of breeding rhinos...
sumatran rhinos are one of those species thats not a little bit endangered - they are seriously endangered. i'm sure jay, you are aware that there are just 300 or so left and that these are broken up into even smaller isolated groups in sumatra, borneo and penninsular malaysia often in numbers as low as 10-30.
if you say i am giving mixed messages because of my views on elephants, then i will explain how i differentiate between the two. you and i have had discussions for some years now and you should know that i am by no means opposed to keeping animals in captivity, elephants or otherwise. but i do like to see it done right and for the right reasons.
in the situation with sumatran rhinos - captive breeding could be a potentially life-saving tool for this species. without going off on a crazy google searh for the next half hour i will guess that there are about 10-20 captive sumatran rhinos in the world. there are a few in indonesian and malaysian zoos, a few in breeding centers (that, as you said are having no luck at breeding so far) and the few in the states.
personally, i'm inclined to say that the situation with these animals is so bad that i would like to see all the rhinos removed from zoos and go into breeding centers. that to me would be locically the best scenario to induce breeding by giving animals a greater choice of mates and keeping options open for mangement. however, so far the breeding centers have failed miserably. one center recently lost all its rhino, due to alledgedly to lax hygene standards. this is not due to the rhino being non-breeders, many are young enough and should be reproducing (emi by the way, is no spring chicken). it is ironically a zoo in a freezing cold climate in cincinnati that is having the only sucess with breeding. and on account of the fact that they are breeding so well - i think it would be foolish to move them.
what i want to see is the experts in america work hand in hand with the breeding centers. spend time there real time there and fund upgrades and importantly labs/equipment for hormone monitoring.
but, as i said, in my last post - the last thing i want to see is american zoos try and start up a sumatran rhino breeding program again. absolutely not. no, the situation is so bad for these rhino that we can't risk them on half-arsed conservation in zoos. LA should send andalas back to indonesia and work with them there to breed him.
but you have to go with whats providing results. right now thats a zoo, so i respect what they have done and think they should continue. rather than see them aquire more rhino i would like to see them have a much, much greater involvement back in asia, but at the same time i can respect that, if a decision was made to send a second pair to cincinnti to see if their experts can replicate their success, well, i suppose its something that is worth looking into. but all offspring should be going back to asia. at this last-minute stage we certainly don't need to start expanding the amount of zoos holding this species. we need to consolodate - hence why i would like to see the zoo-based rhino in asia move to the breeding centers (and if a another pair did go to cincinnatti, these zoo-rhino would be the best candidates).
why do i think sumatran rhinos need a breeding program? because the situation in the wild is already so bad that they need human intervention, not just protection, to ensure their survival long-term. even if these small populations are protected sufficiantly, inbreeding will eventually become a problem and animal translocation will become nescersary. the breeding program is made up of animals that lived in areas doomed to become logged or areas where the population was unsustainable even in the short term. these animals are good candidates to become a founder population whose offspring will one day provide that fresh blood the wild populations need. we now have experts in america who understand rhino breeding. we have a reasonable sized captive population in southeast asian breeding centers. there needs to be very close co-operation between them if we are going to save the species.
so a successful in-situ breeding program is of great benifit to the species because it will see captive-bred animals periodically added to protected wild populations to boost their numbers and add fresh genetics. if the breeding centers are located in these protected areas, which they are, unlike in a zoo, the animals are raised in the local climate with local vegetation and an immune system that is protective against local ailments. the chances of re-intoduction success are far greater.
so you see jay, unlike asian elephants who, though under immense threat, still have large viable wild populations numbering in the thousands, sumatran rhinos do not and will be unlikely so survive without a degree of human intervention. protection alone is the biggest issue facing elephants.
with such as small wild population, the captive sumatran rhinos are of real asset (unlike other zoo populations of a species who although often are represented in very large numbers genetically they represent very little).
zoos are not ideal places for breeding such a rare species, but since one is having success at doing so it would be foolish not to utilise it.