Racism and Anti-Semitism in Conservation and Animal Fields

Have you received hate for your race, religion, gender, etc while working in conservation?


  • Total voters
    10

Nesher

Member
Hello,
As a Mizrahi (Middle Eastern), Israeli who is very proud of his Judaism and who is very passionate about conservation and animals, I often get penalized by many in these fields for my diverse background. I wanted to post some of my stories and experiences and see those of others to understand if these are issues that I alone face or are universal.

Sadly for me, Anti-Semitism and racism are things that I'm used to receiving in all aspects of my life. While I would obviously much prefer to live in a world where I am allowed to be myself with no barriers to that, that is not something likely in my life for sure. But it was when I first came to the United States, after my service in the Israeli Armed Forces, that I realized what it was like. After going through several years of college, I had gotten a job at a local animal facility, (which will remain unnamed for obvious reasons). As a religious Jew, I wore tallit, and kippah, and wrapped tefillin every day. I was already lucky in getting the job for being visibly Jewish, as I had volunteered there before and formed connections. But after just several weeks of working there, I had two separate coworkers ask for me to be moved areas, as my appearance made them uncomfortable. Sadly they ended up moving my areas in order to keep a safe work environment for all parties, and I now worked with their camp and education sections. But even here parents and guests would come and ask me if I was safe for their kids and animals. I ended up leaving since this was not a great environment but it only started what would become a rather extensive relationship with Anti-Semitism in conservation.

I later got a job with an international conservation organization, where I mainly worked with their bird programs, and served as a resource for their divisions in the Middle East. But here I received even more hatred than I had before. One of the animals I was working with was a beautiful Mountain Gazelle. And at the time, I referred to them as Israeli Mountian Gazelles, as that is what I grew up with. I called them this at work all of the time, and was constantly told, "Of course, you would call them that." and "It's actually the Palestinian Mountain Gazelle, that's the only way to call it." I could barely even sit in my office area without people coming up and telling me "Free Palestine". I would bring in shwarma, falafel, and hummus, all food my family has made for centuries, and people would tell me I'm a thief and oppressor. And in my time here, my kippah was ripped off my head on 5 different occasions, and the Israeli flag that I had in my office was stolen and burnt. Even on Channukah my menorah was taken out of my office and slammed into the ground, breaking something that meant more to me than could have been imagined.

With the recent rise of Anti-Semitism, I wanted to be able to share my experiences, which could go on forever, and share what our community as conservationists and animal lovers can do to protect our friends and supporters from around the world. Here's a small list of what you can do to help people in your workplace whether it's conservation-based or not.
  1. First, understand we are a global community. Every single inch of the Earth and all of her people are included when we talk about conservation, and that includes people we don't agree with, like, or understand. As supporters of conservation, it is our role to embrace our community and support everyone as human beings.
  2. Then, support, defend, and point out wrongs. Many times that these vents above happened did no one do anything to support me. While it may be scary to put yourself out there like that, it is going to mean a lot to the people that you defend and protect.
  3. Finally, embrace them as them. They are not some token, or some charity case. They have earned their spot next to you where it may be, and as a friend and coworker, it is your responsibility to embrace them. If they open up and talk about their culture or traditions, then that means that you have earned their trust and you can now embrace them. Make them feel loved and as though you care about them, through every inch of their person.
It's hard to be different in a field that is still not as diverse as others. It's hard to be a first, and it's hard to pave paths. While I hope these experiences and slight suggestions on how to be better friends to the diverse people we all know helped, I would also love to hear your experiences about Racism and other hatred you have received in zoo-based fields, but also what would have made you feel better. Thank you so much for reading my stories, and please share yours. Also please answer the poll so I could possibly see just how many other people on this website have received hate in the field of conservation. Thank you!
 
I am really sorry to hear about your experiences. I felt sad reading this and knowing that you had to put up with this kind of abuse and disrespect... I want to say that I greatly appreciate and admire your openness and vulnerability. I respect you, I support you and I hope things get better. These people are ignorant and hateful and it is their loss. If they can't appreciate what you contribute, it is their loss. Keep being persistent and keep following your passion.

By the way, with my main interest being ungulates (hence my screen name), I appreciate and relate to your fascination with Mountain gazelles (Gazelle gazella gazella). I am fascinated by the flora and fauna of the Levant in general.

Kind Regards,
UngulateNerd92

PS I hope you enjoy your time on ZooChat, our community welcomes you.
 
I am really sorry to hear about your experiences. I felt sad reading this and knowing that you had to put up with this kind of abuse and disrespect... I want to say that I greatly appreciate and admire your openness and vulnerability. I respect you, I support you and I hope things get better. These people are ignorant and hateful and it is their loss. If they can't appreciate what you contribute, it is their loss. Keep being persistent and keep following your passion.

By the way, with my main interest being ungulates (hence my screen name), I appreciate and relate to your fascination with Mountain gazelles (Gazelle gazella gazella). I am fascinated by the flora and fauna of the Levant in general.

Kind Regards,
UngulateNerd92

PS I hope you enjoy your time on ZooChat, our community welcomes you.
Thank you so much, that truly means a lot. And the animals of the Levant are the best I can agree, while the Gazelle are cool for sure my real favorite is in the vultures of the region. But thank you for kind words it means quite a bit.
 
Thank you so much, that truly means a lot. And the animals of the Levant are the best I can agree, while the Gazelle are cool for sure my real favorite is in the vultures of the region. But thank you for kind words it means quite a bit.

You are welcome. Again, we support you. Vultures are neat too! They definitely play a useful role in their ecosystems. I am familiar with vulture conservation in Israel conducted by the The Israel Nature and Parks Authority. Assuming that you have, where have seen and photohraphed vultures in the wild in Israel, if so, at which localities?
 
You are welcome. Again, we support you. Vultures are neat too! They definitely play a useful role in their ecosystems. I am familiar with vulture conservation in Israel conducted by the The Israel Nature and Parks Authority. Assuming that you have, where have seen and photohraphed vultures in the wild in Israel, if so, at which localities?
Yeah I’ve seen a few! I actually just went to mount Carmel to a feeding restaurant there and photographed a few species. And if you want more Israeli wildlife this locality and a few more are on life feeds on YouTube! And there’s some plans for Lappet faced vultures to be introduced into the Carmel region too, so I can hopefully come photograph them too
 
Yeah I’ve seen a few! I actually just went to mount Carmel to a feeding restaurant there and photographed a few species. And if you want more Israeli wildlife this locality and a few more are on life feeds on YouTube! And there’s some plans for Lappet faced vultures to be introduced into the Carmel region too, so I can hopefully come photograph them too

Watching vulture feeding behavior in action, now that sounds like quite a remarkable experience! How have you been doing since this post? Is everything ok or are things still the same? I wanted to reach out and check in on you.
 
I think one of the big examples of racism in conservation is the way that many northern zoos concentrate on keeping big dangerous animals in the belief that they may be reintroduced into the wild. There would be massive dissent if the northern countries introduced big dangerous animals into their former northern homelands, but it's OK to release big dangerous animals into the third world.
 
On the topic of inequality, this is hard to phrase, but I have noticed that in many countries, city zoos are often located in lower-income neighborhoods populated by marginalized groups. The people who visit the zoo, and the people running the zoo, tend to have a higher social status and privilege than those who live right outside the zoo gates. I wonder how the urban planning came to be, for this to be the trend in many cities around the world? And what programs have city zoos enacted to better serve the communities in their districts? Also, are there studies into if and how zoos benefit local businesses around them?
 
On the topic of inequality, this is hard to phrase, but I have noticed that in many countries, city zoos are often located in lower-income neighborhoods populated by marginalized groups. The people who visit the zoo, and the people running the zoo, tend to have a higher social status and privilege than those who live right outside the zoo gates. I wonder how the urban planning came to be, for this to be the trend in many cities around the world? And what programs have city zoos enacted to better serve the communities in their districts? Also, are there studies into if and how zoos benefit local businesses around them?

That is a very interesting observation... I have noticed this trend from time to time myself... I think this would make for an interesting research project for a graduate student to take on. May I ask which specific zoos you have personally noticed this trend with? One noteworthy example of this is the neighborhood that the Fresno Chaffee Zoo is located in.

Sometimes it is the opposite that is true. For example, Calgary Zoo is located in an upper-middle-class neighborhood in Calgary. Another example of this is that the Detroit Zoo is not located in Detroit proper, nor is it located in the same county as Detroit (Wayne County). Detroit Zoo is located in Royal Oaks, Oakland County, Michigan. Oakland County is an affluent suburban region of the Greater Detroit Metro Area.
 
That is a very interesting observation... I have noticed this trend from time to time myself... I think this would make for an interesting research project for a graduate student to take on. May I ask which specific zoos you have personally noticed this trend with? One noteworthy example of this is the neighborhood that the Fresno Chaffee Zoo is located in.

Sometimes it is the opposite that is true. For example, Calgary Zoo is located in an upper-middle-class neighborhood in Calgary. Another example of this is that the Detroit Zoo is not located in Detroit proper, nor is it located in the same county as Detroit (Wayne County). Detroit Zoo is located in Royal Oaks, Oakland County, Michigan. Oakland County is an affluent suburban region of the Greater Detroit Metro Area.

The WCS parks besides Central Park Zoo, Franklin Park Zoo in Boston, Adventure Aquarium in Camden, NJ, and in Japan, Tennoji Zoo. That said, it’s possible a lot of these neighborhoods have changed over time through gentrification.

A thread, but with some classist and possibly racist language. It seems like they found more counterexamples than examples. Apparently it has been a trend with sports stadiums, though.

Are all of the zoos in the ghetto? (best, better, places) - City vs. City - City-Data Forum

@Sicarius Which zoos in Europe would you say follow this trend?
 
Last edited:
On the topic of inequality, this is hard to phrase, but I have noticed that in many countries, city zoos are often located in lower-income neighborhoods populated by marginalized groups. The people who visit the zoo, and the people running the zoo, tend to have a higher social status and privilege than those who live right outside the zoo gates. I wonder how the urban planning came to be, for this to be the trend in many cities around the world? And what programs have city zoos enacted to better serve the communities in their districts? Also, are there studies into if and how zoos benefit local businesses around them?
Really? Can you give some examples?

I can't say I have noticed that myself in zoos I have visited around the world, and it is not the case here in Australia. Indeed, Australia's most famous zoo, Taronga, is located in Mosman, one of the most expensive suburbs in the country. The problem they have is that people working in the zoo cannot afford to live anywhere near it.

My impression is that most zoos are built in large parks and thus barely impact on surrounding communities, or on greenfield sites.
 
The WCS parks besides Central Park Zoo, Franklin Park Zoo in Boston, Adventure Aquarium in Camden, NJ, and in Japan, Tennoji Zoo. That said, it’s possible a lot of these neighborhoods have changed over time through gentrification.

A thread, but with some classist and possibly racist language. It seems like they found more counterexamples than examples. Apparently it has been a trend with sports stadiums, though.

Are all of the zoos in the ghetto? (best, better, places) - City vs. City - City-Data Forum

@Sicarius Which zoos in Europe would you say follow this trend?
I see you have already have provided examples!

With respect, I think what you are seeing is accidental convergence, that is older zoos tend to be in older parts of cities and therefore more likely to be in an area where the socio-economic situation has changed over the years.
 
I think one of the big examples of racism in conservation is the way that many northern zoos concentrate on keeping big dangerous animals in the belief that they may be reintroduced into the wild. There would be massive dissent if the northern countries introduced big dangerous animals into their former northern homelands, but it's OK to release big dangerous animals into the third world.
You're framing this as a hypothetical, but there is already dissent in the United States about the small reintroduction project for red wolves, and in many states for whether or not to reintroduce gray wolves or treat them as endangered animals, though there seems to be less for Mexican gray wolves in some instances, and it's to be seen if there will be dissent if jaguar reintroduction projects advance... but certainly efforts are being made to introduce big dangerous animals in northern countries to former habitat. You also have instances like the recent introduction to Cheetah to India based on animals from South Africa, which while you could argue about north/south and first/third world, I would say it is definitely outside any racial question.

I don't expect to see many zoos in the United States releasing "big, dangerous animals" like lions, tigers, or bears into the wild in "third world" countries in the future. Many release programs have been less successful than was hoped, and exotic bears are declining in zoos. Lion and tigers are not there for wild conservation purposes as much as popularity with visitors. The idea the end goal of the majority of species in captivity is the eventual return of animals to the wild is already outdated and sustainability is really the word we should be shifting towards, but I understand the reluctance to embrace a narrative that admits to animals spending their lives in captivity when that is very much not what people want to hear right now.

(I am well aware 'northern zoos' is much, much broader than the United States, but that is the limit of my knowledge.)

On the topic of inequality, this is hard to phrase, but I have noticed that in many countries, city zoos are often located in lower-income neighborhoods populated by marginalized groups. The people who visit the zoo, and the people running the zoo, tend to have a higher social status and privilege than those who live right outside the zoo gates. I wonder how the urban planning came to be, for this to be the trend in many cities around the world? And what programs have city zoos enacted to better serve the communities in their districts? Also, are there studies into if and how zoos benefit local businesses around them?
I can only speak to Chicago here. Lincoln Park is considered a very wealthy neighborhood but because it is completely free, there is usually a sizable number of visitors from marginalized communities. It is worth noting that its wealth is a result of recent gentrification, however, and it was once one of the city's poorer neighborhoods. Brookfield is suburban and the zoo, which is not free currently, tends to attract more affluent and privileged visitors today, but Brookfield is not an especially wealthy neighborhood, and the zoo is their main claim to relevance. At the time it was built, however, Brookfield would definitely have been wealthier.
 
On the topic of inequality, this is hard to phrase, but I have noticed that in many countries, city zoos are often located in lower-income neighborhoods populated by marginalized groups. The people who visit the zoo, and the people running the zoo, tend to have a higher social status and privilege than those who live right outside the zoo gates. I wonder how the urban planning came to be, for this to be the trend in many cities around the world? And what programs have city zoos enacted to better serve the communities in their districts? Also, are there studies into if and how zoos benefit local businesses around them?
In France the (few) city zoos are in large urban parks, near wealthy or gentrified areas.
I don't know any current example of zoo in a poor district of a French town.
 
Regardless of zoos’ location, I think what’s most important is that they work hard to be accessible, user-friendly, and understandable to everyone. Discounted tickets and free days, paths accessible to wheelchairs and strollers, quiet zones, and exhibit interpretation in multiple languages are all good and necessary steps. Proximity to affordable public transportation and sufficiently large and affordable parking lots are also very important for accessibility. The communities living closest to the zoo should also benefit from it in some way.

And I’d appreciate it if zoos discussed in signage and programs the history of conservation and past and present racism, inequality, and issues like colonialism.

I wonder if there’s any studies into whether or not neighbors of zoos like or dislike living next to them?
 
Back
Top