Everyone is entitled to their opinion on this site. But when one argues for a no-breeding policy ... it appears to me you are acceptant and fatalistic about the plight of endangered species.
The example of the "most tigers" at Isle of Wight Zoo makes me rather sad. Figures - to my mind - do not matter it is matter that matters! I suppose we are all aware of the plight of tigers in this day and age. I assume, johnstoni, that you are talking of "mixed" tigers or Bengals in retirement? But if they are truly pure-bred Bengals f.i. it would take on another meaning all together ....
So, your account just makes me a little sad ... (and the tiger was just an example (lol)). If you must point to good small zoos with a conservation ethic and educational drive take to Linton or Jersey Zoos. They have a special knack at making the non MEGA fauna mighty interesting and worth conserving. Now that is what I call a good zoo.
I rest my case (and hope you might yet agree on this one (lol)) I am cool though!![]()
All the Tigers at the Isle of Wight Zoo are 'mixed race'. I have heard that while the new 'Indian- themed' tiger enclosures are excellent, a number of theTigers still live in very cramped quarters. With up to twenty or more tigers, not all can use the enclosures at the same time.
Apart from these mixed-race Tigers, some other big cats, and the various Lemurs, there isn't a lot else to see at the IOW Zoo.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion on this site. But when one argues for a no-breeding policy ... it appears to me you are acceptant and fatalistic about the plight of endangered species.
Just your account and description on IoW Zoo was not conclusive on the nature of the tigers exhibitted. I glean from your comments that all are generic or hybrid tigers from an age when an indiscriminate breed policy was in place.
Would it not be a sound idea that in this day and age some safari parks, open range zoos and conventional zoos under direction of EAZA would invest resources into setting up breeding groups of pure-bred Bengal tigers for this exact purpose.
Where I agree with you is that we need to have the white tigers' syndrome and generic tigers phased out of the zoos targetted for tiger EEP's as they take up valuable space.
This is true, but it is still very much a hangover from the days of Jack Corney. Since the daughter took over, the enclosures have continuously been replaced with much larger habitats rich in different substrates and vegetation. As a fairly small (though expanding rapidly) site, they made a wise choice to try and do the best they could for the existing animals, rather than go down the route of acquiring something new, marketing it around a new exhibit, and developing that way.
The IOW should be judged by the development and management changes under the current director. From the site, it is obvious that, although some animals are still awaiting more spacious quarters, the environmental enrichment programme is fantastic.
the John Aspinall Foundation used to be big on Bengal tigers, but I think they have since been scaled back in terms of using enclosure space and the breeding programme has been stopped out of .. sheer desinterest. Are you suggesting that most of JAF current stock are hybrids or generics?
I fully agree that it might be worthwhile to investigate the options for a re-instatement of the Bengal tiger breeding programme using direct imports of pure-bred Bengal tigers from Indian zoos.
Anyhow, will continue to discussion and see where it leads us. I will certainly get back to you on the India captive Bengal tiger thingy for you as well as the latest stats in wild tiger populations in protected areas and those just beyond.
I They introduced a no-breeding policy several years ago. I know a lot of the european population aren't pure, but in the absence any others, it seems a shame to slowly run this group down to nothing.
it seems ironic to displace the multi-generational composition of a socially robust primate group in the name of ethics. I would say this argument is especially important in the UK chimpanzee population right now. Another example of a 'happy accident' despite birth control, was the last chimpanzee baby at Colchester zoo.
Another interesting collection I am trying to find out more about, also on the Isle of Wight, is 'Monkey Haven', which I believe will take in most of the BIAZA surplus males of Eastern colobus subspecies, Javan brown langurs etc, forming bachelor groups and creating greater space in the collections they come from.
Corney was on good terms with the chipperfields and therefore often had animals from the english safari parks run by them for handrearing. Certainly he recieved lion cubs and black bear cubs at various points. I'm not sure whether this was done as a favour or as a way for a very small zoo to increase it's 'attractions' during tourist season.
Do you know the genetic purity of the Monkey World group(s)?