I’m lucky enough to have seen one, but why are African forest elephants so rare in captivity? There are no breeding programs for them, and their wild habitat has significantly shrunken in the past 15 years. Are there restrictions on their export? The one I saw in Japan was exported from Burkina Faso in the ‘90s.
On a kinda related note, why are some of the more endangered giraffe subspecies so rare or absent in zoos? Are they also restricted from being exported to other continents?
Most elephants that live in European zoos today go back to animals obtained before CITES agreement came into force in year 1975. We have some newer steppe Africans sourced from culling actions in 90s or from imports by countries that signed CITES later (typical for Eastern Europe), however recently such imports into most of Europe or America are veeeeeery rare or non-exitent. Due to new legislation and also due to stronger backlash of general population, that it´is impossible to import Forest Elephants.
Forest Elephants are not captive bred in Western Africa nor are they legally harvested, so it´s basically impossible to obtain them legally under CITES. Few real or teorethical imports done by shaddy countries akin to China or Cuba or through diplomatic gifts (Japan) will never be numerous enough to start any resembly of sustainable captive population. European (and American) zoos know about it so they never attempt to start such zoo population in current age. It is sad because I think they would be much more suitable for zoo life than steppe elephants. But to stay realistic, it will never happen.
Giraffes are similar example, however it´s not CITES that stops imports, but rather very restrictive animal health laws that are valid in most of Europe and America. Giraffes are ruminants and share a large pallete of pathogens with domestic stock like cows, sheep or horses. It is basically impossible to import them into EU/USA, import permit is impossible to obtain, that is considered too dangerous for farm/agricultural industry by each and every goverment. Only allowed african country of origin is SAR, although still very expensive for export and quarantine. However the South African giraffe subspecies is rather abundand in nature, kept in large numbers in managed parks in SAR, so no need to start ex-situ breeding population.
You can ask why Europe breeds mainly Rotschilds and Reticulate giraffes today, with few Cordofans and tiny Angolans. Answer is pure luck and logistic nets of famous animal dealers of the past. You have to look back in time. Animals imported before WWII came to Europe in many ways, captured and sold by different animals handlers as individuals for high prices, sourced depending where was friendly land to catch them and convenient port to ship them from Africa. Zoos at that time were elated to breed a young or two, zoo mortality was sky high and nobody was interested if two subspecies were bred together, only surviving calf mattered. Today zoo population goes maily to post WWII imports up to 70s when both CITES and modern animal health protection laws were step by step implemented and then imports dried up. Some zoos obtained these late imports with clear wild origin or F1 and started pure subspecies herds. They didn´t look what subspecies were going to be the most endangered in year 2020, they didn´t coordinate between themselves, no zoo associations existed or were just old boy clubs. Zoo directors bought what was avalable at market at those times in larger quantities and that was pure luck.