ZooChat Big Year 2019

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt.


So guys, I'm in a conflict with two animals which I'm hating because I can't identify them.
One is a falcon which I identified for first as a Pallid harrier, then as a Eurasian marsh harrier (which for now is cancelled from the list, but the situation probably will change.This is the last animal I eliminate from my checklists), and now as a Montagu's harrier, the second a gull which maybe was a Gray-headed gull (a rarity here in Italy!).
I think I'll be able to give you news about the bird checklist (60 species) during the next days.
Sorry for the drawback, but I'm soooo bad at identifiyng birds.
It's okay, take your time! Everyone in this thread started somewhere some time, so I'm sure all of us understand. I think the biggest thing to keep in mind is that it's okay to not identify a bird if you didn't see it that well - birds of prey and gulls in Europe are hard if you don't know what to look for, so it's okay if you didn't see enough details to be sure about your sighting - just let it go! Eventually, as you'll get better and better in identification, you'll know exactly what to look for and you'll find it a lot easier to know when to attempt identifying birds and when not to. A good bird guide can help with this, if you don't already own one. I definitely recommend Collins Bird Guide, either the book or the app - it's probably the most detailed (affordable) bird book ever written.

Grey-headed gull is an African bird, and a very, very rare vagrant in Italy, with to my knowledge only a handful of records (3?) in Italy. I'd be surprised if one has been seen in the entirety of Europe this year already, and to my knowledge they haven't been seen in Italy (or indeed the rest of Europe) since December of 2015. That's not to say that you didn't see one - there's a few stories around of beginning birders finding amazing stuff in their first few months of birding, but it should give some perspective as to how rare they actually are. Have you looked at pictures of fairly similar black-headed gulls or Mediterranean gulls, and especially those of birds in transitioning plumage? Those are, in my opinion, much more likely opinions - though of course I can't know what you saw.
 
It's okay, take your time! Everyone in this thread started somewhere some time, so I'm sure all of us understand. I think the biggest thing to keep in mind is that it's okay to not identify a bird if you didn't see it that well - birds of prey and gulls in Europe are hard if you don't know what to look for, so it's okay if you didn't see enough details to be sure about your sighting - just let it go! Eventually, as you'll get better and better in identification, you'll know exactly what to look for and you'll find it a lot easier to know when to attempt identifying birds and when not to. A good bird guide can help with this, if you don't already own one. I definitely recommend Collins Bird Guide, either the book or the app - it's probably the most detailed (affordable) bird book ever written.

Grey-headed gull is an African bird, and a very, very rare vagrant in Italy, with to my knowledge only a handful of records (3?) in Italy. I'd be surprised if one has been seen in the entirety of Europe this year already, and to my knowledge they haven't been seen in Italy (or indeed the rest of Europe) since December of 2015. That's not to say that you didn't see one - there's a few stories around of beginning birders finding amazing stuff in their first few months of birding, but it should give some perspective as to how rare they actually are. Have you looked at pictures of fairly similar black-headed gulls or Mediterranean gulls, and especially those of birds in transitioning plumage? Those are, in my opinion, much more likely opinions - though of course I can't know what you saw.

Thank you for the advices!
I have a small guide at home, but now I use the Collin Laboratory app for the birds of the Western Palearctic
So, I know the GHG is very rare, but I don't think the bird I saw was a Mediterranean because it had different "eyes".
This thing annoyed me sooo much.
 
Just arrived in Monterey, CA.

283. Green heron Butorides virescens
284. American white pelican Pelecanus erythrorhynchos
285. Pied-billed grebe Podilymbus podiceps
 
After mant recent misidentifications, I've decided to show you the "updated" checklists, with all the species I've identified correctly this year (lifers included and signed).


Birds

1. Hooded crow - Corvus cornix

2. House sparrow - Passer domesticus

3. Eurasian jackdaw - Corvus monedula

4. Italian sparrow - Passer italiae

5. Yellow-legged gull - Larus michahellis

6. Common moorhen - Gallinula chloropus

7. White stork - Ciconia ciconia

8. Common buzzard - Buteo buteo

9. Eurasian collared dove - Streptopelia
decaocto

10. White wagtail - Motacilla alba

11. Common blackbird - Turdus merula

12. Alpine cough - Pyrrhocorax graculus

13. Rose-ringed parakeet * - Psittacula krameri

14. Common starling - Sturnus vulgaris

15. Barn swallow - Hirundo rustica

16. Common woodpigeon - Columba palumbus

17. Canada goose * - Branta canadensis

18. Common magpie - Pica pica

19. Carrion crow - Corvus corone

20. Herring gull - Larus argentatus

21. Tufted duck - Aythya fuligula

22. Black-headed gull - Chroicocephalus ridibundus

23. Eurasian coot - Fulica atra

24. Mute swan - * Cygnus olor

25. Egyptian goose * - Alopochen aegyptiaca

26. Common robin - Erithacus rubecula

27. Great-crested grebe - Podiceps cristatus

28. Grey heron - Ardea cinerea

29. Red-crested pochard - Nettia rufina

30. Great tit - Parus major

31. Great cormorant - Phalacrocorax carbo

32. Common swift - Apus apus

33. Pale crag martin - Ptyonoprogne obsoleta

34. House crow * - Corvus splendens

35. Laughing dove - Spilopelia senegalensis

36. White-eyed gull - Ichthyaetus leucophtalmus

37. Common hoopoe - Upupa epops

38. Rock dove (for real) - Columba livia

39. Hooded wheatear - Oenanthe monaca

40. Western reef egret - Egretta gularis

41. Mangrove heron - Butorides striata

42. Common chaffinch - Fringilla coelebs

43. Black kite - Milvus migrans

44. Common house martin - Delichon urbicum

45. Goldfinch - Carduelis carduelis

46. Kentish plover - Charadrius alexandrinus

47. Common egret - Egretta garzetta

48. Common serin - Serinus serinus

49. Mediterranean gull - Ichthyaetus melanocephalus


50. Eurasian crag martin - Ptyonoprogne rupestris

51. Eurasian jay - Garrulus glandarius

52. Eurasian nuthatch - Sitta europaea

53. European bee-eater - Merops apiaster

54. Peregrine falcon - Falco peregrinus

55. Mistle thrush - Turdus viscivorus

56. Pallid swift - Apus pallidus

I think that's it, for now.

Mammals

1. Red fox- Vulpes vulpes

2. Eastern gray squirrel * - Sciurus carolinensis

3. House mouse - Mus musculus

4. Indopacific bottlenose dolphin - Tursiops aduncus

5. Brown rat (yaaay...) * - Rattus norvegicus

Reptiles

1. Italian wall lizard - Podarcis siculus

2. Common wall lizard - Podarcis muralis

3. Common gecko - Tarentola mauritanica

4. Mediterranean house gecko - Hemidactylus turcicus

5. Western green lizard - Lacerta bilineata

6. Western whip snake - Hierophis viridiflavus

7. Aesculapian snake - Zamenis longissimus

Amphibians

1. Common frog - Rana temporaria

2. European green toad - Bufo viridis

3. Marsh frog - Pelophylax ridibundus




In the next hours, I'm going to add the two last checklists (fishes and invertebrates) and other birds.
 
Last edited:
Most of these are from my trip out into Outback Queensland. Was not going to post this until my finished my awful trip thread but since I’ve lost all motivation for that I decided to just post it.

On a more positive note I’ve surpassed my bird total by last year and seen many great lifers, including animals I’ve been wanting to see my entire life.

The list also starts at 106 as I decided to remove glossy ibis, as I think these were just misidentified straw necked ibis.

Mammals:
6. Red Kangaroo (Macropus rufus)
7. Rufous Bettong (Aepyprymnus rufescens
)
8. Pretty Faced Wallaby (Macropus parryi)
9. European Hare (Lepus europaeus)
10. Humpback Whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
11. Indopacfic Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops aduncus)

Reptiles:
17. Green Sea Turtle (Chelonia mydas)
18. Ragged Snake Eyed Skink (Cryptoblepharus pannosus)

Birds:
106. Banded Plover (Vanellus tricolor)
107. White Winged Chough (Corcorax melanorhamphos)
108. Black Faced Wood Swallow (Artamus cinereus)*
109. Zebra Finch (Taeniopygia guttata)
110. Australian Bustard (Ardeotis australis)
111. Spinifex Pigeon (Geophaps plumifera)
112. Caspian Tern (Hydroprogne caspia)
113. Restless Flycatcher (Myiagra inquieta)
114. Satin Flycatcher (Myiagra cyanoleuca)
115. Red Winged Parrot (Aprosmictus erythropterus)
116. Black Fronted Dotterel (Elseyornis melanops)
117. Brolga (Grus rubicunda)
118. Red Browed Pardolote (Pardalotus rubricatus)
119. Oriental Pratincole (Glareola maldivarum)
120. Spotted Bowerbird (Chlamydera maculata)
121. Cockatiel (Nymphicus hollandicus)
122. Dusky Woodswallow (Artamus cyanopterus
)
123. Eastern Rosella (Platycercus eximius)
124. Striated Pardolote (Pardalotus striatus)
125. Wedge Tailed Eagle (Aquila audax)
126. Mallard Duck (Anas platyrhynchos)
127. Budgerigah (Melopsittacus undulatus)
128. Scarlett Honey Eater (Myzomela sanguinolenta)
129. Green Catbird (Ailuroedus crassirostris)
130. Emu (Dromaius novaehollandiae)

* I know I put this species down on my 2017 big year, however now that I’ve actually seen them I think they were a misidentification of a black faced cuckoo shrike.
Forgotten from my trip:
Birds:
131. White Plumed Honey Eater (Lichenostomus penicillatus)
132. Yellow-Throated Miner (Manorina flavigula)


From Kedron Brook today:
Birds:
132. Australian Reed Warbler (Acrocephalus australis)

Fish:
22. Mozambique Tilpia (Oreochromis mossambicus)
 
Fishes

1. Common sergeant - Abudefduf vaigiensis

2. Yellow damselfish -
Pomacentrus sulfureus (are these the correct names? It's a common fish in Red Sea)

3. Threadfin butterflyfish - Chaetodon auriga

4. Red Sea Eritrean butterflyfish - Chaetodon paucifasciatus

5. Masked butterflyfish - Chaetodon semilarvatus

6. Blacktail butterflyfish - Chaetodon austriacus

7. Diagonal butterflyfish - Chaetodon fasciatus


8. Klunzinger's wrasse - Thalassoma rueppellii

9. Red Sea bird wrasse - Gomphosus varius

10. Cleaner common wrasse - Labroides dimidiatus

11. Masked puffer - Arothron diadematus

12. Blue-spotted stingray - Taeniura lymma

13. Arabian picassofish - Rhinecanthus assasi

14. Bluetail trunkfish - Ostracion cyanurus

15. Sohal surgeonfish - Acanthurus sohal

16. Black surgeonfish - Acanthurus gahhm

17. Red Sea bannerfish - Heniochus intermedius

18. Royal angelfish - Pygoplites diacanthus

19. Bridled parrotfish - Scarus frenatus

20. Rusty parrotfish - Scarus ferrugineus

21. Daisy parrotfish - Chlorurus sordidus

22. Red lionfish - Pterois volitans

23. Blue fusilier - Caesio lunaris

24. Sabre squirrelfish - Sargocentron spiniferum

25. Clown coris - Coris aygula

26. Broomtail wrasse - Cheilinus lunulatus

27. Indian sailfin tang - Zebrasoma desjardinii

28. Red Sea anemonefish - Amphiprion bicinctus

29. Red Sea goatfish - Paropeneus forsskali

30. Chocolatedip chromis - Chromis dimidiatus

31. Red Sea houndfish - Tylosurus choram

32. Brown coral blenny - Atrosalarias fuscus

33. Elegant unicornfish - Naso elegans

34. Grey mullet - Mugil cephalus

35. Big scale sand smelt - Atherina boyeri

36. Mediterranean sand smelt - Atherina hepsetus

37. Saddled seabream - Oblada melanura

38. White seabream - Diplodus sargus

39. Banded seabream - Diplodus fasciatus

40. Sharpsnout seabream - Diplodus puntazzo

41. Cardinalfish - Apogon imperbis

42. Ornate wrasse - Thalassoma pavo

43. Mediterranean rainbow wrasse - Coris julis

44. Painted comber - Serranus scriba

45. Sand steenbras - Lithognathus mormyrus

46. Rusty blenny - Parablennius sanguinolentis

47. Dusky grouper - Epinephelus marginatus

48. Goldblotch grouper - Epinephelus costae

49. Garfish - Belone belone

50. Comber - Serranus cabrilla

51. East Atlantic peacock wrasse - Symphodus tinca

52. Mediterranean moray - Muraena helena

53. Salema porgy - Salpa salpa

54. Red scorpionfish - Scorpaena scrofa

55. Silverfish - Trachinotus ovatus

56. Gray triggerfish - Balistes capriscus

57. Cleaver wrasse - Xyrichtys novacula

58. Brill - Scophtalmus rhombus

There are also other fishes I'm trying to identify.

Birds

57. Mallard - Anas platyrhynchos

58. Common kestrel - Falco tinnunculus
 
Invertebrates

-Butterflies and moths

1. Cabbage white - Pieris rapae

2. Painted lady - Vanessa cardui

3. Holly blue - Celastrina argiolus

4. Clouded yellow - Colias croceus

5. Scarce swallotail - Iphiclides podalirius

6. Pine processionary - Thaumetopoea pityocampa

7. Red admiral - Vanessa atalanta

-Bees, wasps & co.

8. European honeybee - Apis mellifera

9. Violet carpenter bee - Xylocopa violacea

10. European hornet - Vespa crabro

11. Garden bumblebee - Bombus hortorum

-Other insects (& co.)

12. Red wood ant - Formica rufa

13. Black garden ant - Lasius niger

14. Firebug - Pyrrhocoris apterus

15. Cicada - Cicada orni

16. House fly - Musca donestica

17. Lesser house fly - Fannia canicularis

18. Common fruit fly - Drosophila melanogaster

19. Stag beetle - Lucanus tetraodon

20. Mediterranean katydid - Phaneroptera nana

-Arachnids

21. Daddy longlegs spider - Pholcus phalangioides

22. Crab-spider - Thomisus onustus

-
Crustaceans

23. Common pill bug - Armadillidium vulgare

24. Marbled rock crab - Pachygrapsus marmoratus

25. Rockpool shrimp - Palaemon elegans

26. Hermit crab - Clibanarius erythropus

-Other marine invertebrates

27. Beadlet anemone - Actinia equina

28. Snakelocks anemone - Anemonia sulcata

29. Black sea urchin - Arbacia lixula

30. Purple sea urchin - Paracentrotus lividus

31. Mediterranean red sea star - Echinaster sepositus

32. Maxima clam - Tridacna maxima

33. Net fire coral - Millepora dichotoma

(This is the only coral I've identified)

34. Long spined black sea urchin - Diadema setosus

35. Cotton spinner sea cucumber - Holoturia tubulosa

36. Firebearded worm - Hermodice caruncolata

37. Purple-striped jellyfish - Pelagia noctiluca

38. Common octopus - Octopus vulgaris

39. Barrel jellyfish - Rhizostoma pulmo

40. Fried Egg jellyfish - Cotylorhiza tuberculata


For now, these are the checklists, which will be completed in the next days!
 
Last edited:
MAMMALS
26 - Australian Fur Seal (Arctocephalus pusillus)

BIRDS
252 - Indian Yellow-nosed Albatross (Thalassarche carteri)
MAMMALS
27 - Southern Long-nosed Bandicoot (Perameles nasuta)
28 - Western Grey Kangaroo (Macropus fuliginosus)

BIRDS
253 - Yellow-tufted Honeyeater (Lichenostomus melanops)
254 - Fuscous Honeyeater (Ptilotula fusca)
255 - Noisy Friarbird (Philemon corniculatus)
256 - Yellow-plumed Honeyeater (Ptilotula ornata)
257 - Black-chinned Honeyeater (Melithreptus gularis)
258 - Pied Butcherbird (Cracticus nigrogularis)
259 - Blue-faced Honeyeater (Entomyzon cyanotis)
260 - Greater Bluebonnet (Northiella haematogaster)
261 - Chestnut-rumped Thornbill (Acanthizia uropygialis)
-- Brown Songlark (Megalurus cruralis) [heard]
-- Rufous Songlark (Megalurus mathewsi) [heard]
-- Crested Bellbird (Oreoica gutturalis) [heard]
-- Southern Scrub-robin (Drymodes brunneopygia) [heard]
262 - Inland Thornbill (Acanthizia apicalis)
263 - Purple-gaped Honeyeater (Lichenostomus cratitius)
-- Red-lored Whistler (Pachycephala rufogularis) [heard]
-- Shy Heathwren (Hylacola cauta) [heard]

264 - White-fronted Honeyeater (Purnella albifrons)
-- Purple-backed Fairywren (Malurus lamberti) [heard]
265 - Mallee Emuwren (Stipiturus mallee)
266 - Tawny-crowned Honeyeater (Gliciphila melanops)
267 - Jacky Winter (Microeca fascinans)
-- Brown Treecreeper (Climacteris picumnus) [heard]
-- White-browed Babbler (Pomatostomus superciliosis) [heard]
-- Black-eared Cuckoo (Chrysococcyx osculans) [heard]
268 - White-winged Triller (Lalage tricolor)
-- Little Crow (Corvus bennetti) [heard]
269 - Striated Grasswren (Amytornis striatus)

270 - Yellow-throated Miner (Manorina flavigula)
271 - Red-capped Robin (Petroica goodenovii)
272 - Black Falcon (Falco subniger)
273 - Gilbert's Whistler (Pachycephala inornata)

274 - Australian Ringneck Parrot (Barnardius zonarius)
275 - Splendid Fairywren (Malurus splendens
 
Some species I forgot to sign yesterday!

Fishes

59. Tompot blenny - Parablennius gattorugine

Invertebrates

- Butterflies and moths

41. Nine-spotted moth - Amata phegea

42. Hummingbird hawk-moth - Macroglossum stellatarum

- Crustaceans

43. Nimble spray crab * - Percnon gibbesi

- Marine invertebrates

44. Common limpet - Patella vulgata

Birds

The red-crested pochard I've seen this year was a non-native species (it was in Hyde Park, London) but I forgot to sign it with a *
 
Last edited:
Invertebrates

Colias croceus is cancelled from the list and replaced with another species:

4. Cleopatra - Gonepteryx cleopatra

- Crustaceans

45. Fiddler crab - Uca tetragonon
 
Invertebrates

Also Holly blue is cancelled by the butterflies list (so there are 44 species in the invertebrate list)
Now I'm sure all the animals of my checklist are correctly identified.
Finally tomorrow I'll leave for Sicily, where I'm going to do a lot of birdwatching (I hope 10-15 new species), snorkeling (I think I'll be able to include in my list also the Mediterranean parrotfish, which seems it's a novelty for this thread) and also some "insect-watching".

Birds

Some minutes ago I saw one of these beautiful birds from the car, in company of many Eurasian crag martins.
Also, I'm almost sure I saw another one the last week in a colony of Pallid swifts.

59. Alpine swift - Tachymarptis melba


(Yes, my English sucks.)
 
Last edited:
I've had a fanastic seven-day wildlife trip with some friends to the north of the Netherland to once again find birds, in particular coastal waders and terns. We first birded our way towards the tip of Noord-Holland. We then went to the island of Texel for a few days, and on the boat trip we already spotted a Parasitic Jaeger flying among the many terns. At Texel we enjoyed the thousands upon thousands of waders, gulls and ducks. We had surprise sightings of several rarities, but the heavy rain also surprised us. my binoculars got wet and took two days to dry. It can't be great trip without at least some minor complications!

After we had seen the birds of Texel to our satisfaction, we left the island and drove to Friesland. On our way, we went looking for a very rare shrike (see list). In Friesland the Lauwersmeer (meer = lake in Dutch) was our main destination, and it yielded again large numbers of birds, including spectacular hunting Caspian Terns. In the Zuidlaardermeer in Groningen we found White-Tailed Eagles and Wiskered terns, although we had to walk many kilometers in the burning sun to see the latter. The absolute highlight however was in the Fochtelooërveen (veen = bog), which it known for it's breeding population of cranes. At a viewing platform we saw a group at least thirty of them flying at eye-level right in front of us, which was an unforgettable experience. The last day we twitched some rarities (including again a shrike very high on my wishlist!) on our way back the south.

The trip was very succesfull, with 140 species seen and an additional 7 heard. We found all tern species that breed in the Netherlands bar one, and I added many species to my year list, including several lifers!

Birds
219. Stilt Sandpiper, Calidris himantopus

220. Gull-Billed Tern, Gelochelidon nilotica
221. Curlew Sandpiper, Calidris ferruginea
222. Red-Necked Phalarope, Phalaropus lobatus
223. Spotted Redshank, Tringa erythropus
224. Sandwich Tern, Thalaseus sandvicensis
225. Parasitic Jaeger, Stercorarius parasiticus
226. Whimbrel, Numenius phaeopus
227. Bar-Tailed Godwit, Limosa lapponica
228. Red Knot, Calidris canutus
229. Little Tern, Sternula albifrons
230. Bearded Reedling, Panurus biarmicus
231. Purple Heron, Ardea purpurea
000. Pied Crow, Corvus albus*
000. Red-Tailed/Isabelline Shrike, Lanius phoenicuroides/isabellus**

232. Little Stint, Calidris minutus
233. Caspian Tern, Hydroprogne caspia
000. Ross's Goose, Anser rossi*
234. Great Bittern, Botaurus stellaris
235. Whiskered Tern, Chlidonias hybrida
236. Common Crane, Grus grus
237. Water Rail, Rallus aquaticus
238. Woodchat Shrike, Lanius senator
239. Montagu's Harrier, Circus pygargus

Herptiles
11. Marsh Frog, Pelophylax ridibundus


Invertebrates
169. Rusty Tussock Moth, Orgyia antiqua
170. Shuttle-Shaped Dart, Agrotis puta
171. Twenty-Plume Moth, Alucita hexadactyla
172. Compass Jellyfish, Chryoaro hysoscella

173. Small Tortoiseshell, Aglais urticae
174. Dotted Rustic, Rhyancia simulans

* Both the Pied Crow and the Ross's Goose were seen "in the wild" but are unlikely to be real vagrants (escapees probably), so I don't count them. If any of them turns out to be accepted by the authorities I'll count them.
** There is no consensus yet on the identity of this vagrant shrike, although it seems that Red-Tailed is the most likely option, but as far as I know Isabelline is not entirely excluded (maybe @Vision knows more about it). I'll count it as soon as there's any certainty on the matter. It's a lifer anyway!
 
000. Red-Tailed/Isabelline Shrike, Lanius phoenicuroides/isabellus**

** There is no consensus yet on the identity of this vagrant shrike, although it seems that Red-Tailed is the most likely option, but as far as I know Isabelline is not entirely excluded (maybe @Vision knows more about it). I'll count it as soon as there's any certainty on the matter. It's a lifer anyway!
I've obviously not seen the bird in person, but as far as I can read on the dutch birding forums the general consensus is red-tailed shrike, and as far as I can see on pictures I think it does look most like red-tailed shrike as well, which is by far the rarer of two species - but the species pair is always very difficult when the individuals aren't males in breeding plumage, of course! Great birding in the Netherlands, though, everyone in Belgium is pretty jealous of all of the amazing rarities you guys are getting recently! :p

* Both the Pied Crow and the Ross's Goose were seen "in the wild" but are unlikely to be real vagrants (escapees probably), so I don't count them. If any of them turns out to be accepted by the authorities I'll count them.
I have my reservations on the goose as well and wouldn't count that either, but the pied crow definitely seems legit to me... Potentially a ship-assisted bird, but definitely no escapee. The bird is almost certainly the same individual (based on a few missing feathers from a cat attack in the UK) as one seen in 7 places all over the UK coasts last year, which received quite a bit of attention and obviously shows that this bird is quite a wanderer, advocating for its wild nature... As unlikely as it might sound!
 
Last edited:
Nevermind

Fishes

Scophthalmus rhombus is replaced with:

Wide-eyed flounder - Bothus podas

Invertebrates

Echinaster sepositus is replaced with:

Sea star - Ophidiaster ophidianus

Ok, now it's perfect.
 
Last edited:
isent rosse gose a cat c specis in the neterlands i think some guys that did a big year in the western paleartic caunted it as one
 
isent rosse gose a cat c specis in the neterlands i think some guys that did a big year in the western paleartic caunted it as one
I think the Swedish guys in the Big Year WP 2017 team did tick Ross' goose in the Netherlands, yeah, but I think they did so as a category A species (as in, implying it's an actual vagrant) rather than as a category C species (because they definitely aren't established yet in the Netherlands, nor have they ever been). The bird they ticked hasn't been officially accepted by the Dutch authorities yet though, and I'm not sure if it will... I'm sure that if the specific goose they saw ends up getting rejected they'll remove it from their list. They've already retroactively removed another bird they saw that didn't get accepted as well (the pale river martin they saw in Kuwait).

The Netherlands, unlike most of the rest of Europe, has actually accepted quite a few Ross' geese in the past, but since 2014 none have been officially accepted yet so I understand @Mr. Zootycoon doesn't want to officially tick this one yet until it gets officially accepted by the CDNA (the Dutch rarity committee). It's currently quite unpredictable which ones they do accept and which ones they don't, but it being summer definitely won't help its case!
 
Last edited:
Mammals

1. Eastern Grey Kangaroo
2. Brown Hare
3. European Rabbit
4. Common Wallaroo
5. Swamp Wallaby
6. Red-necked Wallaby
7. Fallow Deer
8. Common Wombat

Reptiles

1. Eastern Water Skink
2. Tree Skink
3. Eastern Bearded Dragon
4. Red-bellied Black Snake

Birds

1. Pacific Black Duck
2. Grey Teal
3. Hardhead
4. Spotted Dove
5. Crested Pigeon
6. Eurasian Coot
7. Australasian Swamphen
8. Silver Gull
9. White-faced Heron
10. Australian White Ibis
11. Laughing Kookaburra
12. Nankeen Kestrel
13. Galah
14. Sulphur-crested Cockatoo
15. Little Lorikeet
16. Superb Fairywren
17. Red Wattlebird
18. Black-faced Cuckooshrike
19. Magpie-lark
20. Golden-headed Cisticola
21. Australian Reed Warbler
22. Common Starling
23. Common Blackbird
24. Red-browed Finch
25. House Sparrow
26. Australian Wood Duck
27. Australasian Grebe
28. Ducky Moorhen
29. Crimson Rosella
30. Rainbow Lorikeet
31. Eastern Spinebill
32. White-plumed Honeyeater
33. Brown Thornbill
34. Striated Thornbill
35. Australian Magpie
36. Willie Wagtail
37. Welcome Swallow
38. Silvereye
39. Masked Lapwing
40. Yellow-faced Honeyeater
41. White-browed Scrubwren
42. Grey Fantail
43. Freckled Duck
44. Black Swan
45. Australasian Shoveller
46. Pink-eared Duck
47. Musk Duck
48. Great Crested Grebe
49. Pied Stilt
50. Red-kneed Dotterel
51. Black-fronted Dotterel
52. Latham's Snipe
53. Australasian Darter
54. Little Pied Cormorant
55. Little Black Cormorant
56. Australian Pelican
57. Dusky Woodswallow
58. Great Cormorant
59. White-necked Heron
60. Superb Parrot
61. Eastern Rosella
62. Red-rumped Parrot
63. Noisy Miner
64. Grey Shrikethrush
65. Hoary-headed Grebe
66. Yellow-billed Spoonbill
67. Black Kite
68. Straw-necked Ibis
69. Pied Currawong
70. Pacific Koel
71. Muck Lorikeet
72. Noisy Friarbird
73. White-winged Chough
74. Brown Songlark
75. Dollarbird
76. European Goldfinch
77. White-browed Woodswallow
78. Common Myna
79. Sacred Kingfisher
80. Little Corella
81. Buff-rumped Thornbill
82. Grey Butcherbird
83. Pied Butcherbird
84. Little Raven
85. Fairy Martin
86. Diamond Firetail
87. Wedge-tailed Eagle
88. Zebra Finch
89. Shining Bronze-Cuckoo
90. Australian Pied Oystercatcher
91. Pacific Golden-Plover
92. Red-capped Plover
93. Little Tern
94. Common Tern
95. Crested Tern
96. Black-shouldered Kite
97. Rainbow Bee-eater
98. Little Wattlebird
99. Australasian Figbird
100. Australasian Pipit
101. Bar-shouldered Dove
102. Azure Kingfisher
103. Green Catbird
104. Regent Bowerbird
105. Variegated Fairywren
106. Lewin's Honeyeater
107. Yellow Thornbill
108. Brown Gerygone
109. Eastern Whipbird
110. Eastern Yellow Robin
111. Yellow-tailed Black-Cockatoo
112. Yellow-throated Scrubwren
113. Large-billed Scrubwren
114. Satin Bowerbird
115. Brown Quail
116. Scaly-breasted Lorikeet
117. White-throated Treecreeper
118. Brown Honeyeater
119. Olive-backed Honeyeater
120. Greater Sand-Plover
121. Double-banded Plover
122. Eastern Curlew
123. Bar-tailed Godwit
124. Red-necked Stint
125. Sanderling
126. Osprey
127. Noisy Pitta
128. White-throated Needletail
129. Collared Sparrowhawk
130. White-throated Gerygone
131. Rufous Whistler
132. Australian Raven
133. Little Eagle
134. Emu
135. Spiny-cheeked Honeyeater
136. Little Friarbird
137. Yellow-rumped Thornbill
138. Apostlebird
139. Brown Goshawk
140. Spotted Pardalote
141. Peregrine Falcon
142. Rock Dove
143. Torresian Crow
144. Chestnut Teal
145. Buff-banded Rail
146. Sharp-tailed Sandpiper
147. Great Egret
148. Cattle Egret
149. Royal Spoonbill
150. Striped Honeyeater
151. Mangrove Gerygone
152. Pacific Swift

153. Eastern Reef Egret
154. White-cheeked Honeyeater
155. Spangled Drongo
156. Spectacled Monarch
157. Pied Cormorant
158. White-headed Pigeon
159. Tawny Grassbird
160. Brolga
161. Wonga Pigeon
162. Wompoo Fruit-Dove
163. Superb Lyrebird
164. Common Bronzewing
165. White-naped Honeyeater
166. Varied Sittella
167. Blue-faced Honeyeater
168. Striated Pardalote
169. Scarlet Robin
170. Grey Currawong
171. Australian King-Parrot
172. Yellow-tufted Honeyeater
173. Fuscous Honeyeater
174. Brown-headed Honeyeater
175. Golden Whistler
176. Whistling Kite
177. White-winged Triller
178. Peaceful Dove
179. Turquoise Parrot
180. Greater Bluebonnet
181. Brown Treecreeper
182. Speckled Warbler
183. Grey-crowned Babbler
184. White-browed Babbler
185. Restless Flycatcher
186. Jacky Winter
187. Hooded Robin
188. Double-barred Finch
189. Purple-backed Fairywren
190. Inland Thornbill
191. Southern Whiteface
192. Red-capped Robin
193. White-eared Honeyeater
194. Red-whiskered Bulbul
195. Barn Owl
196. Painted Buttonquail
197. Spotted Quail-thrush
198. Red-browed Treecreeper
199. Bell Miner
200. New Holland Honeyeater
201. Rockwarbler
202. Gang-gang Cockatoo
203. Swamp Harrier
204. Little Grassbird
205. Chestnut-breasted Mannikin
206. Swift Parrot
207. Spotted Harrier
 
Last saturday I went on a 12 hour whale watching trip with Monterey Bay Whale Watch. Most people take a three or four hour whale watching tour, with any of several companies at Monterey. MBWW certainly play in that market too, but several times a year they will run an all day tour. Spaces are limited - there were only 12 paying customers, 5 crew of whom three were marine biologists, including the owner, and a professional photographer who was there for his own photos but willing to talk about any aspect of whale photography. The woman in the office described this tour as "nerdy" and I think it must be run as much for the interest of the owner because they could not have made much money from it. Also included are some animals seen around town.

Mammals

27. Western grey squirrel Sciurus griseus
28. Sea otter Enhydra lutris
29. Northern elephant seal Mirounga angustirostris
30. Harbour seal Phoca vitulina
31. Californian sea lion Zalophus californianus
32, Mule deer Odocoileus hemionus
33, Risso's dolphin Grampus griseus
34. Dall's porpoise Phocoenoides dalli
35. Humpback Whale Megaptera novaeangliae

Birds

286. Brandt's cormorant Phalacrocorax penicillatus
287. Black-crowned night heron Nycticorax nycticorax
288, Black turnstone Arenaria melanocephala
289. Red-necked phalarope Phalaropus lobatus
290. Heermann's gull Larus heermanni
291. Arctic tern Sterna paradisaea
292. Elegant tern Thalasseus elegans
293. Sabine's gull Xema sabini
294. Parasitic jaeger Stercorarius parasiticus
295. Pigeon guillimot Cepphus columba
296. Rhinoceros auklet Cerorhinca monocerata
297. Common murre Uria aalge
298. Buller's shearwater Ardenna bulleri
299. Pink-footed shearwater Ardenna creatopus
300. Sooty shearwater Ardenna grisea
301. Black-footed albatross Phoebastria nigripes
302. Belted kingfisher Megaceryle alcyon
303, California scrub-jay Aphelocoma californica

Also a correction, I mistook immature brown pelicans for white pelicans:
284. Brown pelican Pelecanus occidentalis

Fish

9. Ocean sunfish Mola mola

Invertebrates

3. Pacific sea nettle (Jellyfish) Chrysaora fuscescens
 
Great birding in the Netherlands, though, everyone in Belgium is pretty jealous of all of the amazing rarities you guys are getting recently! :p

Thanks, we had a really good trip! Usually I'm not a real twitcher but when you're only a few minutes away from a rarity it can be hard to resist. However, my top sightings are from birds we actually found ourselves (jaeger, purple heron, cranes) and not those found by others.

I have my reservations on the goose as well and wouldn't count that either, but the pied crow definitely seems legit to me... Potentially a ship-assisted bird, but definitely no escapee.

Why can't the Pied Crow be an escapee? Crows are smart, maybe this one escaped and figured out how to stay alive in the wild. I'm not saying it is an escapee, but given that it is not a very rare bird in aviculture and it's so far removed from its regular distribution I still think I could be one.

The Netherlands, unlike most of the rest of Europe, has actually accepted quite a few Ross' geese in the past, but since 2014 none have been officially accepted yet so I understand @Mr. Zootycoon doesn't want to officially tick this one yet until it gets officially accepted by the CDNA (the Dutch rarity committee). It's currently quite unpredictable which ones they do accept and which ones they don't, but it being summer definitely won't help its case!

The current method, as far as I understand, is that a bird will be accepted if no traces of captivity can be discovered. Given that genuine wild Snow Geese are known from the Netherland and populations of Ross's Goose are expanding, it is not entirely impossible for actual vagrants to show up. However, the increase in captive populations at the same time make it more likely that escapees show up. I won't count this goose, at least not for now, but it was a cool sighting anyway.
 
Back
Top