cloning...
unfortunately zooboy, whilst its nice to say that the millions spent on cloning an extinct animal would be better spend saving another in danger - and whilst there is indeed much truth to this, thats not how the world works. indeed it would be the right theing to do if we all gave a little more of our GDP to obliterating poverty or nice if we looked at habitat destruvtion in 3rd world countries not as their problem, but as everyones. the fact is that its highly unlikely that the money that would and has been financing the thylacine project would have been spent on conservation of any other species had the project not existed. its the very fact that the thylacine is extinct - that created the interest and funds to try and bring it back.
i'm not saying it necessarily right - just the way it is.
my personal beliefs are that, whilst genetic engeneering and cloning offer the world a plethora of environmental benifits, they do so at the risk of others. essentially i think the genetics/cloning boom is a little out of control and is moving too fast for us to respond appropriately. people are patenting lifeforms like crazy - something that potentially puts us in a very dangerous and disturbing position in the future. there is a man trying desperately to thus place a patent on all chimeras (thats any two lifeforms spliced together) not so he can create and own them, but so others cant! whilst he may be doing it ffor the responsible reasons it demonstrates just how vulnerable we are to this very real and distubing future where animals, indeed, life, has become a commercially owned product.
yuk!
so far virtually all cloning of species has been very much for commercial reasons, not conservation. somewhere in the UK they cloned a guar - the project beat up as conservation initiative. this is rediculous since we all know the situation with gaurs, both in the wild and in zoos, is knowhere near at the stage where cloning is required (keep in mind that cloned animals are genrally always unhealthy and carry mitochondrial DNA of their host-egg - in this case a different species, the domestic cow). san diego cloned a banteng, not even a wild banteng either but, like australia's animals one decended from a domesticated strain. the national zoo talked of cloning their long-dead pandas and using black bears as hosts - was this because the genetic pool of pandas desperately needs new blood or because it is potentially cheaper in the long-run to clone their dead pandas than spend 10 million to rent them for a decade - and still not own them or any of their offspring!
no, the truth is that to date there has been no beneficial cloning of endangered species that i know of at all.
but what if the species was already extinct? what if we raised recently-dead animals, animals extinct at the hands of humans like thylacines, yangtze dolphins or dodos? what then about cloning to recover animals that died longer ago, but arguably at the hands of humans, like mammoths or wooly rhino? what about cloning to save a species or suspecies not yet extinct but in desperate need of new blood like the south china tiger or some obscure hawaiian bird?
whilst talk of jurassic park has in many cases given many poeple a false sense of security about the prospect of species going extinct i believe the technology, as dangerous as it can be - can be used responsibly. i for one would love to see a restored tasmanian wilderness with its top predator back in place. i can imagine the attention and funding such a project could gather could spurr a huge amount of attention/protection into tasmanian forests - but at the same time it could very much go the other way, being already extinct once, i can imagine it swinging the other way, with little interest in reintroducing an incredably expensive, alreadt extinct animal that has absolutely massive commercial potential in a zoo...
like anything to do with the issue it can swing both ways, its up to the intentions of people that dictate with me whether or not it is moralistic.
little cloned Qi Qi's doing tricks in an hong kong aquarium for $500 a ticket? no thanks!
a genetically varied pod of cloned dolphins spurring an interest in cleaning up stretches of the yangtze and protecting the endemic porpoises - hey, if it gets the job done...