Is this Sumatran tiger story real?

Sounds a bit far fetched. I recon a tiger would climb better than a man.
 
there's a longer version here with details of how they know what happened. And also the Indonesian killed was named, um, David....


If anything I think the cats were actually cigau and not Sumatran tigers. It's the only explanation.


BBC News - Indonesians trapped up tree by Sumatran tigers
Several tigers have trapped five Indonesian men up a tree in a national park on Sumatra island, after mauling a sixth person to death, police say.

The group was attacked on Thursday after they accidentally killed a tiger cub. One man died while the others managed to flee up some branches.

The survivors alerted nearby villagers using mobile phones.

It could take rescue crews up to three days before they find the men in the Gunung Leuser jungle, officials said.

The national park covers nearly 7,930 sq km (3,060 sq miles) along the border of North Sumatra and Aceh provinces.

A 30-member search team entered the jungle on Saturday, police chief Dicky Sondani said.

"It might need two or three days to walk on foot to the depths of the jungle," he said

Failed rescue attempt
Villagers had tried to rescue the men on Thursday but retreated when they saw at least four large Sumatran tigers circling around the base of the tree.

"If the tigers remain under the tree, we may have to shoot or sedate them to rescue the five people," Mr Sodani added.

The six men, all from Simpang Kiri village in Aceh Tamiang district, had ventured into the national park in search of rare incense wood.

"People keep entering the jungle to look for the wood because it's very expensive," the police chief said.

"But that's the risk: there are many tigers and elephants in Gunung Leuser jungle."

The group set up deer traps for food, but accidentally caught a tiger cub.

The injured animal drew nearby tigers who then pounced on the men and killed a 28-year-old only identified as David.

The smallest of all tigers, Sumatran tigers are a critically endangered species only found on the Indonesian island.

As few as 350 remain in the wild, of which the largest population lives in the Gunung Leuser national park.
 
I saw tigers in action at Dreamworld: they are great climbers. However, maybe the tree is quite tall.
 
I have some thoughts on this story.

1) there is no reason for the search to need 30 men or for it to take 2-3 days to "find" the men. They already know where they are: up a tree near a village. The villagers, according to the story, already know exactly where the tree is, because they went there and saw the men up there with the ravening pack of tigers at the base.

2) by the time the search party gets there the tigers will be either gone, or their bellies will be full and they will have gone to sleep. Either way a wasted trip.

3) if these are tigers and not cigau then conservationists will have to revise their estimates of Sumatran tiger numbers. The assumption, based on other tiger subspecies, is that tigers are solitary and thus estimates of population size are garnered through territory range of individual cats. However, Sumatran tigers are obviously pack-hunters like lions, as this story proves, and therefore the population must be something like three to ten times greater than the previous estimates.
 
"Good news everyone!" The five men have been rescued! (Oh, also, the "two to three days" rescue time in the original articles one day ago must have been based on an estimate of "Indonesian time" ;))

BBC News - Indonesia men safe after five-day Sumatran tiger ordeal
Five men have been rescued in an Indonesian national park after spending five days trapped in trees surrounded by Sumatran tigers, officials say.

Dozens of rescuers, including police, arrived at the Mount Leuser National Park on Sumatra Island to help the men.

They moved in after tamers managed to drive the tigers away, reports say.

Several tigers attacked the group on Thursday after they accidentally killed a tiger cub. A sixth man died in the initial incident.

Andi Basrul, head of the national park, said the survivors were being transported to the nearest village, which normally takes six hours on foot.

Jamal Gayo, from the conservation group Leuser International Foundation, said the five were weak after not having had food for three days.

...................................
 
"Good news everyone!" The five men have been rescued! (Oh, also, the "two to three days" rescue time in the original articles one day ago must have been based on an estimate of "Indonesian time" ;))

BBC News - Indonesia men safe after five-day Sumatran tiger ordeal

It's a good thing that they had tamers. :D At least they did not kill the tigers.

This reminds me of that crocodile movie where the crocodile chased a guy up a tree and he was stuck there for a few days. I don't think they used croc tamers then though.
 
So now the million dollar question is, will they be prosecuted for setting traps and harvesting wood in a national park?
 
Haha. You're a funny guy. Westerners crack me up. :D

Sadly, I fear that you're right. In situ conservation only works in the long run if laws are enforced.

And I come from a rich country where Government let nests of a protected bird of prey be destroyed so that game rearers could let more pheasants loose for toffs to shoot. So I have no illusions about being in a position to preach.
 
Given Sumatran tigers must normally be incredibly shy creatures, (how often do you see photos of them apart from cameratrap footage?) a gathering like this must have been quite unique. Do we believe this story- or parts of it, and if so, which parts? Or was it one tiger, for a few hours (or even less time perhaps?) I wonder if the 'tamers' were really needed to drive the Tiger(s) away. What a strange story..:confused:
 
Given Sumatran tigers must normally be incredibly shy creatures, (how often do you see photos of them apart from cameratrap footage?) a gathering like this must have been quite unique. Do we believe this story- or parts of it, and if so, which parts? Or was it one tiger, for a few hours (or even less time perhaps?) I wonder if the 'tamers' were really needed to drive the Tiger(s) away. What a strange story..:confused:
I believe this much of the story:
The national park covers nearly 7,930 sq km (3,060 sq miles) along the border of North Sumatra and Aceh provinces.

The smallest of all tigers, Sumatran tigers are a critically endangered species only found on the Indonesian island.

As few as 350 remain in the wild, of which the largest population lives in the Gunung Leuser national park.
 
Those are pretty much the same parts I believe also....;) Its also possible if they caught a cub 'by accident' that they were charged by an irate mother and sought refuge in a tree. I don't think I would go any further than that though.
 
Back
Top