the mammal tree of evolution. They are the sister group to the carnivores, but their placement here in the thread is solely due to their looks.

full

@Mehdi Absent from Europe since the 1970s: the black-bellied pangolin

Pangolins - Manidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 0
# Species kept currently: 1 (+1)
# Species gained: 2
# Species lost: 1


While most pangolin species have been kept in European zoos in the 20th century, those imports were mostly very short-lived and breeding was non-existent. Improved husbandry means that pangolins can now at least be kept alive and sometimes even bred, though the rather mixed success of the import of white-bellied pangolins to the US shows that there is still a lot to learn about pangolin husbandry.

Species gained

Chinese pangolin - Manis pentadactyla B4*
Both Zoo Riga and Zoo Wuppertal shortly kept this species in the 1990s, but those animals quickly perished. Zoo Leipzig imported a pair from Zoo Taipei in 2007, which meant the start of a new age in pangolin husbandry in Europe. Leipzig holds the longevity record for pangolins in Europe by a big margin, but no breeding was achieved. Zoo Prague imported a young pair from Zoo Taipei in 2022 and achieved Europe’s first breeding in 2023, which gives some hope that with Taiwanese help an European captive population can hopefully be established.

full

@Maguari One of the first pangolins in Europe this century, a Chinese pangolin in Zoo Leipzig

Species gained but lost

White-bellied pangolin - Phataginus tricuspis A2
Paris Menagerie/Jardin des Plantes imported this species from Gabon in 2006, where it was kept until 2007. It seems only a single animal was imported. The European longevity record is still from a confiscated animal that lived nearly 5 years in captivity from 1990-1994, first in Diergaarde Blijdorp and later in Burgers' Zoo.

full

@RatioTile Still present in low numbers in the US, but absent from Europe; the white-bellied pangolin

Progress
13/22 orders completed
23/106 families completed
47 species present in 2000
61 species present in 2023
33 species gained since 2000
19 species lost since 2000
 
TREESHREWS - SCANDENTIA
23 species across 2 families
3-4 species kept this century (13%-17%)


Only a few species of this family have been kept in Europe and only one of them is left.

Treeshrews - Tupaiidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 2-4
# Species kept currently: 1 (-1 – -3)
# Species gained: 0-1
# Species lost: 2-3


At the moment only a single species is kept, the northern (Belanger’s) treeshrew (Tupaia belangeri), which is not uncommon across the continent. Several species were however lost this century, but it is unclear how many exactly and whether all these species were already present in 2000.

full

@TheoV Northern treeshrews have lost all their treeshrew competition in Europe

Species lost

Pygmy treeshrew - Tupaia minor B4*
A tree shrew that was only kept in the UK in the past 100 years. The species bred in London Zoo and in Thrigby Hall Wildlife Gardens and was kept in 2 other zoos too. First breeding was achieved in 1994 and the final animals perished in the early 2000s in Thrigby.

Status uncertain

Large treeshrew - Tupaia tana B4*?
This century kept in a few UK zoos and bred in Newquay Zoo, with the last animal kept until 2010 in Thrigby Hall Wildlife Gardens. It is unclear whether this species was already kept at the start of the century, as the earliest evidence in Zootierliste dates from 2004, but is inconclusive. I personally think it is likely that this species was already kept in the UK in the 1990s, but based on current data in Zootierliste that can't be said with certainty. Additional online research didn’t yield much.

Common treeshrew - Tupaia glis ??
This species was kept in the 20th century, but northern treeshrews were often listed as Tupaia glis too, given they were for some time considered conspecifics. These misidentifications still occur in zoos currently keeping northern treeshrew, which means it is hard to be sure which species was kept in former holdings. Alleged common treeshrew holdings in the 21st century were in Zoo Magdeburg until 2001, Zoo Saarbruecken until 2002 and Pistoia Zoo, Italy, until 2012, Zoo Zagreb until 2010 and the former Ruhr Zoo Gelsenkirchen until 2000. Which zoos truly kept common treeshrew cannot be identified, but I think it is likely that most, if not all, of these holdings were in fact northern treeshrews.

full

@Maguari Listed as a northern treeshrew on Zootierliste, but signed as a common treeshrew in Tropical World in Leeds some 13 years ago. Confusing stuff indeed, I would say this is a northern treeshrew though.


With the treeshrews we have reached the end of the 1st of 5 blocks of mammals, so before we move on to the primates there will be a recap on the orders covered so far. Although we have covered the majority of orders by now, the four most speciose orders are still to come and these will make up the bulk of the remaining posts.

full

@gentle lemur Large treeshrews were present in the UK during multiple decades, but were they kept continually?

Progress
14/22 orders completed
24/106 families completed
49-51 species present in 2000
62 species present in 2023
33-34 species gained since 2000
20-22 species lost since 2000
 
Large treeshrew - Tupaia tana B4*?
I personally think it is likely that this species was already kept in the UK in the 1990s, but based on current data in Zootierliste that can't be said with certainty.
This species was certainly kept in the UK during the 1990s; they were kept at London Zoo throughout that decade.

(The first large treeshrews to be bred in the UK were born at London Zoo in 1973.)
 
This species was certainly kept in the UK during the 1990s; they were kept at London Zoo throughout that decade.

(The first large treeshrews to be bred in the UK were born at London Zoo in 1973.)

Thanks, I assumed so but good to know for sure. I will adapt it in the future posts.
 
SUMMARISING EXOTIC MAMMAL ORDERS

With over half of all mammal orders completed it is time for the first summarising post. While the orders treated until now come from all over the mammal tree, they have one thing in common: none of them has any native species in Europe currently (bar humans for the nitpickers). With the exception of some marsupial families they are also mostly very species poor lineages with often unique adaptations. These unique adaptations have probably saved them once rodents, carnivores, primates and hoofed mammals started to spread and take over. These mammals are often favourites among zoochatters in general, and the species hunters in particular.

While it might sound surprising, the interest from zoos in exotic looking smaller mammals has grown considerably this century, despite many of them not being crowd favourites or ABC mammals. There has been a ~20% increase in the number of species held in Europe this century and many of the families covered have gained a considerable number of holders. This was generally expected for marsupials, which have seen a significant increase in species numbers as well as a spread of some formerly rare species. Xenarthrans were also expected to have gained popularity and while there were no species gains a few of the xenarthrans have become increasingly common. Largely unexpected seems to be the rise of the afrotherians, with an increase from 10 to 14 species held and clear increases in holders for the majority of families. This was hardly picked up in the survey, though.

full

@JaxElephant The rise of the hyrax might have been a surprise

Increased understanding of husbandry of previously difficult animals such as anteaters and aardvarks has most certainly helped. Hyraxes, aardvarks, manatees, anteaters, sloths, armadillos, echidnas, dasyurids, wombats, koalas and pangolins are all more widespread than they used to be 23 years ago. The rise of the giant anteater is particularly remarkable, going from relatively uncommon to over 80 holders. Treeshrews and sugar gliders are the only 2 families bucking the trend, with both having a clear net loss in terms of species held.

There is also a trend that enough zoos are moving away from the most commonly kept species in favour of less kept similar species so that several previously rare species are now more common. This is most clear with macropods, where an increasing number of zoos that either replace their red-necked wallaby with a rarer kangaroo species or add a second species to their kangaroo exhibit. This has led to clear growth in the population of a few rarer macropods such as swamp wallaby and yellow-footed rock wallaby. There are still plenty of “superfluous” red-necked or red kangaroo holders which for diversity's sake would best switch to a different species. There are of-course plenty of zoos sticking with the easiest option, but enough aren't to make a difference. This trend is also there in other groups and we will see it multiple times this thread.

full

@Fat-tailed dwarf lemur A red-necked wallaby ripe for replacement

It seems a bit strange that all these animals have increased in popularity, while mammal diversity in many big zoos has decreased. Whereas the historical major zoos have almost without exception shrunk their mammal collection, this is at least partly counterbalanced by the growth of the number of zoos and the rise of new superstars like Pairi Daiza and Zooparc de Beauval which both were relatively unassuming places in 2000. While major zoos themselves have moved away from a post stamp collection, there still seems to be an interest in maintaining higher taxonomic diversity. So these more “obscure” groups do profit from enough zoos that take an interest in displaying new families and orders instead of rows of similar species. Many of the smaller species in these orders have the advantage that they can relatively easily be mixed with other species and with such mixed-species exhibits becoming ever more common, a place for species like hyraxes, bettongs and armadillos is basically assured in such setups

There are, like is always the case, a few zoos for which normal is not enough. Zoo Ostrava seems obsessed with tree hyraxes and Zoo Hamerton with marsupials. But their enthusiasm has in several cases spread to other zoos and a species like rufous bettong has gone from absent to 10 zoos in a matter of years. It remains to be seen whether most imports can be sustained as the rufous elephant shrew history shows that booms and bust can follow each other quite quickly.

full

@Alwaysevergreen Hamerton Zoo Park seems to have a insatiable love for marsupials and brushtail possums in particular

An interesting observation, which might stem from the rise of the geographically ordered zoo, is that Australian fauna is becoming more widespread than before. Echidnas, wombats, koalas, Tasmanian devils and the smaller creatures are all gaining popularity as more zoos make an effort to do an Australian zoo with more than a few parrots, emus and kangaroos. The animals are in recent years often (partly) sourced from Australia A highlight of that is the new Australia house in Wilhelma, Stuttgart, which houses 10 marsupials and with the import of quokka has managed to gain a new species for Europe, just a pity for us that the planned import of fat-tailed dunnarts to Stuttgart did not happen. I am not sure whether Australia has loosened its export policies or that more zoos are willing to do the paperwork? Back in 2000 it was probably Dierenpark Planckendael in Mechelen, Belgium with the most extensive Australian area. Nowadays there is plenty of competition for that prize from Duisburg to Copenhagen and from Stuttgart to Budapest.

Looking ahead it will be interesting to see whether this Australian craze will continue. I personally think it will and it isn’t impossible that we will have either platypus or long-beaked echidna arrive within 10-20 years, the latter either through confiscations or with purposefully wild-caught individuals. With smaller mammals there have always been surprises and I see no reason why that wouldn’t happen in the near future. These surprises seem more likely to come from non-EAZA zoos or from countries with a long history of importing new species, such as Czechia. But even household names such as Zoo Leipzig, Wilhelma and Zoo Copenhagen are active in the marsupial importing business.

full

@WhistlingKite24 Platypus as the next European target?

Next up are the primates, which are one of those orders which tend to be well represented in basically any mainstream zoo.

Progress
14/22 orders completed
24/106 families completed
50-51 species present in 2000
62 species present in 2023
33 species gained since 2000
21-22 species lost since 2000
 
I recall I often joked in 2019 when Hamerton was at the peak of their Australia craze that sooner or later they would get a platypus as the ultimate.
Perhaps not Hamerton.... but seeing recent developments in Australian fauna the idea of a platypus [or several] coming to the continent doesn't seem entirely ridiculous now!
 
Treeshrews and sugar gliders are the only 2 families bucking the trend, with both having a clear net loss in terms of species held.

Strange, as Sugar gliders gained recently popularity as "pets" (many videos seen on internet)

I am not sure whether Australia has loosened its export policies or that more zoos are willing to do the paperwork?

The imports from Australia have probably been made easier, but not in the sense of a deregulation. It's more a conservation strategy that aims to build breeding populations (or, at least, "ambassador animals") out of Australia.
The Tasmanian Devils and Quolls are a good example of such policies.
The Koalas are a bad example, as most of them have been sourced from the US (where they were quite frequent at the end of last century). Nonetheless the presence of this species in many zoos has probably been an incentive to have more Australian/Oceanian species : in the case of Beauval I think to Tree Kangaroos (up to 2 species), Bettongs (breeding but extremely elusive and unseen by the visitors), then Tasmanian Devils.


Looking ahead it will be interesting to see whether this Australian craze will continue. I personally think it will and it isn’t impossible that we will have either platypus or long-beaked echidna arrive within 10-20 years, the latter either through confiscations or with purposefully wild-caught individuals.

It can really be expected for the Platypus, as it is one of the rare mammal species that everybody knows, but that no one (out of Australia) have seen in real life.
 
It isn't the biggest surprise, that small mammals do easier on this topic than big mammals.

Next up are the primates, which are one of those orders which tend to be well represented in basically any mainstream zoo.

After seeing the result of the starting survey, primates are probably the most exciting group to see what's happening. Maybe both answers are somehow correct, as lemurs and smaller primates are increasing, while medium sized primates are decreasing.
 
Interestingly, this thread also show changes in what are the best zoos on the continent.

I would intuitively expect that new, remarkable animals would first appear in some big, old zoo with lots of experience, probably in some big and wealthy city. But from new holders, perhaps only Copenhagen, Leipzig, Stuttgart and Prague are what can be called an old big city zoo.

Zoos which actually acquired new species are mostly small zoos, most are relatively new zoos and a good proportion are in so-called post-communist Europe. New species first appeared in RSCC, Plzen, Bernburg, Besancon, Halle, Hamerton, Beauval, BestZoo, Poznan Nowe Zoo or Ostrava.
 
Really good and often expectation-subverting thread!

I look forward to the rundown of the primates given that EAZA to my knowledge have established phase-outs for quite a few species of those (at least macaques and gibbons). It's not necessarily much help that the zoos themselves strive more for diversity than previously thought if their superiors won't allow it.
 
Back
Top