Looking at the original plans for housing, it does make more sense as to why Auckland Zoo imported orangutans as they did. Initially, since Horst and Charlie were juveniles when they arrived, the zoo may have assumed that they would coexist successfully until the planned enclosure was built.
I too think that the larger orangutan group would have thrived in the current orangutan/siamang habitat and made good use of the towers and aerial pathways. Although I do believe that the current group will make increased use of the aerial pathways as Bahmi matures and Daya is allowed to explore them.
I imagine the long term plan may have been to house them in pairs (Horst and Indra; Charlie and Dara) under the initial plans for a two exhibit complex. Charlie could have then bred with the female offspring of Horst and Indra, so in that sense the zoo were being forward thinking in sourcing more founders than they needed in the here and now.
It was also mentioned in the zoo’s history book that they imported Bornean orangutan because most zoos in the region held Sumatran. This sounds like reverse logic, but likely referred to a lack of availablity of Sumatran orangutans at that time (early 80’s), with Bornean being more prevalent in Europe.
