ESSAY HELP! ORCAS IN CAPTIVITY
- Status
what do you already have on the topic?
Lots of things that go against the holding of orcas in captivity. SeaWorld is the main culprit in my essay and examples such as the small tanks, neglect of the whales, poor caring, inhumane breeding and in-bred whales in their own family line. How it is wrong for them to poorly care for these animals for pure human entertainment and money.
Zooplantman
Well-Known Member
And where are you getting these opinions from? Has the poor care you cite been authenticated by reputable, impartial experts who understand the issues and have studied the situation there? Have you also studied the opposing views to see where inconsistencies lie and form your own opinion based on provable facts?
With the release of Blackfish there was a great deal of misinformation and carefully edited "proof" of whatever the writers wanted to "prove." Are you certain you are not simply eating what they have put out to feed you?
Have you read all through these threads:
http://www.zoochat.com/183/blackfish-movie-trailer-323685/
http://www.zoochat.com/17/blackfish-342356/
Here's an "insightful opinion" for you, then.
Quite apart from the fact that you are more or less openly stating you intend to disregard any feedback which does not support your argument, and have come to a website for zoo enthusiasts rather than anti-zoo individuals..... you really should do your own homework rather than asking us to do it for you
Quite apart from the fact that you are more or less openly stating you intend to disregard any feedback which does not support your argument, and have come to a website for zoo enthusiasts rather than anti-zoo individuals..... you really should do your own homework rather than asking us to do it for you
SamMetz
Well-Known Member
You really don't understand what an opinion is. Whats right and whats wrong can't be proven because they're morals, not facts. Its a matter of your own opinion, morals are subjective. If you already have a concrete way you're viewing something and just state any other facts or ideas against it will not change your out look on a topic why ask? Honestly it just sounds like you watched Blackfish and now thats your opinion and refuse to believe anything else. If thats true, really just think about how you've based your entire opinion on one thing. Thats the problem these days no one cross checks anymore to see if what they've been told is in fact correct. You can't take anything at face value honestly. Maybe a better report would be how emotions can effect a way a person relates to topics? Im not trying to be negative toward you but you're not thinking clearly and going about this report wrong. And thats the thing about BF it builds your emotions up and then you'll believe ANYTHING they'll say to you. Its a play on emotions that people don't get.
Last edited:
Do more research on the topic, form your own opinion. There are plenty of people on the internet who have posted lots of stuff on the topic. As much as I like to complain about orca captivity, I'm not doing your homework for ya.
there's not much point posting replies on this thread. Her essay was due on the night she posted it, so she has already either passed it or failed it.
Pootle
Well-Known Member
Do todays students actually 'fail' things these days or just get very low pass marks so as to not offend?
In the US, generally the latter, unless you're taking an advanced class. Maybe it does vary, but in my middle and high school, teachers were encouraged to make tests easy, drop low grades and zeroes, give lots of extra credit points and high curves... I once had a biology test where only two people in the entire class passed. (me and an exchange student) The teacher gave a 20 point curve, so I went from a C to an A because everyone else is dumb. Or maybe I'm just smart. I dunno. Point is, our public school system has problems.
Maybe it's a regional thing, I guess. But at my schools, a teacher could get in trouble for failing a kid. It was stupid.
azcheetah2
Well-Known Member
Really? In Arizona you don't get a grade you don't earn. If you don't do the homework you fail the class.
As for the OP...looks like your opinions are from the movie Blackfish and you've never visited a Sea World park because if you had, you'd know that the whales are well cared for. They're not neglected. They don't inbreed the whales. The pools are larger and deeper than what is required. They're not forced to perform by withholding food. They are not physically punished for not performing. I used to be a heavy regular to SWC and saw a lot of what the general public does not get to see and I never saw any misbehavior by the trainers towards the whales.
JBZvolunteer
Well-Known Member
It is pretty widespread in the US. We have Common Core and No Child Left Behind which punish teachers for failing a student. I have heard of school districts that won't hold a student back in elementary or middle school unless they get parental approval. But this wasn't the original point of the thread.
I don’t disagree with anything aside from inbreeding. Mistakes were made in 2006, it’s most likely what she was referring to. Unna has a stillborn calf with either an uncle or half-brother in San Antonio and Katina had a calf with her son in Orlando. Adan Andre Victoria were Born to whales at Lori Parque, all calves not born to Morgan at the park are guaranteed to be at least slightly inbred.
C'mon. The last reply was 4 years ago....is it really worth it to reply?
Why don't some of these zombie threads just get closed?
- Status