DAY 22: Tuesday, August 2nd
Zoo/Aquarium Review # 18: Phoenix Zoo
Phoenix Zoo’s website:
The Phoenix Zoo, Voted One of the Nation's Top 5 Zoos for Kids
Zoo Map:
http://www.phoenixzoo.org/images/phxzoo_map.pdf
Phoenix Zoo will celebrate its 50th anniversary in 2012 and there has been a lot of progress in the past few years. For the first time ever this largely self-supported zoo accepted government funding in 2006, and in reality the zoo could use some more cash to spruce up several aging sections. With recent new additions such as Land of the Dragons (a pair of Komodo dragon outdoor exhibits) and Orang-Hutan (an orangutan complex) the zoo has begun a busy period of construction.
Next up is an Education and Event Center that will open later this year (situated where the now bulldozed Enchanted Forest play area used to be – only the tree house remains), a revamped gift shop as the current one is closed down, an Entry Oasis to fix a confusing and untidy entrance area, and a Sumatran tiger exhibit near Main Lake. The tiger complex is budgeted at $3 million and the zoo will be able to hold up to 6 of the cats in a new exhibit next to the elephant paddock. Interestingly enough in 2013 possibly 3 major zoos will open new Sumatran tiger exhibits within months of each other: Phoenix Zoo, Woodland Park Zoo and San Diego Zoo Safari Park.
Phoenix Zoo has something that not a single other North American zoo has, and that is a wildly entertaining, walk-through squirrel monkey habitat. That wonderful experience, especially early in the morning when the 16 monkeys are frisky and not afraid to come within a foot or two of visitors, is probably worth the price of admission. There are a number of other excellent exhibits, as well as many average ones. We spent a full 5 hours at this 125-acre zoo and it was our second visit as the first time was on the long 2008 road trip.
THE BEST:
Tropics Trail: Monkey Village – This is North America’s only walk-through monkey area (Omaha now has a lemur zone) and there are 16 squirrel monkeys (2.14) jumping right next to visitors and creating commotions with their screeching cries. This habitat is only open for a few hours a day in the summer months and so my family made it one of our first stops at the zoo. An absolute treat to see such hilarious antics from the troop! There are always two zoo volunteers overseeing things as the monkeys aren't afraid to venture quite close to the folks clicking their cameras.
Africa Trail: Savanna – This is one of the best savannas of any zoo in North America, even though at times it appears a little crowded with the large variety of animals on display. Multiple up-close viewing opportunities abound, and the 11 animal species are not afraid to come close to the fence line. There is an extremely panoramic environment and the few visitors that actually were at the zoo on a scorching day mainly congregated in this area. Species list: Masai giraffe, reticulated giraffe, common eland, Watusi cattle, gerenuk, Thompson’s gazelle, ostrich, lappet-faced vulture, Ruppell’s griffon vulture, yellow-billed stork and East African crowned crane.
Arizona Trail – This part of the zoo begins with a section focusing on birds, reptiles, amphibians and fish, and then most of the mammals are located along a pathway beyond the main entrance. There is a walk-through aviary with multiple species of birds on display that is the first thing that most visitors see but there are no signs or placards whatsoever detailing the names of the species. A lizard exhibit also has zero signage, and a small gila topminnow pool greets visitors just inside the main entrance. There is a nice black-tailed prairie dog exhibit, a turkey vulture/raven aviary with zero signage, a single room with around 20 terrariums that contain a variety of amphibians, and another shaded pathway that has 8 small reptile terrariums as well as 3 huge terrariums that contain a variety of rattlesnakes. Reptile species list: Madrean alligator lizard, ornate tree lizard, Sonoran mud turtle, chuckwalla, desert tortoise, green ratsnake, gila monster, Sonoran gopher snake, Arizona mountain kingsnake, coachwhip, Arizona black rattlesnake, Grand Canyon rattlesnake, western diamondback rattlesnake, Mojave rattlesnake, speckled rattlesnake, black-tailed rattlesnake and tiger rattlesnake.
After leaving this area there is a small golden eagle aviary, a burrowing owl/roadrunner exhibit, a white-nosed coati enclosure, and then spacious and naturalistic habitats for coyotes, collared peccaries, pronghorn antelopes, Mexican wolves, coatis and Andean condors. Only the small enclosures for bobcats and mountain lions are disappointing, as yet again both large and small cats get shafted at a zoo. The viewing for some of the exhibits is open-top and well-designed, but the cats are difficult to spot and the Mexican gray wolves have a great enclosure but the viewing is terrible as it is through chain-link fencing. Metal aviaries for great horned owls, thick-billed parrots and pinyon jays round out the area, along with a small pool with endangered desert pupfish.
Tropics Trail: Forest of Uco – This is a great immersion experience with a fake South American village on the outside of the pathway and thick foliage on the dirt track that takes visitors around the exhibits. The spectacled bears are the true highlight here, in an enclosure that winds around a viewing window and is larger than it seems. The only downside is that the viewing opportunities are hit-and-miss and one has to wait until the end of the path before getting an open-top view of the main habitat. There is a small freshwater tank filled with black pacu, sawtooth catfish, suckermouth catfish and oscellated river stingrays; a boa constrictor exhibit set inside a tree trunk, a scarlet macaw on a perch, hawk-headed parrots, golden lion tamarins, spider monkeys and white-faced saki monkeys. One thing that was missing was another enclosure on the far side of the bears, as there is a long walk through the jungle setting without any animals whatsoever other than a few low-set terrariums, and now the rear-side of the new orangutan exhibit looms overhead. A jaguar, howler monkey, maned wolf, giant anteater or ocelot exhibit would be perfect in that area, as instead those animals are all found elsewhere throughout the zoo. This zoo actually has a tremendous variety of South American species and for the most part exhibits them quite well.
Desert Lives – There is a pair of enormous habitats for desert bighorn sheep, and an extremely picturesque mountain backdrop and a lot of rocky crags for the sheep to climb on. Also, a nearby Arabian oryx enclosure and informational signs highlight the success that this zoo has had saving that particular species from extinction. Over 230 oryx have been born at the zoo, and to see both the oryx and bighorn sheep visitors must walk a long, dusty, dry, demanding trail that juts off from the main Africa Trail loop.
Tropics Trail: Land of the Dragons – This area is fairly new (2009), cost $1 million, and features a pair of nicely planted Komodo dragon exhibits that are both quite impressive. It was great to see these lizards, which are now very commonly found in American zoos, in outdoor enclosures. Also, there is a viewing area into a small indoor exhibit and one of the yards is open-topped and that allows visitors to get a clear look at the world’s largest species of lizard.
Yakulla Caverns – This area was under construction on my visit in 2008 but it is a brilliant addition to the zoo. There are no animals here as it is a nicely-designed children’s waterpark that contains a mazelike cave structure with slides, fountains and cascading waterfalls. Moms (and sometimes dads!) let the water flow over them so that they don’t fry to death beneath the Arizona sun since the zoo has almost nowhere indoors to cool off from the heat. Today my wife watched as my daughter spent ages playing in this area, and my son had cold water poured on his head in the shade. I went off to see a large portion of the zoo alone as it was simply too hot for a young baby at a zoo that is almost entirely outdoors.
THE AVERAGE:
Africa Trail – Other than the multi-acre main Savanna there are a number of enclosures along a long loop that runs through the top part of the zoo. A pair of terrific yards for cheetahs and African wild dogs are lush and vibrant with greenery; there is a basic African spot-necked otter pool; a flamingo lagoon; a pair of lemur islands that are okay but nothing special; a pair of rocky grottoes for mandrills and Hamadryas baboons are average; a white rhino/Speke’s gazelle yard is below average; an impressive meerkat exhibit has a lot of space for the digging mammals; a warthog exhibit is average; Grevy’s zebra and marabou storks have an enclosure that is surprisingly green and spacious; a fennec fox exhibit is haphazardly placed off the main trail; and a natural-looking paddock for gerenuk/Kirk’s dik-dik/kori bustard/sulcata tortoise is excellent.
Most of the Africa Trail exhibits are of average quality, but they all dim in the glow of the multi-acre main Savanna and its almost dozen species. There is a lion/tiger pair of enclosures where visitors look through fencing and down upon the animals in their steep, hilly exhibits. The zoo plans to add a new tiger habitat in 2013, and I wonder if the lions will take over a revamped enclosure all for themselves.
Tropics Trail – There are basic small paddocks for Aldabra and Galapagos tortoises, and rhinoceros iguanas that are all standard at many southern zoos. The rest of the Tropics Trail area, outside of the Forest of Uco loop, varies widely in quality. Large enclosures for Chacoan peccaries, crested screamers and giant anteater/maned wolf are all impressive and natural-looking, while substandard metal boxes for black howler monkeys and a jaguar are disappointing. One highlight is a fairly new mixed-species wetlands exhibit that is seen via a boardwalk that ventures to a gazebo set in the middle of a lagoon. The 5 species here are: Mexican red brocket deer, Chilean flamingo, coscoroba swan, sandhill crane and American white pelican. Tropical Flights is a series of ugly metal aviaries for tropical birds, and there is also a lookout onto the buff-cheeked gibbon island. Black wire aviaries that are functional yet aesthetically awful dot the landscape in this region of the zoo and feature these species: scarlet ibis/roseate spoonbill, blue-grey tanager, black-throated magpie jay, plush-crested jay, blue-crowned motmot and golden conure.
Elephant Paddock – There are 3 Asian females that are all a minimum of 40 years of age (years born: 1970, 1971 and 1965) that live in an average-sized paddock that contains a wide pool. Unfortunately one of the elephants doesn't get along with the other two and thus there is a rotation going on while they each take turns kicking dust around in a tiny yard while waiting to be let into the much bigger main habitat. If the zoo closes at 2 p.m. in the summer and all 3 elephants are taken off and put into the 2 tiny yards next to the main enclosure, then that means all summer long the 3 elephants spend 17 hours each per day (and really more like 20 hours per day with the rotation system) in extremely dull, tiny paddocks. Hopefully the zoo allows some access to the main habitat when visitors aren't around, or else the elephants have barely any space at all.
The elephant enclosure is another example of function overtaking aesthetic appeal in Phoenix. There are lots of sand piles, old tires and enrichment items for the elephants, but most of the viewing is done by looking down into what is basically a huge concrete bowl, and after seeing so many truly great elephant exhibits during the past few years then this one barely scrapes into my “average” category. Of note is that the three aging pachyderms all have behavior problems and it will be interesting to see if Phoenix maintains elephants in the future once their current group dies off.
Children’s Trail – This area of the zoo is split into two sections, the excellent Harmony Farm area and the somewhat outdated menagerie of cages in the main children’s area. The farm section has a Fisher-Price Little People toddler playground designed specifically for little ones, a huge red barn, and then all sorts of domestic animals to see, touch and feed. There is even an air-conditioned school house and a large windmill to add an authentic touch to the experience and I was impressed with this area.
The second part is not really for kids at all but is mainly a series of metal cages that are almost all badly outdated. The bald eagle aviary is spacious, wallaby walkabout is boring, the small Visayan warty pig yard is decent, and then many small metal boxes contain these species: caracal, ocelot, green oropendola/red-legged seriema, Pemba flying fox/green wood hoopoe, black-capped lory and spectacled owl. A lush siamang island seems out of place next to the poor set of exhibits that are for the most part nothing but metal cages.
Stingray Bay – This is a 12,000 gallon touch tank featuring stingrays that can be petted for an additional fee. The zoo used to also house small sharks here but I question whether that is still the case as none of the signs indicated that there was anything but rays in the pool.
THE WORST:
Tropics Trail: Orang-Hutan: People of the Forest – The previous orangutan enclosure was built in 1975 and had aged badly over the years and the new area cost $5 million and just opened in April of this year so it is practically brand-new. There is a nicely-designed visitor entrance area surrounded by tall walls with lots of informational signs, and a neat visitor “tree house” style overlook allows for viewing into one of the large mesh ape exhibits. There are two main yards for the group of 4 Bornean orangutans, and one of the exhibits is functional yet boring aesthetically. It consists of an innumerable number of wooden beams with ropes attached to them to allow for brachiating apes to traverse the landscape. This yard is fine for the apes but is not innovative or trend-setting and in fact is as basic as it gets in terms of orangutan exhibitry.
What lands this exhibit in my “worst” category is the second yard and indoor areas. The yard has a small climbing structure and then a long row of wooden beams a few feet off of the ground with nothing else to climb on. Not knowing any different there is no way that I would ever have guessed that the habitat was built for orangutans, and the section of the yard closest to the huge viewing windows has a small stream that the apes will avoid, the back area is hotwired to death, and so the apes basically have a low beam to practice their tightrope walking on. Brutal.
The two indoor areas are head-scratching because there is nothing in them. On my long visit to this new area all 4 orangs spent time indoors and out of the hot sun but in either room there is not a single branch or device to climb on and only some bark-mulch/sawdust like carpet and one cardboard box. The orangs were walking around with not a beam or rope in sight, which is as bizarre as it gets for a species that spends 85% of its life in trees. Overall this exhibit is hailed as part of the zoo’s “a world-class zoo for a world class city capital campaign” but the orangutan pair of enclosures are disappointing and perplexing. Realistically the viewing windows are terrific for visitors and one of the yards is fine but overall I’m going to be highly critical here and most of the orang habitat is subpar.
The Lack of An Air-Conditioned Restaurant – How does this zoo, set in one of the hottest regions in America, not have a huge air-conditioned restaurant? I guarantee that the zoo could rake in hundreds of thousands of dollars a year just by erecting one by the main entrance. Reid Park Zoo in nearby Tucson in the past few years built a Conservation Center and a Café that are both beautifully cool with air-conditioning and there is one structure at each end of the zoo. Phoenix has nothing whatsoever, and visitors walk for hours with no relief around this large zoo. All the misters and drinking fountains in the world cannot replace an air-conditioned oasis such as a restaurant that would bring in a staggering amount of cash. Everything is open-air, all of the eating areas at the 5 cafes/snack shacks are outdoors, and the temperature all summer long is close to 110 Fahrenheit. Why would the zoo not build an indoor structure to relieve the sweating, struggling visitors?
Metal Cages – The plethora of black metal boxes that are scattered throughout the zoo grounds make for an ugly group of eyesores that I’d rather see torn down than house exotic species. I said the same thing about San Diego’s wire cages and Phoenix has the potential to be such a beautiful zoo that to see animas in outdated cages is frustrating. By the Komodo dragons are a pair of corn crib aviaries with king vultures and scarlet macaws, and peering through the black metal made me wonder why such constructions would be located in the Tropics Trail section of the zoo as there is nothing tropical about them. The many bird and primate cages should all be lumped into one location, maybe the cage-friendly Children’s Trail, and a new area can be named “Pet Store Boxes”.
OVERALL:
Phoenix Zoo doesn't receive any tax-payer funding and I’ve been told in the past that it is a constant battle to raise money to improve the zoo. Many of the exhibits dotted around the grounds have plaques that detail the year that they were built, and since the dates were ages ago it seems that the zoo is due for a freshening up. In 2006 there was a proposal that the zoo needed at least $70 million in improvements, but that was quickly downgraded to the current $20 million. It's too bad that money is such an issue because the zoo grounds are beautiful and the landscaping crew has utilized the surrounding desert perfectly. To add to the ambience are the many lizards that are to be found scampering across every conceivable pathway.
The zoo has a unique squirrel monkey walk-through exhibit, a panoramic African Savanna, a solid set of Arizona Trail habitats, and an extensive collection of South American animals. It's not a zoo that is highly regarded throughout North America, but it is definitely worth a visit just to see the fascinating collection and beautiful cacti that appear to devour the landscape. I think that Phoenix is in the second tier of American zoos (in the #23-30 range on my personal list) and it will always remain that way unless there is a significant amount of money raised to overhaul the sections that are outdated. All visitors just have to be considerate of the climate in summer, as today the temperature nudged quite close to 110 degrees Fahrenheit and the zoo is almost entirely outdoors.