African Elephant

Ban the circus elephant, says protester | Stuff.co.nz
Ingrid Weihmann is urging people to think twice before going to the circus that she believes causes an elephant to suffer.

The Timaru woman plans to support a Safe (animal welfare group) protest to be held outside the Loritz Circus at Aoraki Polytech at 12.45pm tomorrow.

However, Loritz management say Jumbo was saved from certain death when she joined the circus and was happy and well looked after, with plans in place to retire her when they find the right place for her.

Ms Weihmann wanted to protest after seeing Safe footage which shows Jumbo tethered and rocking side-to-side. "She is exhibiting behaviour that shows she is unhappy. Elephants are herd animals. She must be lonely and miserable not being able to roam.

"SPCA wouldn't allow it into Dunedin city."

Ms Weihmann was not a member of Safe but wanted to support the protest. She differentiated between exotic animals and domesticated animals and only ate meat that was free range. "It's different when they are animals that have been domesticated, which can still exhibit cow-like or sheep-like behaviours. This elephant is completely away from its natural environment."

Safe member and Timaru protest organiser Debbie Crowe said she did not think it was right for an elephant to be caged and this had led her to organise the protest. "She could be in a sanctuary. We need to teach our children it is not right to treat animals this way."

When the circus visited Dunedin early last month, Safe made a complaint to the Agriculture and Forestry Ministry and the SPCA after seeing Jumbo kept in what it said were conditions that were in breach of the circus code of welfare.

According to Safe, Jumbo had been illegally tethered in her trailer, kept in inadequate living conditions without sufficient exercise and kept on the hard surface of a car park.

Loritz Circus was scheduled to perform in Dunedin for three weeks from the first week of April, but the Dunedin City Council council and SPCA had Jumbo removed to Mosgiel as the council had a policy prohibiting exotic animals from performing.

Loritz Circus marketing manger Paul Johnson said Jumbo had performed to 48,000 people in the South Island in the past year, and only 48 people had protested.

"I flew to Christchurch to talk to the people from Safe and asked them to provide some suggestions and they never have.

"I respect their right to protest but they have never come up with what we could do. Maybe I should drop her, Jumbo, off at their doorstep, although that would be cruel.

"We have plans to retire her when we can find the right place. We were talking to a zoo but she was a different breed to the elephant they had so they didn't want her."

Jumbo is 36-years-old, and came to New Zealand 31 years ago. Mr Johnson said she was saved from certain death as she had been thrown into a moat in Honolulu and left to die. Jumbo costs up to $200 a day for food and can eat up to 30 cabbages and consume 45 gallons of water a day. On average she appears six times a week in the circus for about five minutes a day.
 
I was just wondering. There has been alot of talk about bringing Jumbo to Australia and hopefully (if they would take her ) sending her to TWPZ. Now the cost to the zoo would be a near $150,000 each year on top of the other five elephants they keep. They took on Arna and Gigi just a few years ago and this cost them $25,000 each year in food alone. plus the additional staff that are required to handle the extra workload. However IF TWPZ was interested in taking her on does any one know if it is even possible to import her.

Would AQIS allow her import from New Zealand in the first place???
 
AFAIK, the circus is in complete control over Jumbo's future and have no intention of letting her go... Unless the government shows she is being mis-treated (in the legal sense not moral) there is nothing anyone can do about it...
 
The circus is actually looking at their options. They are happy to send her to a new home when one suitable can be found. They offered her to Auckland, but as they wish to stay in the breeding program this is not an option.
 
This is what annoys me with SAFE campaigning against her being there. they protest and protest which in my opinion causes stress to all of the animals and then when it comes down to it they are all talk. The circus has said if a suitable home can be found they will do something to help her. But SAFE has nothing. I know how most people here feel about african elephants but the circus isn't in a situation to do anything. I think you will find that nobody wanted her (that could afford to look after her) so loritz took her on. They only planned to keep her temporarily.
 
The circus is actually looking at their options. They are happy to send her to a new home when one suitable can be found. They offered her to Auckland, but as they wish to stay in the breeding program this is not an option.

Hmmm, they changed their tune on that one...
 
Hmmm, they changed their tune on that one...


The Circus?? It appears bthat it was never their intention to keep her permanently but to provide her with a home for the duration of their out of africa show, during it's tour funds are being saved to find her a new home. They spent half a million dollars on her. They are doing the best they can. I think if SAFE should stop talking and protesting and start acting.
 
I think we are thinking of a different elephant then mate...
 
If you read articles there are many references to the fact that they have a fund set up to help fund her retirement and that has been the case for a while. If Loritz didn't buy her who knows where she would be.
 
I agree with you on this one.

Those wishing for her relocation away from the circus:
A) only protest, protest and protest and yes create undue stress on everyone involved including the elephant herself (e.g. legally trying to endanger her future).
B) have no clue as to proper management and husbandry of elephants in the first place (.. other than an emotional bonding with Free Willy style elephant cuddlyness)
C) create a racket where in all fairness there seems none as the circus has put all sorts of procedures and mechanisms in place to have her in the best of animal welfare practice ... even to the point of creating a retirement welfare fund
C) have no viable alternative for her to relocate to (e.g. the Auckland suggestion is just preposterous)
D) provide no funding base to foot the elephant's animal welfare concerns should she be relocated (it is always others that are supposed to come and cough up the cash for a transfer)

I just find all this animal welfare stuff ... a bit much and rich
(alas I am afraid strong-minded folk will again find this an excuse to rant an rave over ... :eek: a mous!!! and an elephant :D)
 
Just in case anyone doesn't know the latest on Jumbo, she is now at Franklin zoo, along with her former owner who looks after her. She has her own enclosure, not sure how big it is but still better than a trailer and a chain around her foot, and plenty of care. No reson why she shouldnt' live another 20 years.
 
She is at Franklin Zoo, and seems very happy there, with mud wallows, sand piles, lots of tasty browse and many stimulating enrichments.

However, her former "owner" is NOT there. She is being cared for by a number of keepers.
 
She is at Franklin Zoo, and seems very happy there, with mud wallows, sand piles, lots of tasty browse and many stimulating enrichments.

However, her former "owner" is NOT there. She is being cared for by a number of keepers.

I stand corrected, when I visited the owner was there, and told me he had been retained as the keeper since he was the only one who could handle the animal.

Ive since visited several times and been told by the Zoo director that the former owner lives nearby, and often visits, however has no control or direct ocntact with the elephant.

the Elephant herself is getting on well with the keepers assigned to look after her, and on my last visit there were two elephant experts from Australia at the zoo checking her out and advising on training and de-circusing her.

Franklin also has a great lion enclosure, but only one lion left. They ar elooking at getting a couple more from Aus possibly.
 
a recent post from the Franklin Zoo website about Jumbo, from 19 May
Jumbo the elephant enjoying her retirement at Franklin Zoo
Franklin Zoo and Wildlife Sanctuary in Tuakau has been the home for Jumbo the retired circus elephant for the past six months.

Sanctuary director and veterinarian Dr Helen Schofield says Jumbo has settled in to her life at the Sanctuary well and has developed close and affectionate relationships with her team of keepers.

“Jumbo is responding well to her operant conditioning and protected care management. The program allows keepers to manage her through a protected wall, and is based solely on positive feedback. She is responding well by presenting feet for care, all parts of her body for washing, rub downs and other health care procedures.”

“Our dream for Jumbo is to get her in a situation where she can have other African elephants for company; most elephant sanctuaries around the world manage their elephants using these procedures so she will understand them if and when it comes time to move.”

“Our program is designed to ‘future proof’ Jumbo by giving her skills so that if it becomes possible to move her to a social situation in the future she will be able to cope well. Not only has she learnt to work with more than one keeper, she has also developed more physical fitness and confidence, she has perfected her mud wallowing and sand bathing techniques, not to mention her ability to knock down pretend trees (telegraph poles), all these activities will help her in the future”

Work has started on Jumbo’s winter barn, with plans including an indoor area that will provide under cover protection for when the weather gets cold, heaters for those frosty mornings, warm water for wash downs and areas for training and indoor activities. Included in the design is an area to place her travel crate. It will become part of the entry chute, so if and when the time comes she will be very familiar with it. Part of the area will be a deep sand pit, allowing for soft footing and a comfortable place to lie down.

“The Franklin community has been hugely helpful in caring for Jumbo, mostly by delivering wonderful browse (branches and trees) for her to eat. Our visitors are overjoyed to see her as she gains more confidence moving around her parkland enclosure or watching her play and sand bathing” says Schofield.

“It is a tremendous privilege to take care of Jumbo, I feel personally humbled and flattered by the big ear flapping purrs she gives me as a greeting when I return to see her from other activities in the zoo. She is so affectionate and responsive. It will be a joyful day to see her develop friends of the elephant kind in the future. This is a way off and the earliest we could get her with others would be 12 months away.”

Keeping an elephant is a significant financial commitment. Dr Schofield says she set up the Franklin Zoo and Wildlife Sanctuary Charitable Trust in November 2008 to assist in the care of exotic and native animals being retired or re-homed. The Sanctuary successfully purchased and retired the last circus lions in New Zealand in 2006, the Sanctuary is also home to over 300 birds and animals including Zebra, Bobcats, and Lemurs, Capuchin monkeys, Kea and many others. Donations are very much needed and can be made at the Zoo or here on the website
 
well thats all a load of PR bull isnt it! why would you build such a state of the art barn if you are looking to send the elie away!

and im pretty sure that as a circus elephant she needs no help with crate training....
 
well thats all a load of PR bull isnt it! why would you build such a state of the art barn if you are looking to send the elie away!

and im pretty sure that as a circus elephant she needs no help with crate training....

Very perceptive, torie.

But when you are fishing for money you have to throw out the sort of bait the suckers will go for.

Many years ago a senior RSPCA bloke in Victoria told me that if he could get a good anti-circus story on the TV evening news it would be worth at least $5000 in donations - and that was 20 years ago.

Nothing's changed except the figures.
 
well thats all a load of PR bull isnt it! why would you build such a state of the art barn if you are looking to send the elie away!

and im pretty sure that as a circus elephant she needs no help with crate training....


Also the Sanctuary they have were originally talking about sending her to only keep cows and use primarily FC. Unless those plans have changed.

I was also going to comment on the fact that it seemed to be a fairly fancy barn for something that's only going to be used for 12 months.
 
Back
Top