European (Tea)Cup - League A - Zurich vs Artis

Zurich vs Artis - ISLANDS

  • Zurich 5/0 Artis

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Artis 3/2 Zurich

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Artis 4/1 Zurich

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Artis 5/0 Zurich

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    22
  • Poll closed .

TeaLovingDave

Moderator
Staff member
15+ year member
And so we come to the final League A match, and although both competitors can go no further within the Cup, they each have one last chance to prove themselves and leave with their heads held high.

The category is one which everyone should be very familiar with by now - ISLANDS AND AUSTRALIA. I hope everyone enjoys the match to come!
 
I'd posit that there are very few zoos in the competition stronger than Zürich in this category. Arguably the greatest zoo exhibit on the planet, and certainly the best replication of a rainforest ever achieved by a zoo in a temperate climate, Masoala Regenwald, counts in its entirety here (EDIT: I thought the consensus was that, while Bush is better in some aspects, Masoala is more successful in recreating a particular ecosystem, although if some disagree, then apologies for trying to objectively assert this). Very few experiences offered by zoos can surpass the thrill of watching lemurs emerge from the foliage after patiently watching a rustling branch, or having huge geckos scurry across your path.

Aside from Masoala, the Australia zone is also of a very high standard. It is a shame they no longer have Perenties, but even still there is a reptilian, island-based (though not Australian) rarity, the Exuma Island Iguana. Being in a walkthrough space with Emus is also a rare treat (much more common with rheas, of course), and throughout the complex the use of bright red rock, as well as the main pavilion being, I believe, a replica of the Sydney Opera House, further enhance the experience.

Zürich was also the first zoo in Europe to breed Galapagos Giant Tortoise, and to this day has seen by far the most success of any such collection. Some subspecies-pure individuals, as well as hybrids, inhabit a very nice enclosure. I am not sure if we can count the excellent coral reef aquariums (the most aesthetically pleasing such ones that I have seen, more so than even Burgers') in the Exotarium here, as they also counted for Asia, but several of the inhabitants do have the coasts of island nations as part of their range. Elsewhere in the Exotarium, the Lesser Antillean Iguanas, something of a rarity, should count too, as well as Red-tailed Ratsnakes, Fiji Banded Iguanas, Yellow-headed ay Geckos and Reticulated Pythons. And then there are the tiny, beautiful and endangered Tiger Chameleons, the only ones in Europe and one of Zürich's best rarities!

That said, all this excellence is somewhat dampened by the atrocious orangutan enclosure in the Ape House, and the rather mediocre gibbon enclosure in the same building. Depending on how much each voter thinks these low points detract from the excellence elsewhere, Artis may have a lifeline. As I know very little about what the Dutch collection has on offer here, I remain fully open to changing my vote based on future discussion, but for now I am voting 4-1 to Zürich.

A shame that poor luck with key closures and narrow losses mean that Zürich is out regardless of this result, but on the bright side that has facilitated quite the underdog story with Paris making it into the final twelve!
 
Last edited:
I am not big fan of Zurich's Australian zone, but Masoala's advantage in this game is unquestionable. Artis is not completely naked here and is important to mention they're Lemur Walktrough exhibit and the Sumatran Minangkabause House. I will be more careful and vote 3:2 for Zurich.

Zurich actually have chance to qualify and Panthera is already open, so they can perform even better on the semifinals.
 
Some quick thoughts on Zurich which I visited in 2022

I've certainly never been more impressed with an ordinary walk-through enclosure for Emu and Red-necked wallaby than I was in Zurich. Thematically it's spot on.

I guess the gelada baboon won't count as an 'island in the sky' species?

Other island species include Cuban grassquit, Jamaican Ring-tailed pigeon, Blue-headed Quail-dove, Montserrat Oriole, Bali myna, Western crowned pigeon, Mountain chicken, Lesser Antillean iguana (Exotarium), Northern Koala, Savu Python and Western Wyolie (Australia), Sumatran Orangutan,

And then there is Zurich's collection of giant tortoise (sub)species. And a whole bunch of species in Masoala.

At the time of my last visit, they had quite a good number of island anoles, but these all seem to be out of collection in 2024.
 
Last edited:
Zurich, in fact, has even more to offer pertaining to the category of this match than what has already been mentioned:

  • In the Australia house the - by far - best planted and most naturalistic Koala indoor enclosures I have seen anywhere, one of which also houses woylies / brush-tailed bettongs (Bettongia penicillata).
full

Second, larger Koala enclosure


full

First Koala enclosure that also houses woylies.

  • A large and beautifully landscaped enclosure for Exuma Island Iguana also in the Australia house.

full

ca. half of the Exuma island iguana enclosure

  • The emu and Bennet-wallaby Australia walkthrough.
  • King penguins in the exotarium. Notable features here include a rotation concept with the kings held indoors during summer and outdoors in winter, live prey as behavioral enrichment in the indoors enclosure, and daily penguin walkabouts through the zoo grounds in winter.
  • A sizeable Madagascan gecko collection in the terrarium section of the exotarium with Phelsuma standingi, Phelsuma inexpectata, Phelsuma breviceps, and Phelsuma klemmeri as well as Paroedura lohatsara (in addition to Phelsuma grandis, Uroplatus fimbriatus, Madagascar girdled lizard, and panther chameleon free-ranging in Masoala), mostly in outstandingly landscaped vivaria.
  • Lesser Antillean Iguana, Red-tailed Ratsnake, Fiji Banded Iguana, Reisinger's tree monitor, tiger chameleon, and blue-spotted tree monitor in the terrarium section of the exotarium (the reticulate python has left the collection).
  • A new focus on endangered (and obscure - at least to me) Madagascan fishes in the sweetwater aquaria of the exotarium, including one of the research stations in the exotarium and - I believe - also the water bodies in Masoala with the following species: Pachypanchax varatraza (an Aplocheilid killifish), Ptychochromis oligacanthus (a cichlid endemic to Nosy Be), Pachypanchax sakaramyi (another endemic Aplocheilid killifish), red-tailed silverside (Bedotia geayi), pinstripe menarambo (Paretroplus menarambo), Paratilapia polleni ( endemic cichlid), Mangahara cichlid (Ptychochromis insolitus), powder-blue panchax (Pachypanchax omalonot), Bedotia madagascariensis, Ptychochromis loisellei (cichlid), as well as further island species humpbacked limia, and harlequin rasbora
full

Exotarium 'research station' on breeding endangered Madagascan fishes
  • The reef aquaria in the exotarium.
full

  • Lake Kutubu rainbowfish in the Galapagos tortoise house together with a breeding group of the name-giving reptiles.
  • Mountain chicken / giant ditch frog, Mantella expectata, and Blommersia transmarina in the terrarium section of the exotarium (in addition to tomato frog and false tomato frog in Masoala).
  • Montserrat oriole, blue-headed quail dove, crested quail-dove, western crowned pigeon, and swift parrot in the open, walk-in 'aviary' of the exotarium.
  • Crested partridge in the ape house, as well as a breeding group of Orang-Utan (the only low point in the list), the pileated gibbon are not an island species.
  • Rainbow lorikeet in a pleasant walk-in aviary with a large connected outdoor aviary.
  • Red junglefowld free ranging and Bali myna in the aviary as well as red devil vampire crab in the Kaeng Krachan elephant house, (furthermore two elephants are of half Sri Lankan origin).
  • In the new walkthrough insect house (as everywhere: island species only): Achrioptera manga ('turquoise-blue phasmid'), Sungaya inexpectata ('Sungaya stick instect'), Sechelleptus sp. nov. ('giant Madagascan millipede'), Rhombodera kirbyi ('giant shield mantis'), Siliquofera grandis ('giant bush cricket'), Heteropteryx dilatata ('giant Malaysian stick insect'), Tirachoidea biceps ('giant Javan stick instect'), thorny devil walking stick (Eurycantha horrida), and thorny devil stick insect (Eurycantha calcarata).
  • Masoala species list: Tier- & Pflanzenlexikon | Zoo Zürich
full


full

 
Last edited:
Although Zurich has unfortunately failed to progress within the Cup, it has ended its run with a result to be very proud of:

Zurich - 86/110 points - 78.182%
Artis - 24/110 points - 21.818%

However, as alluded elsewhere, I do have rough plans for an informal handful of matches which will provide further opportunities for Zurich to prove itself.... watch this space!
 
Oooh, the overall winner of each designated group, perhaps? So Zurcih would take on the other three "Islands & Australia" winners?
 
Within this Cup, Zurich has had some tremendous misfortune with the drowning and the closed, but recent opening of various projects. Looking at the just renovated Asian carnivore complex and exotarium, if timing had been slightly different, literally by a couple of weeks, the outcome would have been different. And big chance they would have progressed maybe winning the group. In future cups, much can be expected. However, there are always those with bad luck in competitions, and in this case, Zurich will get that trophy. While Chester, for instance, with their Heart of Africa almost open, will probably be the lucky bastard one in this competition.
 
There are some other possible aspects that may explain Zurich's loss: they have relatively few species for such a large zoo, and relatively few true rarities.

Then again, they score very high on the overall quality and immersive aspects of their exhibits and with the visitor experience, but these are not categories in themselves.
 
However, there are always those with bad luck in competitions, and in this case, Zurich will get that trophy. While Chester, for instance, with their Heart of Africa almost open, will probably be the lucky bastard one in this competition.

As I'll discuss in a few days, there are far better candidates for both titles!
 
Back
Top