The Hobbit: the Desolation Of Smaug
So it must be a year since the first Hobbit movie? I haven't seen it since it was in the theatres so I can't compare it directly to the second part. I liked this installment, although it did sort of drag a bit. No singing either (except the end song over the credits – by Ed Sheeran!? What?). There was some rather ropey CGI: I mean there was some great CGI but also some very bad CGI as well. Some scenes may as well have been cartoons for all the live elements in them (i.e. none!). Fortunately Smaug was well done, and they must have spent most of their CGI budget on the fire-breathing because that looked fantastic. There was not as much juvenile and innapropriate humour as in the first Hobbit so someone must have reigned Peter Jackson in on that. The best humour came from Martin Freeman (Bilbo) who does his role extremely well. The New Zealand scenery was not used to the best advantage. There were parts with great scenic shots but often it was overlain with a lot of CGI elements, or was even entirely CGI. I'm not sure how others will view that but as a Nzer who is used to what it really looks like, a lot of it is obviously and poorly faked which is a shame because I feel like what really made The Lord Of The Rings movies work was the (mostly real) scenery.
Gandalf is in it of course, looking even older than ever. Legolas is back for no good reason other than the ladies like him, and he is also looking older (do Elves age backwards like wizards do?). Nobody's favourite wizard Radagast returns with his god-damn rabbit sled – does Peter Jackson not read public opinion or does he just have George Lucas style “Jar Jar Binks Blindness”? Speaking of Peter Jackson, he is the very first character seen in the movie. Then there's, um, Stephen Fry....? Okay.
Best character is sexy lady Elf, Tauriel, played by Evangeline Lilly. I never particularly liked her as Kate on Lost, or in anything else she's been in really, but she makes a damn fine lady Elf!!
Verdict: not fantastic, not bland, somewhere in the middle. Say 7 out of 10.
Last minute thought: isn't Thorin the head dwarf just really boring? I'm not sure if it's the character or the actor or what, but he's not the best.