With things getting back to a sense of normality and with films finally being released then I thought it was time to resurrect the movie thread. First new film of the year for me was (surprising nobody) Black Widow, which I rented from Disney+ rather than going to the cinema. Not sure if that impacted my enjoyment of the movie or not but I thought the film was generally pretty meh for an MCU property, especially being released in between the final two episodes of Loki which is a bonafide masterpiece.
There were some really good bits of action in there, some great acting, but in the finest traditions of the MCU there is also a lot of quickly edited action scenes and dodgy accents. The humour isn't overdone in this which is a common complaint in most Marvel properties, but the stakes are meaningless because we've all seen Infinity War and Endgame by this point so there could have been a lot more levity.
Things I liked - Scarlett Johansson and Florence Pugh sell their relationship from the start, David Harbour is amazing as Red Guardian, Rachel Weisz (my teenage crush) has aged like a fine wine, and it's always great to see Ray Winstone chewing the scenery. Good to see General Ross back as well, even if it is only for one scene. Post-credit scene is great as well, looking forward to what it sets up going forward. Finally Taskmaster is a standard Marvel villain, not a patch on the comics version mind, but the changes they've made work for the story.
Things I didn't like - The the story is very similar in places to Winter Soldier with some of the same story beats. Granted I only picked up on that on the second watch but now I can't get over the similarities. Ray Winstone's accent is BAD and David Harbour's is very heavy to the point of stereotyping, Florence Pugh's is pretty damn good though. There's some very on the nose imagery in the flashback opening, the actual definition of heavy handed. And the Taskmaster reveal is telegraphed a mile off, a proper "Chekov's Gun" moment is provided very early on in the movie and you'd have to be deaf, dumb and blind not to pick up on it... (no offence to anyone who didn't notice!)
I'll give this movie a rather average 6/10 but I feel it really suffers by being released now, rather than say 4 years ago when it would have been relevant.
I watched Black Widow a couple of months ago in a hotel. I liked it, on the whole, although there were bits I took issue with.I haven't seen it, which I know surprises you, but I've seen various clips and I really like the scenes I've seen with Yelena. She seems much more interesting and fun as a character than Natasha does. On the other hand, while I like Olga Kurylenko and Rachel Weisz, the clips I've seen with them make them seem extremely uninteresting.
The best part was, obviously, Yelena. Her character just stole the whole movie - she needs her own one, and I'd probably even go to the cinema to watch it.
The Red Guardian was also fun - I did have a moment of "why is his English so broken when he was previously undercover as an American dad?" but then I decided that after several decades of being in a Russian prison he wouldn't be so used to English any more, so I could let it slide. His rapport with Yelena was also solidly done.
There were quite a few things I didn't like. Taskmaster was awful, and as @Brum says, it was very clearly signposted as to who was under the mask (for a start, Olga Kurylenko was prominently named as being in the movie, and wasn't for most of it, so it had to be her as the "dead" daughter). That line of "the one resource the world has too much of - girls" was just the terrible topping on a terrible ham-fisted plot message. The complete indestructability of Black Widow was impossible to ignore.
There are a bunch of other plot holes and inconsistencies, but generally speaking it was a fun movie to watch.