Best UK Sea Lion enclosure

Best UK Sea Lion enclosure?

  • Banham

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • WMSP

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Whipsnade

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Flamingo Land

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Belfast

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dudley

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    50
  • Poll closed .
From my understanding, which is based on a conversation with a keeper over a year ago... it's more the lack of salt water, rather than the fresh water actually doing anything negative. Obviously, a chemical imbalance can cause issues, but that's somewhat separate from the "fresh water" side of things, as salt water is also treated.

Thanks - that certainly feels more logical.
 
From my understanding, which is based on a conversation with a keeper over a year ago... it's more the lack of salt water, rather than the fresh water actually doing anything negative. Obviously, a chemical imbalance can cause issues, but that's somewhat separate from the "fresh water" side of things, as salt water is also treated.

Thanks - that certainly feels more logical.

I imagine the fact that detrimental algae and fungal blooms would potentially be inhibited by salinity would have a bearing on the matter, too.
 
I think that if you're looking for an overall winner, it has to be Blackpool for a number of reasons: -
  • The whole pool is salt water, promoting good health of the species.
  • I can personally vouch for the great care provided, and the fantastic training that they receive (that is NOT me saying that this isn't the case for other collections).
  • They have the largest group in the UK, 2.7. individuals, with consistent breeding.
  • It is the largest artificial pool in the UK.
  • The viewing opportunities of the exhibit are great - with a nice arena and viewing windows either side.
Still my first choice, with Colchester second.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TNT
Precisely, so it is not the presence of a tunnel that is the issue per se :) which is the implication I got from Zia's post.

And yes, that is more or less the story I heard too.

It is the presence of that particular tunnel that is the issue due to its structural limitations. You have incorrectly extrapolated that to all underwater viewing tunnels which is not at all what I said at all.
 
Out of interest, when did sealions finally leave London Zoo? I’m assuming it was for cost reasons, or was it always the intention that they’d take the place of Whipsnade’s dolphins?
 
Still can't believe I went to Whipsnade as a youngster and they had 3 dolphins in that enclosure, sorry a bit off topic but adding a beach area does not condone the enclosure for sealions. Blackpool a winner.
 
Out of interest, when did sealions finally leave London Zoo?
London Zoo stopped keeping California sea lions in 1992.

However, twenty years later, in 2012, the species returned to Regent's Park, for a short time, as the Whipsnade sea lions were temporarily housed there whilst their accommodation at Whipsnade was renovated.
 
Giving my vote to Colchester on this one, though it pains me to not vote for Longleat. Along with Blackpool, Belfast looks very nice from the photo.. is it as nice in person?
 
Still can't believe I went to Whipsnade as a youngster and they had 3 dolphins in that enclosure, sorry a bit off topic but adding a beach area does not condone the enclosure for sealions. Blackpool a winner.
While I agree about Whipsnade's dolphins, there were quite a few smaller dolphin pools in the UK when it was built and I don't think any were as well designed (or probably as well equipped). Times have changed for the better now of course.
 
Out of interest, when did sealions finally leave London Zoo? I’m assuming it was for cost reasons, or was it always the intention that they’d take the place of Whipsnade’s dolphins?

I believe one reason they left London was because they didn't fit their new (at the time) 'Conservation in Action' policy of focusing on endangered species. Whether replacing the Dolphins at Whipsnade was coincidental or deliberate or how much that counted in the decision I don't know but I think that no longer fitting the bill in the new 'conservation policy' aspect was the main one highlighted for their departure. Not sure whether the state of repair of the London pool may also have been a contributory factor.
 
I believe one reason they left London was because they didn't fit their new (at the time) 'Conservation in Action' policy of focusing on endangered species. Whether replacing the Dolphins at Whipsnade was coincidental or deliberate or how much that counted in the decision I don't know but I think that no longer fitting the bill in the new 'conservation policy' aspect was the main one highlighted for their departure. Not sure whether the state of repair of the London pool may also have been a contributory factor.
If it needed repair, there wasn't much money available then so it may have contributed.
 
How deep is Blackpool's enclosure? I'm voting Colchester for underwater appeal and it is deep and relatively dark. Shout out to Banham, as they painted their pool a darker colour and fitted a tarp structure to reduce the glare, apparently reducing the risk of sight issues for the sea lions.

Is the sun in that part of Norfolk so much stronger than in California?
 
Is the sun in that part of Norfolk so much stronger than in California?

I imagine it has more to do with the bright blue pool lining than the sun itself. It would be rather effective at reflecting UV energy back at them as they swim and dive. Ocean floor not so much. I would think they'd also have more reason to look skyward than your average wild sealion - during training / feeding for instance.
 
Score update. Colchester currently have a healthy 7 vote lead over Blackpool. It would appear the presence of the underwater viewing tunnel which has swung the vote in Colchester's favour at the moment. This is the best category we have had so far in terms of votes gained for both Colchester and Blackpool.
 
Nobody has mentioned it yet, but Blackpool's enclosure was originally designed for dolphins. That never eventuated but explains why it is a good size for the sealions. Can build up a bit of speed when they want too. Not seen it but I thought Belfast's looked nice too.
Salt tablets are usually given in the feed when kept in freshwater pools, so I suspect the issue with eye problems is the fresh water rather than the pale colour.
 
Score update. Colchester currently have a healthy 7 vote lead over Blackpool. It would appear the presence of the underwater viewing tunnel which has swung the vote in Colchester's favour at the moment. This is the best category we have had so far in terms of votes gained for both Colchester and Blackpool.
Not that it compares but Bristol also has underwater viewing.
 
Back
Top