johnstoni
Well-Known Member
Yes I'd be interested to see any anecdotal evidence of male elephants being culled at birth, I really don't believe any institution would risk the publicity. There are parks in Europe holding specifically bachelor groups, two chester-born bulls went to belgium, and two Rotterdam-born bulls that arrived as calves at Port Lympne went to a safari park in Spain.
I think the humane issue you were disagreeing with is down to how an animal is euthanased. It's not a case of a wasted carcass when animals are euthanased by injection.....they are contaminated with the medicine used to put them to sleep and cannot be fed to carnivores. That's where the ethical question comes up. Furthermore, there is a qualitative difference in taking a tractable, domestic animal to slaughter and doing the same to a kudu or deer. It's one thing for a deer farm in New Zealand or antelope ranch in South Africa to make that choice, but for a British zoological collection reliant to a large extent on gate revenue, I think it would be a difficult decision to justify. Th
I think the humane issue you were disagreeing with is down to how an animal is euthanased. It's not a case of a wasted carcass when animals are euthanased by injection.....they are contaminated with the medicine used to put them to sleep and cannot be fed to carnivores. That's where the ethical question comes up. Furthermore, there is a qualitative difference in taking a tractable, domestic animal to slaughter and doing the same to a kudu or deer. It's one thing for a deer farm in New Zealand or antelope ranch in South Africa to make that choice, but for a British zoological collection reliant to a large extent on gate revenue, I think it would be a difficult decision to justify. Th