Haliaeetus
Well-Known Member
A female Ring-tailed Lemur called CIRILLA is born on Apr. 19th.
https://www.instagram.com/p/C8rzlBnTIfb/?igsh=Mm9jZ2NrMXoxNmRk
https://www.instagram.com/p/C8rzlBnTIfb/?igsh=Mm9jZ2NrMXoxNmRk
I was fighting myself not to call them out since the moment I saw it, but I ended up commenting anyways, because this is honestly disgraceful.They should be very embarrassed. If you don't like this, please tell them. Make sure its known that AI video is NOT appreciated by anyone with a passion for conservation.
Oiyoiyoi!The center is currently facing pushback after putting out an AI generated add seeking donations for the DLC
Duke Lemur Center on Instagram: "In this new video, we’ve partnered with CYLNDR Studios to explore a fresh way to tell our story. By responsibly using AI tools, we were able to create visuals that help people see and feel the wonder of lemurs—and the urgent need to protect them We’re excited to share this piece as a conversation starter, an invitation for support, and a reminder of what’s at stake.lemur.duke.edu/closer BACKGROUND: “Closer Than You Think” was created by a team of creatives at CYLNDR Studios, a Los Angeles-based video production company, as part of the DLC’s ongoing effort to share the story of lemurs and inspire support for their future. Using AI tools in conjunction with materials provided by the DLC, the result is a bit of fantasy, a blend of real and not, that helps us visualize moments and connections that would otherwise be impossible to capture. This was a pro bono project, done for no charge to the DLC. We’re grateful to the teams at CYLNDR and LTX Labs for donating their time and talent to bringing lemurs, and the people working to protect them, to life in a whole new way "
The whole thing looks very sloppy and their entire reasoning behind it and defense comes across as very weak and shallow.
Oiyoiyoi!
Here's my jab at dissecting the octopus...
The video itself was not conceptualised entirely by the Duke Lemur Centre. It was conceptualised by a video studio in California, that being CYLNDR [Studios]. CYLNDR is a studio which bills itself as a studio which creates 'modern content, powered by design'. A glance at their website gives me the idea that CYLNDR is a company which produces 'content for brands', and works largely with the marketing of brands. I think the thing of most interest/disgust here is that of LTX Labs, which is... ...a studio? ...a platform? ...'the future of storytelling'? Whatever it is it doesn't do the best job at telling what it is meant to be. But it's something which companies can use to generate AI video, from what I see.
What I do find interesting is that on Facebook it is mentioned that on the end of the DLC it was pro bono, free of charge - so what I'm guessing at here is that the DLC reached out to CYLNDR for an idea for an advertisement, and CYLNDR utilised LTX for the AI work.
Now my thoughts on the ad itself.... somehow this ad made me feel nothing. I see the concept they are going for, that people and lemurs aren't that different, hey look at that they do what we do... but the examples they use are rather basic. I have the thought after watching this ad, 'why does this ad have to be about lemurs? It could be about almost any sort of animal!' And as lemurs are a very interesting group of animals, I can't see why they wouldn't show lemurs doing more lemur specific things. Like show lemurs doing 'yoga' and have people doing yoga... have aye-ayes go hunting for food at night and have some people eating at night or something... this doesn't scream 'lemur' to me somehow. And then after that we get a classic feature of corporate ads... the 'we don't have much to say so here's a rapidfire selection of profound things' montage... neurons... baobab trees... DNA... flowers... a colourful load of nothing... chromatography... gametes... baby lemur... milky way galaxy. What is this supposed to tell me?
After that a text explanation of how 'lemurs are disappearing... and with them a world of knowledge...' of various diseases, superimposed by clips of people hugging each other etc. And somehow I am meant to feel something yet I do not. And after that we get some more brand-marketing 'aerogel statements' [very, very light in substance for the screen time it takes] before the end of the ad.
I feel nothing after watching this ad. I feel no inspiration to protect lemurs in their natural habitat. I feel nothing towards whatever potential benefits they may have to humanity from watching this ad. I am impressed in a horrible way that they take a very interesting subject... lemurs... and make me totally disinterested in the subject by watching the ad. Somehow I feel offended that they took this interesting group of animals to make a corporate ad that does all it can to keep the eyes glued... otherwise they wouldn't have that stupid montage... whilst having the least amount of anything to say about its subject as possible. This gives the hallmarks of an ad about lemurs by several executives who did as little research as possible.
And I haven't even began talking about the generative AI in my critique! I don't like the generative AI either... but I can't help but feel that here the gAI works in essence as a mask for the overwhelming amount of nothing contained in this ad. You won't get angry that we made a ad about lemurs with just about nothing interesting to say about them, no... you'll get angry that what you are looking at was generated by a neural network! And I do find it tragically funny that they bill these clips used as something innovative, something that 'would otherwise be impossible to capture'... when most of the clips here are the kind of things you'd find on stock footage sites that may very well have trained the AI model that these clips were made with! Lemurs have been recorded on film for many years, and the lemurs here at least are not doing very much that is unusual for lemurs to do. And if you do mean to say that either the lemurs or people generated by AI in this ad are not actually acting in the way that they actually do at times... surely this totally undercuts your message that people and lemurs are not very different, actually! There is no innovation here! There is nothing new! The use of gAI here feels totally and utterly pointless.
It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth... and it pains me that of all the ways one of the most regarded, interesting conservation organisations in the world could ask for money and support, this is how they go about doing it. And it isn't particularly good whatsoever. And I do believe the DLC is a force for net good in the world, this doesn't detract from that at all, anything that they have done or are to do... I just think that this was just a misstep that I really rather they had second thoughts about.