Who are you Rothschildi? expert indeed , all you say may be correct..except the issue of Balai in France and the bit about EEP as this is a fully approved EEP move as I have discussed it with there staff. you seem to have missed the point..zoos are not on the earth to follow plans and strategies for captive management..they are an educational tool to ensure and encourage the conservation of the animals in the wild. Zoos that dont have this as their mission should not exist as they become entertainment and will watch as the animals dissapear. So let me reiterate to all the zoo philes on this site... conservation issues should outweigh every other issue in any zoo. Every animal should have a reason for being there and have a educational message to help change the world . South Lakes is a shining light to all other zoos in the way it operates , its missions and its aims and missions. thats why i support it and defend it against uninformed negativisms in the "experts" who probably have never worked in a zoo or ever will. regards
Well, many zoos do appear to be "on the earth to follow plans and strategies for captive management" (see Edinburgh, Red River Hogs, for an example). A large percentage of managed populations are managed to maintain a healthy captive gene pool rather than to directly support conservation projects, many of these species are not threatened in the wild.
I do agree with you that it makes sense for South Lakes to exhibit a group of Peralta giraffe given their work in situ, I believe in captive animals as storytellers for their wild counterparts.
I disagree that conservation should take priority over everything else, animals are great educators in their own right, we in the colonial north are not the saviours of the planet, no matter how much our zoological collections might like to portray us as being, in fact the UK zoo community has only really adopted the model of captive flagship species supporting linked in situ projects in the last 20 years, and this was still largely restricted to charitable zoos until recently.
Also, be a bit careful about generalising when you're angry....'Zoophile' didn't seem like a respectful name to call a diverse bunch of people who use this site (including you), many who work or have worked in zoos. I actually agree with much of your praise for South Lakes, but its not above criticism.