w
what is a green cardinal bird ?And then on to birds....
Well, I promised you all there would be a lot of similar posts about birdy trends in this thread at some point this year. Unfortunately for you, life has caught up with me and due to a combination of factors , I have a lot less time & energy to write and analyze for fun this year. This means it is unlikely there will ever be a continuation in as much details for our feathered friends. But as it has taken me quite a lot of time put together the bird dataset last year, it would be a waste not to write at least a tiny little bit.
So the summary is as follows (based on data up to June 2023): in the period 2000-2023 a total of 2240 bird species were kept in European zoos according to Zootierliste, that is roughly 2.5x the number mammal species kept in the same time period (which stands at 880).
![]()
@Rhino00 The exciting addition of the Brazilian merganser to the European zoo world happened after June 2023, as did the death of Europe's last dwarf cassowary, so these changes aren't included in the numbers
Of those 2240 species 1656-1727 species were most likely present in 2000, and 1499-1510 species were most likely present in 2023, so a decline of 157-228 species. That means there has been roughly a 8.8%-13.2% (mean 11%) decline in the number of bird species kept in those 23 years. The median zoochat expectation was a 13% decline, so not that far off, but likely slightly too pessimistic. This decline can in large part be attributed to a decline in the number of passerines kept, whose number of species kept declined by almost 25% from 536-574 to 409-416. For non-passerines there was only a slight decline from 1119-1152 to 1090-1094 species, so 2%-5.4%. A large number of passerine species was also kept at some point between 2000 and 2023, but not at the start of the century or end of the sampling period, that concerned some 227 species. For non-passerines, only 85 species were present at some point this century but not in 2000 or 2023.
There are a few reasons for the decline and the high volatility of bird holdings. Most important to note is that the majority of bird species kept this century was never very common in captivity, and often incredibly rare, limited to 1-3 holders this century. Small populations are per definition at a high risk of extinction and in many cases that did happen. Especially with passerines there are few rarities that remain rarely kept for a long time without disappearing. Only the few zoos that don't treat these rare birds as expendables and set up a breeding regime (often exchanging animals with private keepers), are able to keep rare passerines for decades. Burgers' Zoo is probably the prime example of this, having good success and often larger numbers of their rare species. Compare this with zoos like Plzen and Walsrode whose rarities often appear and disappear at high pace because they were often only kept in very small numbers. Both Plzen and Walsrode of-course also have their success stories but the number of species they go through is quite staggering if you add it all up and breeding success much more limited when you keep only small numbers of a species.
![]()
@Therabu Burgers' Zoo has multiple breeding pairs of painted bunting and breeds up to two dozen of them per year. Such numbers are needed to keep such small fragile species long term
An important reason for the decline is also the ban on imports of wild birds into the EU that came into effect in 2005. Before that is was very common to see new bird species being imported and being kept in a single/a few zoos for a short period, before disappearing again. With the ban in effect, a sizable number of new species consists of confiscated animals, which in most cases also means they die out within a few years. But the number of species entering zoos is smaller than before. A ban on wild imports also meant zoos couldn't treat birds as expandable items as much as they used to, because there is no infinite supply anymore. There are still far more bird species in private hands than in zoos and many zoos with large bird collections frequently exchange birds with private keepers. But an important source has been gone for nearly 20 years now and especially with passerines this shows.
It is also important to note that bird diversity has throughout the century been driven by some bird parks and 20-30 large zoos. This century has seen the closure of several bird parks (which haven't really been replaced elsewhere), but also the significant decline in the number of bird species kept in some zoos. Both Berlins have seen huge declines (roughly 50%) in species numbers as an example, but many other zoos too. This is not uniform, a zoo like Cologne (but also Plzen) has actually seen their bird collection grow this century. But if diversity is driven by a few places, the closure of a single random bird park can mean the loss of multiple species simultaneously. Imagine if Loro Parque would close, that would mean the loss of dozens of species at once. That is something that wouldn't really happen with mammals. This reliance on a few zoos has made bird species numbers far more susceptible to changes than e.g. mammals.
![]()
@lintworm Bird houses like the new one in Berlin are increasingly rare, whereas large aviaries become the norm
Whereas mammal holdings remained stable because losses in big zoos were counterweighted by the rise of smaller zoos and zoos in e.g. France, this hasn't hasn't happened with birds. There have nevertheless been some winners when it comes to birds. An obvious one are the herons & ibisses, but also birds-of-paradise are now more popular. In general there seems to be a trend towards "fancy" species and species that do well in large (walk-through) aviaries. It also helps tremendously if you get yourself an EEP. From scaly-sided merganser and white-winged wood duck to Sumatran laughing-thrush and green cardinal. Birds with an EEP are ones that gain new holders the fastest. Many zoos hold less bird species than mammals, but as there are far more birds to chose from, a criterion like EEP status becomes important at once.
This is a very short summary of what could have been 100 separate posts, but it was not meant to be.