Trends in European zoo collections in the 21st century

The decline of Babirusa can be explained easy. For some ecological reason they have losed the typical hyperfertility of other pigs. There isn't a litter but 1/2 pups. Also for their naked skin they are more susceptible at skin issue.

The other pigs simply go for exponential increase
 
The decline of Babirusa can be explained easy. For some ecological reason they have losed the typical hyperfertility of other pigs. There isn't a litter but 1/2 pups. Also for their naked skin they are more susceptible at skin issue.

The other pigs simply go for exponential increase

The small litter size is not something that happened at once in 2000 and was solved in 2015 though. So while it might explain why their population grows at a lower pace compared to other pigs, it doesn't explain the near-collapse of the population and then the recovery afterwards. The problem seems to lie more with an aging population in the early 2000s, which was only turned around with import of new blood from the US and establishment of harem groups (1 male + multiple females), which improved breeding.

I might be mistaken, but I've heard that these are not purebred Celebensis.

Source? They used to be signed as Babyrousa babyrussa , as in Moluccan babirusa, but that just reflects that babirusa were split into 3 species and zoos were slow to catch up, which might be part of the confusion? I have never heard that they aren't pure Sulawesi babirusa.
 
The small litter size is not something that happened at once in 2000 and was solved in 2015 though. So while it might explain why their population grows at a lower pace compared to other pigs, it doesn't explain the near-collapse of the population and then the recovery afterwards. The problem seems to lie more with an aging population in the early 2000s, which was only turned around with import of new blood from the US and establishment of harem groups (1 male + multiple females), which improved breeding.



Source? They used to be signed as Babyrousa babyrussa , as in Moluccan babirusa, but that just reflects that babirusa were split into 3 species and zoos were slow to catch up, which might be part of the confusion? I have never heard that they aren't pure Sulawesi babirusa.
When looking to ZIMS (which sometimes also has its inaccuracies) there are 26 B. babyrussa and 17 B. celebencis + 9 no species assigned individuals. Berlin Tierpark and Chester have the 3 types of them.
 
When looking to ZIMS (which sometimes also has its inaccuracies) there are 26 B. babyrussa and 17 B. celebencis + 9 no species assigned individuals. Berlin Tierpark and Chester have the 3 types of them.

Especially when it comes to taxonomy of somewhat recent splits, ZIMS is often extremely unreliable, so I wouldn't put too much trust in that.
 
Source? They used to be signed as Babyrousa babyrussa , as in Moluccan babirusa, but that just reflects that babirusa were split into 3 species and zoos were slow to catch up, which might be part of the confusion? I have never heard that they aren't pure Sulawesi babirusa.
There was something about one of the founder animals being from the Togian Islands (from memory), which was only discovered quite recently through DNA testing of the captive population. I'm not sure of its authenticity.
 
When looking to ZIMS (which sometimes also has its inaccuracies) there are 26 B. babyrussa and 17 B. celebencis + 9 no species assigned individuals. Berlin Tierpark and Chester have the 3 types of them.
That is just a data artifact from some holders using the split name and others the pre-split name. It doesn't actually signify that the population is made up of different (sub)species.
 
Number of zoos kept (current and former during the holding period):
A 1 zoo
B 2-5 zoos
C 6-10 zoos
D >10 zoos

Time period kept:
1 < 1 year
2 1-5 years
3 6-10 years
4 11-20 years
5 > 20 years

* Species successfully bred
♱ Dead end (in case of species gained)
↑ Species gaining popularity (in case of species gained)


Hippopotamuses - Hippopotamidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 2
# Species kept currently: 2
# Species gained: -
# Species lost: -


Both species of this family are present in Europe and have been so for a long time, but they are each on a different trajectory.

full

@Swedish Zoo Fan Tiny hippo exhibits in city zoos are increasingly a sign of the past


Species gaining popularity

Pygmy hippo - Choeropsis liberiensis
These pocket hippos have 2 advantages as opposed to their larger cousins: they are small and endangered. That is more than enough reason for zoos either to switch from the big to the small or when starting with hippos, to just get the smaller version. They are much cheaper and space effective to provide for and the general public still sees a (baby) hippo.

full

@betsy Despite a lack of males, because of a bias for females in spermatozoa the zoo population of pygmy hippos is slowly growing


Species losing popularity

Common hippo - Hippopotamus amphibius
The common hippo is not so common anymore in major zoos as it used to be. No big zoo used to be complete without them and they can be kept very “effectively” in tiny pools. However, in an era where welfare has become important they have become one of the most expensive animals to provide a good home for. For big zoos to continue with hippos, new developments often include underwater viewing, which given their preference to poop in water means you need very expensive filtration. Even with that filtration, getting clear water is not a given. That means that for many larger zoos this species is slowly disappearing, except in Spain and Italy. Given how hard it is to find space for young animals, breeding is also halted in many zoos, which means that the population is slowly aging too. There is still a future as large or extremely rich zoos still make an effort for this species, but fortunately the US trend of extremely expensive new hippo habitats that are often inadequate, isn’t followed in Europe.

full

@lintworm A few hippos are already hard enough to provide for, so large pods, such as this one in Tanzania, are basically absent in captivity

Progress
21/22 orders completed
97/106 families completed
521-530 species present in 2000
539-542 species present in 2023
222-231 species gained this century
211-215 species lost this century
 
Number of zoos kept (current and former during the holding period):
A 1 zoo
B 2-5 zoos
C 6-10 zoos
D >10 zoos

Time period kept:
1 < 1 year
2 1-5 years
3 6-10 years
4 11-20 years
5 > 20 years

* Species successfully bred
♱ Dead end (in case of species gained)
↑ Species gaining popularity (in case of species gained)


Hippopotamuses - Hippopotamidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 2
# Species kept currently: 2
# Species gained: -
# Species lost: -


Both species of this family are present in Europe and have been so for a long time, but they are each on a different trajectory.

full

@Swedish Zoo Fan Tiny hippo exhibits in city zoos are increasingly a sign of the past


Species gaining popularity

Pygmy hippo - Choeropsis liberiensis
These pocket hippos have 2 advantages as opposed to their larger cousins: they are small and endangered. That is more than enough reason for zoos either to switch from the big to the small or when starting with hippos, to just get the smaller version. They are much cheaper and space effective to provide for and the general public still sees a (baby) hippo.

full

@betsy Despite a lack of males, because of a bias for females in spermatozoa the zoo population of pygmy hippos is slowly growing


Species losing popularity

Common hippo - Hippopotamus amphibius
The common hippo is not so common anymore in major zoos as it used to be. No big zoo used to be complete without them and they can be kept very “effectively” in tiny pools. However, in an era where welfare has become important they have become one of the most expensive animals to provide a good home for. For big zoos to continue with hippos, new developments often include underwater viewing, which given their preference to poop in water means you need very expensive filtration. Even with that filtration, getting clear water is not a given. That means that for many larger zoos this species is slowly disappearing, except in Spain and Italy. Given how hard it is to find space for young animals, breeding is also halted in many zoos, which means that the population is slowly aging too. There is still a future as large or extremely rich zoos still make an effort for this species, but fortunately the US trend of extremely expensive new hippo habitats that are often inadequate, isn’t followed in Europe.

full

@lintworm A few hippos are already hard enough to provide for, so large pods, such as this one in Tanzania, are basically absent in captivity

Progress
21/22 orders completed
97/106 families completed
521-530 species present in 2000
539-542 species present in 2023
222-231 species gained this century
211-215 species lost this century
The sex bias in pygmy hippos is not only because of the spermatozoa but also because male calves have higher mortality rates than females, which is not clear why.
Another husbandry challenge associated with hippos is managing their complex sociality, which in a limited amount of space like a zoo, means that many holders simply choose to not breed them. The decline in common hippo is observed in its global captive population, not only in Europe.
 
Giraffes - Giraffidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 5
# Species kept currently: 4 (-1)
# Species gained: -
# Species lost: -


This would have been an easier chapter to write if @DavidBrown and others wouldn’t have published a study in 2007 proclaiming there is more than 1 giraffe species. But he did and the consensus view is that there are 3-4 giraffe species (+okapi). The main point of discussion now being whether reticulated giraffes constitute a different species, which in the Mammal Diversity Database is the case. At the start of the century all 5 giraffe species were present in Europe and the survival of 3 is all but guaranteed. The southern giraffe (Giraffa giraffa) is more of a questionmark, while the nominate subspecies will likely disappear, several southern European zoos are clinging on to Angolan giraffe (ssp angolensis), with some 15 animals remaining and Lisbon still breeding the species. Non (sub)specific giraffes are still around in EAZA zoos, but most are in single-sex groups and much of the others on birth control in mixed herds. Within EAZA they are set to become extremely rare within 10-20 years, though non-EAZA zoos remain to breed generic giraffes.

full

@lintworm Though the status of separate species is still debated, it isn't debated that reticulated giraffes are easily the second most common giraffe in European zoos


Species lost

Maasai giraffe - Giraffa tippelskirchi D5*
While Maasai giraffe were regularly imported in the 20th century, they didn’t establish a large population and the main holder in the final decades was Zoo Basel, which kept and bred the species from 1947-2011. This breeding group slowly died out and when the final bull passed away, this species was phased out. The final animals were sent to Turkey and Zoo Antwerp, where the final animal died in 2015.

full

@Maguari While now absent from Europe, Maasai giraffe are still common in North America

Species gaining popularity

Okapi - Okapia johnstoni
These forest giraffes were among the last large mammals to be discovered and in the 20th century they were something of a status symbol for the big city zoos that did keep them. The number of holders has doubled since 2000 and as such it is not the prestigious animal it once was, but still one that plenty of zoos are interested in.

Northern giraffe - Giraffa camelopardalis
Two subspecies of this species are managed in Europe, the Rotschildt’s giraffe (ssp. rothschildi) and the Kordofan giraffe (ssp. antiquorum). The former has long been the most commonly kept giraffe in Europe, whereas the latter was long one of the rarest giraffe taxa. In recent years interest in Kordofan giraffe has grown considerably, also outside of France which is still the stronghold. The status as the rarest giraffe that is actively managed and not listed as a phase-out probably helps. All Kordofan giraffes derive from the (inbred) herds of Zoo Antwerp and Paris Zoo de Vincennes. For decades the Vincennes animals were listed as W-African giraffes (ssp peralta), but in the age of genetics is became clear that the range of true peralta was much smaller then previously thought. Both lineages had already been mixed before that was clear, but the European animals remain a pure subspecies.

full

@Therabu While losing some of their prestige, Okapi remain on of the poster boys for the African rainforest

Progress
21/22 orders completed
98/106 families completed
526-535 species present in 2000
543-546 species present in 2023
222-231 species gained this century
212-216 species lost this century
 
For my experience the needs of common hippo are overrated. If you really study how they live, the hardest to stabulate in opportune condition are the pygmy. I have never seen a pygmy hippo. But i passed a lot of time with the commons. I have a pair of shoes that smell of hippo poops.

And well they simply stay in the pool. They interact eachother in the pool. And sleep in the pool. Eazybizy. The real problem can be the breeding because you need two different enclosure and someone that take the newborn when he grow.

But in the end they only need a decent size pool. Not small. But not an entire swamp. The ground part is rarely used at best. Someday they go in the pool the morning and go out when the indoor are opened. And yes the animal welfare Is important, but in reality, of big animals they are the species that in nature occupy less space for individual.

For what i have experienced they are the perfect big animals for medium/small size zoo. The problem is find a way to make them viewable in the pool.
 
For my experience the needs of common hippo are overrated. If you really study how they live, the hardest to stabulate in opportune condition are the pygmy. I have never seen a pygmy hippo. But i passed a lot of time with the commons. I have a pair of shoes that smell of hippo poops.

And well they simply stay in the pool. They interact eachother in the pool. And sleep in the pool. Eazybizy. The real problem can be the breeding because you need two different enclosure and someone that take the newborn when he grow.

But in the end they only need a decent size pool. Not small. But not an entire swamp. The ground part is rarely used at best. Someday they go in the pool the morning and go out when the indoor are opened. And yes the animal welfare Is important, but in reality, of big animals they are the species that in nature occupy less space for individual.

For what I have experienced they are the perfect big animals for medium/small size zoo. The problem is find a way to make them viewable in the pool.

I do not have your experience with hippos in captivity as a simple zoo goer but your analysis show a few bias in my opinion :

- what does hippo do at night ? In Africa they will roam quite extensively and offering them decent space to roam at night or even during the day, maybe even scater the food like we do for elephants would maybe enhance welfare.
- hippos are social and live in large groups. There is very few zoos who tried to exhibit them accordingly. In this regard, pygmy hippos are much easier to exhibit.
 
For my experience the needs of common hippo are overrated. If you really study how they live, the hardest to stabulate in opportune condition are the pygmy. I have never seen a pygmy hippo. But i passed a lot of time with the commons. I have a pair of shoes that smell of hippo poops.

And well they simply stay in the pool. They interact eachother in the pool. And sleep in the pool. Eazybizy. The real problem can be the breeding because you need two different enclosure and someone that take the newborn when he grow.

But in the end they only need a decent size pool. Not small. But not an entire swamp. The ground part is rarely used at best. Someday they go in the pool the morning and go out when the indoor are opened. And yes the animal welfare Is important, but in reality, of big animals they are the species that in nature occupy less space for individual.

For what i have experienced they are the perfect big animals for medium/small size zoo. The problem is find a way to make them viewable in the pool.
Your view of hippo welfare is poorly informed.
Actually, hippo welfare is often overlooked and neglected compared to other large mammals like elephants, rhinos or giraffes.
Hippos require a vast amount of space to be housed in a correct social group and enclosures must have an even water/land ratio. Most hippo holders are not reaching the enclosure size standards necessary for a naturalistic group size, and neither the appropriate group sizes exist at all or are very rare. Moreover, indoor or overnight facilities are recommended to be large enough to allow the animals to stay active since hippos feed and move extensively during the night. They can walk around several kilometres in just one night to feed. This idea that hippos do all their life inside water is completely outdated. In northern countries, they do not even go into the water if this is too cold. And many facilities have limited land area or overnight foraging and activity to offer (Tennant et al., 2018). This lack of behavioural opportunities might be the reason why many captive hippos are obese (of course together with an incorrect diet). And overweight is why females reach sexual maturity much earlier than in the wild; which also makes breeding management difficult. Even the poor water quality in which the animals many times have to spend all day has been associated with skin problems in hippos.
Hippos are easy to display, breed and maintain in captivity, but give them optimal welfare not so much. And zoos should strive for the latter. Having a viable well-managed breeding population is another big challenge.

Tennant, K. S., Segura, V. D., Morris, M. C., Snyder, K. D., Bocian, D., Maloney, D., & Maple, T. L. (2018). Achieving optimal welfare for the Nile hippopotamus (Hippopotamus amphibius) in North American zoos and aquariums. Behavioural Processes, 156, 51-57.
 
Giraffes - Giraffidae
# Species kept 1-1-2000: 5
# Species kept currently: 4 (-1)
# Species gained: -
# Species lost: -


This would have been an easier chapter to write if @DavidBrown and others wouldn’t have published a study in 2007 proclaiming there is more than 1 giraffe species. But he did and the consensus view is that there are 3-4 giraffe species (+okapi). The main point of discussion now being whether reticulated giraffes constitute a different species, which in the Mammal Diversity Database is the case. At the start of the century all 5 giraffe species were present in Europe and the survival of 3 is all but guaranteed. The southern giraffe (Giraffa giraffa) is more of a questionmark, while the nominate subspecies will likely disappear, several southern European zoos are clinging on to Angolan giraffe (ssp angolensis), with some 15 animals remaining and Lisbon still breeding the species. Non (sub)specific giraffes are still around in EAZA zoos, but most are in single-sex groups and much of the others on birth control in mixed herds. Within EAZA they are set to become extremely rare within 10-20 years, though non-EAZA zoos remain to breed generic giraffes.

full

@lintworm Though the status of separate species is still debated, it isn't debated that reticulated giraffes are easily the second most common giraffe in European zoos


Species lost

Maasai giraffe - Giraffa tippelskirchi D5*
While Maasai giraffe were regularly imported in the 20th century, they didn’t establish a large population and the main holder in the final decades was Zoo Basel, which kept and bred the species from 1947-2011. This breeding group slowly died out and when the final bull passed away, this species was phased out. The final animals were sent to Turkey and Zoo Antwerp, where the final animal died in 2015.

full

@Maguari While now absent from Europe, Maasai giraffe are still common in North America

Species gaining popularity

Okapi - Okapia johnstoni
These forest giraffes were among the last large mammals to be discovered and in the 20th century they were something of a status symbol for the big city zoos that did keep them. The number of holders has doubled since 2000 and as such it is not the prestigious animal it once was, but still one that plenty of zoos are interested in.

Northern giraffe - Giraffa camelopardalis
Two subspecies of this species are managed in Europe, the Rotschildt’s giraffe (ssp. rothschildi) and the Kordofan giraffe (ssp. antiquorum). The former has long been the most commonly kept giraffe in Europe, whereas the latter was long one of the rarest giraffe taxa. In recent years interest in Kordofan giraffe has grown considerably, also outside of France which is still the stronghold. The status as the rarest giraffe that is actively managed and not listed as a phase-out probably helps. All Kordofan giraffes derive from the (inbred) herds of Zoo Antwerp and Paris Zoo de Vincennes. For decades the Vincennes animals were listed as W-African giraffes (ssp peralta), but in the age of genetics is became clear that the range of true peralta was much smaller then previously thought. Both lineages had already been mixed before that was clear, but the European animals remain a pure subspecies.

full

@Therabu While losing some of their prestige, Okapi remain on of the poster boys for the African rainforest

Progress
21/22 orders completed
98/106 families completed
526-535 species present in 2000
543-546 species present in 2023
222-231 species gained this century
212-216 species lost this century
In my clearly biased opinion, :p okapis are still a very prestigious species. I would say that what changed is that this species is no longer a victim of a certain elitism from the old, prestigious and rich city zoos. This is due to a change in the person in charge of the EEP and the way the population is being managed, where smaller zoos that want to be highly committed to the species long-term, contribute financially to the okapi conservation project and build high-standard enclosures, overpass big city zoos in the waiting list. A good decision in my opinion. This is also how you help smaller collections to become bigger.
 
To be honest i wanted to be a little bit provocative ;)

Conservation is indeed very important. If every EEP with a sexy species wants EEP participants to fundraise also ex situ projects there will be a lack of money on species that aren't as shiny.
 
To be honest i wanted to be a little bit provocative ;)

Conservation is indeed very important. If every EEP with a sexy species wants EEP participants to fundraise also ex situ projects there will be a lack of money on species that aren't as shiny.
We are talking about a very specific case. It is far from being the standard among EEPs. The DRC is a very poor country and the okapi is a poorly known species from the general public. Zoos have been key partners to the OCP either promoting the species or financing the project. Zoos are responsible for between one quarter to one third of the budget of the OCP.
 
Your view of hippo welfare is poorly informed.
Actually, hippo welfare is often overlooked and neglected compared to other large mammals like elephants, rhinos or giraffes.
Hippos require a vast amount of space to be housed in a correct social group and enclosures must have an even water/land ratio. Most hippo holders are not reaching the enclosure size standards necessary for a naturalistic group size, and neither the appropriate group sizes exist at all or are very rare. Moreover, indoor or overnight facilities are recommended to be large enough to allow the animals to stay active since hippos feed and move extensively during the night. They can walk around several kilometres in just one night to feed. This idea that hippos do all their life inside water is completely outdated. In northern countries, they do not even go into the water if this is too cold. And many facilities have limited land area or overnight foraging and activity to offer (Tennant et al., 2018). This lack of behavioural opportunities might be the reason why many captive hippos are obese (of course together with an incorrect diet). And overweight is why females reach sexual maturity much earlier than in the wild; which also makes breeding management difficult. Even the poor water quality in which the animals many times have to spend all day has been associated with skin problems in hippos.
Hippos are easy to display, breed and maintain in captivity, but give them optimal welfare not so much. And zoos should strive for the latter. Having a viable well-managed breeding population is another big challenge.

Tennant, K. S., Segura, V. D., Morris, M. C., Snyder, K. D., Bocian, D., Maloney, D., & Maple, T. L. (2018). Achieving optimal welfare for the Nile hippopotamus (Hippopotamus amphibius) in North American zoos and aquariums. Behavioural Processes, 156, 51-57.

I completely agree with you, but I have seen plenty of common hippos in the wild in pools/puddles that make Stuttgart/Frankfurt/Artis/Kronberg/Leipzig look spacious. Many pods in the wild also seem to consist of only 2-4 individuals, but that seems more limited by available water than what they actually want. In a way these small enclosures and small groups fit what is going on in the wild (though at night they can of-course roam much further).

Displaying hippos optimally in areas with proper winters is really though and I haven't seen a single indoor enclosure for them yet with appropriate amounts of land area...

In my clearly biased opinion, :p okapis are still a very prestigious species. I would say that what changed is that this species is no longer a victim of a certain elitism from the old, prestigious and rich city zoos. This is due to a change in the person in charge of the EEP and the way the population is being managed, where smaller zoos that want to be highly committed to the species long-term, contribute financially to the okapi conservation project and build high-standard enclosures, overpass big city zoos in the waiting list. A good decision in my opinion. This is also how you help smaller collections to become bigger.

Okapi are still a prestigious species indeed (though rarity is part of the prestige and that is lacking now), but they aren't limited to the old-boys network anymore, which is indeed a good sign.

Together with chimpanzee/bonobo it is basically the only ABC/prestige species that Pairi Daiza will lack once the new tropical hall is completed. But will be interesting to see how cooperative the EEP-studbook holder will be with their main rivals :p

This one point is a quite unfair solution in my eyes and in my opinion EAZA shouldn't allow EEPs things like this.

IIRC the contribution is something like 5.000 euros which is (or should be) peanuts. It is an exception, but there are other EEPs that function similarly like red panda and black-footed penguin.
 
Back
Top